Broadway has long been the heartbeat of musical theatre, a dazzling world where stories come to life through powerful voices and unforgettable performances. Over the years, countless stars have graced the stage, but only a select few have reached legendary status. The best Broadway singers possess a rare combination of vocal prowess, emotional depth, and the ability to command an audience with every note they sing. They are the voices that have transcended the footlights, making us laugh, cry, and believe in the magic of live performance.
From the golden age of Broadway to modern-day smash hits, these artists have left an indelible mark on theatre history. Whether belting out show-stopping numbers or delivering heart-wrenching ballads, these singers have captured the essence of storytelling through song, shaping the very fabric of musical theatre.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—those whose voices have become synonymous with the stage. These performers have not only defined iconic roles but have also raised the bar for what it means to be a Broadway star. So, take your seat, dim the lights, and prepare to be amazed by the greatest voices that have ever graced the Great White Way!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is celebrated as one of Broadway’s true icons, a powerhouse who brought a new standard of vocal projection and showmanship to the stage. Known for her bold, brassy voice and a personality to match, Merman defined the Broadway style with her dynamic presence. She starred in numerous unforgettable roles, including the sharp-shooting Annie Oakley in Annie Get Your Gun and the ambitious Mama Rose in Gypsy. These roles were more than just parts for Merman; they became benchmarks for how musical theatre could blend personality with musicality. What set Merman apart was her ability to belt songs with unwavering clarity and power—something few performers could match, especially without amplification. Her iconic performance of “There’s No Business Like Show Business” essentially became Broadway’s anthem, symbolizing the resilience and vibrancy of the stage world. Even today, her legacy shines as a symbol of musical theatre’s golden era, inspiring new generations of performers who look to capture just a fraction of her unmatched spirit.
2. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews’ voice has often been described as pure magic, a crystal-clear soprano that can soothe and captivate audiences with remarkable grace. She burst onto the Broadway scene with her portrayal of Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady, a performance that many still regard as definitive despite her absence in the film adaptation. Andrews brought elegance, humor, and a vocal finesse to the stage that few could rival. She further dazzled audiences with her portrayal of Queen Guinevere in Camelot, showing a depth and versatility that solidified her place in theatre royalty. Andrews’ transition to film in The Sound of Music and Mary Poppins only expanded her legacy, helping her become one of the most beloved performers worldwide. Her voice, which effortlessly reaches soaring highs and tender lows, has enchanted audiences for generations and continues to be celebrated as a benchmark of vocal artistry and emotional warmth.
3. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is a Broadway mainstay, recognized for her stunning ability to bring both humor and emotional depth to her roles. With over five decades in show business, Peters has left a mark on Broadway in iconic roles like Dot in Sunday in the Park with George, the Baker’s Wife in Into the Woods, and Mama Rose in Gypsy. Known for her unique voice—a mix of warmth, richness, and vulnerability—Peters has managed to make every role her own, even in shows that demand extraordinary emotional depth and vocal control. Her signature curly red hair and undeniable charm add to her memorable stage presence. Peters’ dedication to embodying each character’s nuances has cemented her as a beloved figure in musical theatre, particularly in the works of Stephen Sondheim, where she’s proved her ability to navigate complex songs with apparent ease. Her contributions continue to inspire and captivate audiences who seek a blend of classic Broadway flair with deeply felt character portrayals.
4. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a force of nature in the theatre world, celebrated for her extraordinary vocal talent and impressive range of emotional depth. With six Tony Awards, McDonald holds the record for the most wins by an actor, a testament to her versatility and command of the stage. Known for her exquisite soprano, she has taken on a wide array of roles, from the tragic Bess in Porgy and Bess to the heart-wrenching portrayal of Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill. Her voice carries not only technical brilliance but also a haunting vulnerability that draws audiences into the lives of her characters. McDonald’s unique ability to channel profound emotion into each performance, combined with her technical precision, has solidified her status as one of Broadway’s greatest performers. She remains a vibrant and influential figure in the theatre, continuing to inspire and captivate audiences with every performance.
5. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone brings a fierce and electrifying energy to every role she takes on, captivating audiences with a voice that is both powerful and precise. Her standout performances in roles like Eva Perón in Evita and Mama Rose in Gypsy have become iconic moments in musical theatre history. Her passionate rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” is often considered one of Broadway’s most unforgettable performances, showcasing her ability to convey complex emotions through powerful vocals. LuPone’s stage presence is intense and unapologetic; she brings a raw, visceral energy that few can match. This fearless approach to her characters makes each performance unforgettable, and her commitment to every role she plays continues to inspire new generations of theatre lovers and aspiring actors alike. LuPone is truly a legend of the stage, a performer whose name has become synonymous with Broadway excellence.
6. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury is a beloved Broadway legend, known for her versatility, charm, and a career that spans decades. Her role as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd revealed her talent for balancing dark comedy with impressive vocal skills, creating a character who was both endearing and twisted. Lansbury also shined in roles like Mame and Gypsy, demonstrating her boundless ability to bring warmth, depth, and a bit of mischief to her characters. Her magnetic stage presence, impeccable timing, and distinct voice have endeared her to audiences worldwide. Known for her kindness offstage and her charm on it, Lansbury has become a treasured figure in theatre. Her contributions to musical theatre are vast and varied, making her one of Broadway’s most cherished and respected performers.
7. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster took Broadway by storm with her Tony-winning role in Thoroughly Modern Millie, capturing audiences with her boundless energy, comic timing, and impressive vocal range. Foster has since continued to delight in major productions like Anything Goes and The Drowsy Chaperone, showcasing her versatility and resilience as a performer. Known for her infectious enthusiasm and ability to seamlessly blend humor with sincerity, Foster has become one of the most sought-after talents of modern Broadway. Her vibrant performances and strong stage presence make her a joy to watch, and her journey from ensemble member to leading lady is an inspiration to aspiring Broadway stars.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s powerful vocals and ability to connect emotionally with her characters have made her a Broadway icon. Best known for originating the role of Elphaba in Wicked, her performance of “Defying Gravity” has resonated with theatre-goers around the world, becoming a theme of resilience and empowerment. Before Wicked, she gained recognition as Maureen in Rent, showcasing her rock-infused vocal strength and emotional versatility. Menzel’s voice, with its remarkable range and intensity, can move from tender to triumphant with ease, creating unforgettable performances that have made her one of Broadway’s most recognizable voices. Her influence on contemporary musical theatre is undeniable, inspiring audiences with her unique sound and depth.
9. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell, known as “The Last Leading Man” of Broadway, has made a significant mark with his rich baritone and charismatic presence. His roles in Ragtime, Kiss Me, Kate, and Man of La Mancha showcase his ability to embody a range of characters with gravitas and emotional depth. Mitchell’s standout performance of “The Impossible Dream” in Man of La Mancha has left a lasting impression, embodying the spirit of perseverance and passion. His voice, smooth and powerful, captures the essence of each character he portrays, making him one of the most respected figures on Broadway.
10. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand, while perhaps more recognized for her film and recording career, made an unforgettable impact on Broadway with her portrayal of Fanny Brice in Funny Girl. Songs like “People” and “Don’t Rain on My Parade” became synonymous with her, capturing audiences with her distinctive voice that blends clarity with emotional intensity. Streisand’s talent for making each song a deeply personal statement set her apart from her contemporaries, establishing a lasting legacy in musical theatre. Her unique vocal style and exceptional diction continue to influence performers today, making her a timeless figure in entertainment.
11. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin’s unique vocal style and intense performances have earned him a special place in the hearts of theatre fans. His roles as Che in Evita and George in Sunday in the Park with George are among his most celebrated, showcasing his ability to bring a raw, almost haunting emotional depth to his characters. Patinkin’s voice, known for its expressive quality, adds a level of drama and vulnerability that makes his performances unforgettable. His dedication to each role, whether in a classic or contemporary show, has solidified his reputation as one of Broadway’s most respected actors.
12. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a performer unlike any other, known for her razor-sharp wit, powerful stage presence, and a voice that could stop an audience in its tracks. Her iconic performance of “The Ladies Who Lunch” in Stephen Sondheim’s Company captured her unique ability to blend comedy with raw emotion. Stritch’s career in both musical theatre and solo shows demonstrated her versatility and unflinching commitment to her craft, making her a Broadway legend. Her candid, no-nonsense approach to performing endeared her to audiences, securing her place as an unforgettable figure in musical theatre.
13. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera’s career is a testament to her extraordinary talent, versatility, and dedication to the stage. Known for her dazzling dance skills and sultry voice, Rivera originated roles in iconic musicals like West Side Story, Chicago, and Kiss of the Spider Woman, shaping musical theatre history with each performance. Her powerful stage presence and magnetic charisma make her one of the most admired performers in Broadway history. Rivera’s contributions have inspired countless artists and continue to resonate as benchmarks of theatrical excellence.
14. Hugh Jackman
Though he may be best known for his work in film, Hugh Jackman has a natural affinity for the Broadway stage. With roles like Curly in Oklahoma! and the dynamic Peter Allen in The Boy from Oz, Jackman has shown his versatility and ability to captivate live audiences. His charm and powerful voice make each performance a memorable event, and his Tony-winning portrayal in The Boy from Oz only solidified his place in musical theatre. Jackman’s charisma and stage presence continue to delight audiences, blending charm with dramatic intensity in a way that few can match.
15. Lin-Manuel Miranda
Lin-Manuel Miranda has reshaped the landscape of Broadway with his innovative storytelling and unique blending of hip-hop and traditional theatre. With Hamilton, he revolutionized what a Broadway musical could be, while his earlier work In the Heights introduced audiences to his energetic style and lyrical prowess. Miranda’s ability to connect with audiences through both his lyrics and performance has made him one of Broadway’s most influential figures, redefining the modern musical with his storytelling and paving the way for new voices and genres in theatre.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
