Broadway has long been the heart and soul of American musical theater, a vibrant realm where talent meets artistry in spectacular performances that captivate audiences night after night. Among the dazzling lights and grand stages, a select group of singers has risen to legendary status, enchanting theatergoers with their powerful voices and unforgettable presence. In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time, each a beacon of talent who has left an indelible mark on the stage.
From the golden age of musicals to contemporary hits, these artists have defined what it means to be a Broadway star. Their ability to convey emotion through song transcends mere performance; it creates a connection with the audience that lingers long after the final curtain falls. Whether belting out show-stopping numbers or delivering poignant ballads, these singers have showcased the extraordinary range and depth of the human experience.
Join us as we explore the lives, careers, and iconic performances of these remarkable individuals. Prepare to be inspired by their stories and awed by the sheer brilliance of their vocal prowess. The world of Broadway is about to come alive!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman was a Broadway powerhouse who helped define the golden age of musical theater. With a voice that could fill a theater without a microphone, she was known for her bold, brassy style and impeccable timing. Merman’s career took off in the 1930s, and she became a staple of Broadway for decades, commanding the stage in shows like Anything Goes, Annie Get Your Gun, and Gypsy. Her rendition of “There’s No Business Like Show Business” became an anthem for performers everywhere. Merman wasn’t just a singer; she was a force of personality—larger than life, fiercely confident, and entirely unforgettable. Her no-nonsense approach and stage presence helped set the tone for generations of leading ladies who followed. Critics and audiences alike were captivated by her unmatched energy and signature belt, a sound that became synonymous with Broadway itself. Even long after her final curtain call, Ethel Merman’s influence can still be felt. She broke molds, shattered expectations, and left behind a legacy that continues to inspire performers to this day. To talk about the history of Broadway without mentioning Ethel Merman is to leave out one of its most important voices.
2. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is one of Broadway’s most treasured stars, known for her radiant voice, expressive eyes, and incredible ability to breathe life into every character she plays. With her distinctive tone and nuanced acting, Peters has earned a reputation for bringing both emotional depth and vocal precision to the stage. Her collaborations with composer Stephen Sondheim, particularly in Sunday in the Park with George and Into the Woods, are considered masterpieces of musical theater. What makes Peters truly exceptional is her ability to make each role feel deeply personal—whether she’s singing a heart-wrenching ballad or delivering a quirky, comedic line. Her interpretation of “Send in the Clowns” remains one of the most moving renditions of the Sondheim classic. Over her decades-long career, she has won multiple Tony Awards and become a beloved figure in the world of musical theater. Offstage, Peters is also known for her advocacy work with Broadway Barks, supporting animal adoption. Her charm, warmth, and dedication to her craft make her a true inspiration for aspiring performers. Simply put, Bernadette Peters is Broadway royalty—an artist who elevates every production she’s part of.
3. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is Broadway thunder and fire—an unstoppable presence with a voice that pierces through a theater and settles straight into your soul. Known for her fearlessness, emotional honesty, and no-holds-barred performances, LuPone has given us some of the most iconic portrayals in musical theater history. From her Tony-winning role as Eva Perón in Evita to her electrifying Mama Rose in Gypsy, she doesn’t just play characters—she inhabits them. Her voice, rich and commanding, brings an edge of danger and vulnerability that few can replicate. LuPone has made a career of taking risks onstage and speaking her mind offstage, earning her a reputation as both a diva and a truth-teller. But behind her powerful presence is a deep commitment to storytelling and musical integrity. She doesn’t settle for shallow performances; she digs into the heart of every role, ensuring her audience feels every note and every emotion. With multiple Tonys and a legacy of unforgettable performances, Patti LuPone continues to set the gold standard for Broadway excellence. Her name alone carries the weight of theater history, and her performances remain the stuff of legend.
4. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel took Broadway by storm with a voice that’s both powerful and piercing, filled with emotion and raw honesty. Best known for originating the role of Elphaba in Wicked, Menzel’s performance of “Defying Gravity” has become an anthem for self-empowerment and perseverance. With her signature vocal belt and passionate delivery, she brings an intensity to the stage that few can match. Before Wicked, she gained recognition in Rent as Maureen, showcasing her versatility and ability to stand out in a groundbreaking ensemble. Menzel’s transition from Broadway to mainstream fame came with the smash hit “Let It Go” from Disney’s Frozen, solidifying her as a household name worldwide. Yet even with global recognition, she remains a Broadway performer at heart—authentic, vulnerable, and deeply connected to her music. What sets Idina apart is her ability to fuse technical skill with genuine emotion, creating performances that feel as intimate as they are powerful. Whether on stage or screen, she draws you in, makes you feel seen, and leaves you inspired. Idina Menzel isn’t just a Broadway star—she’s a voice of a generation.
5. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury’s career is nothing short of remarkable. Though known to many as the beloved Jessica Fletcher from Murder, She Wrote, Lansbury’s impact on Broadway is equally profound. With a voice full of character and charm, she brought depth and humanity to every role she tackled. Her Broadway debut came in the 1960s, but it was her role as Mame Dennis in Mame that solidified her as a musical theater star. She later dazzled audiences in Gypsy, Sweeney Todd, and A Little Night Music, earning multiple Tony Awards and the respect of the theater community worldwide. What set Lansbury apart was her ability to fully embody a character—she didn’t just sing a role; she became it. Whether playing a whimsical madwoman or a scheming pie-maker, she brought a magnetic energy and subtle emotional intelligence to the stage. Her performances were always grounded, smart, and unforgettable. Offstage, Lansbury carried herself with grace and humility, becoming a role model for generations of performers. With a career spanning over seven decades, Angela Lansbury remains a timeless symbol of Broadway excellence, proving that great theater is ageless and endlessly inspiring.
6. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga is a musical theater phenomenon whose voice has captivated audiences across the globe. Known for her crystal-clear tone and emotional depth, she made history as the first Asian woman to win a Tony Award for her role as Kim in Miss Saigon. Her performance was both vulnerable and powerful, marking her as a true star from the very beginning. Salonga later took on the role of Eponine in Les Misérables, and her rendition of “On My Own” remains one of the most beloved interpretations of the song. Her talent also reached Disney audiences, lending her voice to iconic princesses Jasmine (Aladdin) and Mulan, further cementing her place in musical history. What makes Lea truly remarkable is not just her voice but her grace, humility, and tireless dedication to her craft. She sings with purpose, clarity, and sincerity—qualities that make her performances unforgettable. Beyond Broadway, she continues to tour internationally, mentor young performers, and represent diversity and excellence in theater. Her legacy continues to grow, and she remains a role model for aspiring singers and actors around the world. Lea Salonga isn’t just a star; she’s a standard-bearer for musical excellence.
7. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell possesses a voice as rich and commanding as any to ever grace the Broadway stage. With his warm baritone and regal stage presence, he has become a cornerstone of the modern musical theater world. Best known for his leading roles in Kiss Me, Kate, Man of La Mancha, and Ragtime, Stokes brings both strength and sensitivity to every performance. He can deliver thunderous declarations of passion and, just as easily, tender moments of introspection. His portrayal of Coalhouse Walker Jr. in Ragtime is considered a masterclass in both vocal performance and emotional storytelling. But Mitchell is more than just a performer—he’s a passionate advocate for the arts. As a former chairman of the Actors Fund, he’s worked tirelessly to support the theater community. Onstage, he’s a commanding force; offstage, a humble leader. His ability to blend classical technique with Broadway heart sets him apart from his peers. Whether performing in a musical or singing in a symphony hall, Brian Stokes Mitchell leaves audiences moved, inspired, and in awe of his talent. He’s a true gentleman of the stage and one of Broadway’s finest.
8. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is, quite simply, a Broadway legend. With six Tony Awards to her name—more than any other actor in history—she has redefined what it means to be a musical theater star. Her voice, a luminous soprano capable of incredible precision and emotional range, brings every character she plays to life with authenticity and grace. Whether she’s portraying Bess in Porgy and Bess or Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, McDonald’s performances are raw, powerful, and unforgettable. She moves effortlessly between opera, Broadway, and television, proving her versatility time and time again. But what truly sets Audra apart is her unwavering commitment to truth in storytelling. She never simply performs a role—she inhabits it fully, with empathy and fearless honesty. Her impact goes beyond the stage; she’s a vocal advocate for equality, representation, and the transformative power of the arts. Audra McDonald is not just a singer or actress—she’s a cultural force, a mentor, and an artist whose work continues to shape the future of theater. Watching her perform is not just entertainment—it’s witnessing greatness.
9. Jonathan Groff
Jonathan Groff brings a unique blend of charm, vulnerability, and vocal talent to every performance. He first captured Broadway’s attention in Spring Awakening, where his emotionally raw performance as Melchior earned him a Tony nomination and launched him into stardom. Groff’s voice—rich, expressive, and full of heart—stands out for its ability to convey complex emotions with ease. He continued to showcase his range as King George III in the cultural juggernaut Hamilton, stealing scenes with comedic flair and impeccable timing. Offstage, Groff is beloved for his authenticity, humility, and infectious enthusiasm for theater. His work on stage has been complemented by a successful television and film career, including Mindhunter, Glee, and voicing Kristoff in Disney’s Frozen. But Broadway is where his passion truly shines. Whether in a dramatic ballad or a light-hearted show tune, Groff connects deeply with his audience, making each performance feel personal and sincere. He represents a new generation of performers—versatile, grounded, and incredibly gifted. With every role, Groff continues to grow and impress, proving that his star power isn’t just about talent—it’s about heart.
10. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a trailblazer, a legend, and a true original in the world of Broadway. With a career spanning over six decades, she has become a symbol of excellence in musical theater. Rivera made history as one of the first Latina performers to rise to Broadway stardom, originating iconic roles such as Anita in West Side Story and Velma Kelly in Chicago. Her electric presence, dynamic dance skills, and commanding voice made her a triple threat long before the term became common. Rivera brought grit and glamour to every stage she stepped on, infusing her performances with both passion and polish. She earned multiple Tony Awards and was honored with a Tony for Lifetime Achievement in 2018, a fitting recognition for a performer who broke barriers and paved the way for countless others. But perhaps what defines Chita most is her resilience and love for the craft. Even well into her later years, she continued to perform with the same fire and precision that defined her early career. She is a living legend whose name is etched into Broadway history, not just for what she’s done—but for how powerfully she did it.
11. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is one of Broadway’s brightest stars, known for her sparkling soprano voice, impeccable comedic timing, and larger-than-life personality. She gained widespread fame for originating the role of Glinda the Good Witch in the hit musical Wicked, where her effervescent charm and high-flying vocals made “Popular” a show-stopping number. Chenoweth’s voice is instantly recognizable—light, agile, and capable of reaching soaring notes with clarity and ease. But beyond her vocal talent, she brings an infectious energy to every role, lighting up the stage whether she’s playing a comedic diva or a heartfelt romantic lead. Her theater credits span from You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown to Promises, Promises, and she’s also found success in television, film, and concert performances. What makes Chenoweth truly beloved is her relatability and kindness—she has a unique ability to make each audience member feel like a friend. Offstage, she champions arts education and frequently mentors young performers. With her versatility, humor, and heart, Kristin Chenoweth continues to be a defining voice in musical theater, and her influence reaches far beyond the footlights of Broadway.
12. Norm Lewis
Norm Lewis is a powerhouse performer whose commanding baritone and magnetic stage presence have made him one of Broadway’s most respected and trailblazing talents. He made history as the first African American actor to play the title role in The Phantom of the Opera on Broadway, breaking barriers in one of the most iconic musicals of all time. His performance was not just groundbreaking—it was vocally stunning and emotionally rich. Lewis has starred in major productions like Porgy and Bess, Les Misérables, and The Little Mermaid, consistently earning praise for his ability to bring depth and humanity to his roles. His voice is deep, smooth, and filled with emotion, capable of moving audiences from the first note. Beyond his stage work, Lewis is known for his grace, humility, and advocacy for increased diversity and equity in the theater world. He frequently speaks about the importance of representation, both on stage and behind the scenes. With a career that continues to evolve and inspire, Norm Lewis has proven that talent, integrity, and perseverance can change the face of Broadway—and that his legacy is still being written with every performance.
13. Sara Bareilles
Sara Bareilles made a remarkable and heartfelt entrance into the world of Broadway through her work on the hit musical Waitress. Already a successful pop artist known for songs like “Love Song” and “Brave,” Bareilles brought her storytelling gifts and rich, emotive voice to the theater world and instantly became a beloved figure. As both the composer and lyricist for Waitress, she crafted a score filled with honesty, vulnerability, and hope—songs like “She Used to Be Mine” resonate with audiences for their raw emotional power. When she stepped into the role of Jenna herself, her performances were nothing short of magical, showing that her talents extend well beyond the recording studio. Bareilles connects with audiences in a deeply personal way; her music tells stories about real people and real feelings, often leaving listeners in tears or uplifted by the honesty of her work. She brings a fresh voice to Broadway, one rooted in contemporary music but seamlessly woven into theatrical storytelling. With her generosity, humility, and passion for the arts, Sara Bareilles has become a welcome and vital part of the Broadway landscape.
14. Carole King
Carole King is one of the most influential singer-songwriters of all time, and her impact on Broadway was immortalized through the acclaimed musical Beautiful: The Carole King Musical. Chronicling her journey from a shy teenage songwriter to a music industry legend, the show brought her incredible catalog of hits—like “You’ve Got a Friend,” “It’s Too Late,” and “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman”—to new generations. King’s music has always had a way of speaking straight to the heart, with lyrics that are tender, honest, and deeply human. While she wasn’t a Broadway performer herself, her influence as a composer is immense. Her melodies are unforgettable, and her songs have an emotional clarity that few can match. What sets King apart is her ability to transform life’s ordinary moments into something timeless through music. Beautiful not only showcased her genius but also introduced her story to those who may have only known the hits. Her legacy bridges the worlds of pop, folk, and musical theater, and her music continues to inspire performers and songwriters alike. Carole King’s songs are woven into the fabric of American musical history.
15. Vanessa Williams
Vanessa Williams is a rare talent who has seamlessly blended careers in music, television, film, and theater. While she first rose to fame in the pop world and as Miss America, her contributions to Broadway are equally impressive and enduring. Williams brought grace, power, and vocal excellence to her performances in musicals like Into the Woods, where she played the Witch with a perfect mix of menace and heart. In Kiss of the Spider Woman, she captivated audiences with her stage presence and vocal command, proving she’s much more than a crossover artist—she’s a Broadway powerhouse. Her voice is rich, expressive, and full of control, allowing her to navigate both show-stopping numbers and tender ballads with ease. Beyond her onstage work, Vanessa is admired for her professionalism, poise, and commitment to pushing creative boundaries. She is a role model for artists navigating multiple creative industries, and she continues to inspire with every new project. Whether performing under the bright lights of Broadway or in front of a camera, Vanessa Williams brings elegance and soul to everything she does.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
