Few artists have left a mark on popular music quite like Billy Joel. With a career spanning over five decades, Joel has penned some of the most unforgettable songs in American music history—tracks that blend sharp storytelling, melodic genius, and raw emotional power. Whether he’s crooning about love, rattling off world events at lightning speed, or painting vivid portraits of New York life, Billy Joel has a song for every mood and moment. His catalog is a masterclass in genre-blending, effortlessly moving between rock, pop, jazz, and classical influences, all while staying unmistakably “Billy.”
In this article, we’re counting down the top 10 most popular Billy Joel songs of all time—not just based on chart performance, but also on cultural impact, fan favorites, and the timeless quality that keeps them playing on radios, playlists, and concert stages around the world. From anthems that make you sing at the top of your lungs to introspective ballads that hit straight to the heart, these songs have become the soundtrack to countless lives. So whether you’re a lifelong fan or just discovering the Piano Man for the first time, get ready for a journey through the hits that define a legend.
1. Piano Man (1973)
Released in 1973, “Piano Man” is more than just Billy Joel’s breakout hit — it’s the song that truly introduced his gift for vivid, character-driven storytelling. Based on his time working as a lounge pianist at The Executive Room in Los Angeles, Joel draws from real-life experiences to craft a musical snapshot of barroom regulars, each nursing dreams and regrets with a drink in hand. The haunting harmonica intro sets the stage for a waltzing, bittersweet ballad in 3/4 time, giving the song a lilting, nostalgic quality that mirrors the melancholy atmosphere of the bar itself. Characters like John the bartender and Davy in the Navy feel authentic, almost cinematic, as Joel weaves their stories together in a way that feels both specific and universally relatable. Although it wasn’t a major hit at the time of its release, “Piano Man” grew steadily into one of Joel’s most beloved classics — a staple at his live shows and a singalong favorite that spans generations. Today, it’s considered a cultural touchstone — not just a song, but an experience that captures the soul of everyday people trying to find meaning, connection, and maybe a little solace in a song at the end of a long day.
2. Uptown Girl (1983)
“Uptown Girl,” released in 1983, is Billy Joel’s infectious tribute to the doo-wop and pop sounds of the late ‘50s and early ‘60s, and it remains one of his most recognizable and joyous tracks. Packed with buoyant piano riffs, layered harmonies, finger-snapping beats, and vintage handclaps, the song channels the spirit of groups like Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons, but with a fresh, modern edge. Joel tells the playful story of a working-class guy in love with a sophisticated, high-society woman — a lighthearted take on class contrasts wrapped in a feel-good, radio-ready package. Though initially inspired by supermodel Elle Macpherson, the song became famously linked to Christie Brinkley, who starred in the music video and later became Joel’s wife. The song’s charm helped propel it to No. 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 in the U.S., and it soared to No. 1 in the UK, cementing its place as an international hit. “Uptown Girl” isn’t just catchy; it’s cinematic, upbeat, and timeless — a retro-pop gem that stands out in Joel’s catalog. Whether you’re dancing to it or singing along in the car, it captures the carefree energy of young love and old-school romance with irresistible flair.
3. Just the Way You Are (1977)
When Billy Joel released “Just the Way You Are” in 1977 as part of The Stranger, he struck a deeply emotional chord with listeners that still resonates today. Written originally as a birthday gift for his then-wife, Elizabeth Weber, the song is a tender ballad about accepting someone wholly and unconditionally — loving them not for who they could become, but for who they already are. Joel’s voice is at its most intimate and sincere, floating over a lush arrangement that features smooth electric piano and a gorgeous saxophone solo by jazz legend Phil Woods. With its soft jazz-pop vibe and heartfelt lyrics, the track stood apart from the rock-driven hits of the time, yet it quickly became one of Joel’s biggest commercial successes. It won both the Grammy for Song of the Year and Record of the Year in 1979, helping solidify Joel as a major force in American music. Despite his later ambivalence toward performing it, fans have continued to embrace “Just the Way You Are” as one of the most romantic songs of all time. It’s a wedding favorite, a slow-dance staple, and a timeless anthem of love and acceptance that never loses its warmth or meaning.
4. We Didn’t Start the Fire (1989)
Billy Joel took on an ambitious task with “We Didn’t Start the Fire,” released in 1989 — crafting a whirlwind history lesson in the form of a pop song. With more than 100 rapid-fire references to political, cultural, and historical events spanning from 1949 (the year of Joel’s birth) through the late 1980s, the song reads like a sonic timeline of the post-war 20th century. Backed by a pounding rhythm and minimal melodic variation, Joel forgoes traditional song structure in favor of a relentless stream of names, places, and headlines that blend into a hypnotic chant. The idea was sparked by a conversation with a younger friend who believed the modern era was uniquely troubled. Joel’s response? Trouble has always been here — every generation inherits its own fires. Despite its unconventional style, the song became a massive hit, reaching No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. It’s been studied in classrooms, parodied in pop culture, and endlessly debated for its content and cadence. “We Didn’t Start the Fire” is more than a catchy song; it’s a cultural artifact, a fast-paced mosaic of modern history, and a reminder that the world’s chaos is nothing new — we’re just part of the ongoing story.
5. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant (1977)
“Scenes from an Italian Restaurant” isn’t just a song — it’s a musical journey. Released in 1977 on The Stranger, the nearly eight-minute track unfolds like a mini rock opera, complete with tempo shifts, thematic changes, and rich storytelling. It begins with a soft, jazzy piano intro as two old friends meet at a quiet restaurant and catch up over a bottle of wine. As the song unfolds, we’re taken into the story of Brenda and Eddie, high school sweethearts whose fast-burning romance fizzles out after a brief, turbulent marriage. Joel masterfully shifts from lounge-style piano to rollicking rock to Broadway-esque narrative, making each transition feel seamless and emotionally grounded. While never released as a single, it has become one of his most beloved deep cuts — a fan favorite that captures the bittersweet nature of nostalgia. The song’s complexity, both musically and lyrically, highlights Joel’s songwriting prowess. “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant” is about more than lost love — it’s about time, memory, and the way our youthful dreams evolve as we age. Listening to it feels like sharing a meal with an old friend, swapping stories that are funny, sad, and beautifully familiar all at once.
6. New York State of Mind (1976)
“New York State of Mind,” released in 1976 on Turnstiles, is Billy Joel’s heartfelt tribute to the city that shaped him. After spending a few years living in Los Angeles, Joel returned to New York and channeled his longing for home into this soulful, jazz-tinged ballad. From the first few notes of the slow, smoky piano intro, you can almost see the skyline and feel the city’s pulse. The arrangement is rich and moody, featuring a standout saxophone solo and a relaxed tempo that allows Joel’s impassioned vocals to shine. There’s no gimmick or grand hook — just honest, unfiltered emotion wrapped in a melody that feels timeless. Although never released as a single, the song has become an unofficial anthem for New Yorkers everywhere, especially in moments of pride and resilience. It gained renewed significance after 9/11, often performed at memorials and tributes, reminding listeners of the city’s enduring spirit. “New York State of Mind” is more than a love letter — it’s a musical embrace, a reminder that no matter how far you wander, there’s a place that always calls you back. For Joel, and for many fans, that place is unmistakably New York.
7. Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (1977)
With “Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song),” Billy Joel delivered one of his sharpest critiques of the American dream — and did it with style. Released in 1977 on The Stranger, the track combines biting social commentary with a punchy, piano-driven groove. Joel zeroes in on the pressure to equate success with status symbols — big houses, Cadillacs, and corner offices — and questions whether any of it truly brings happiness. Through characters like Anthony, Sergeant O’Leary, and Mama Leone, he paints a vivid picture of blue-collar life caught between ambition and authenticity. The song’s structure defies convention: there’s no bridge, and it ends with the dramatic screech of a motorcycle and a final staccato piano chord — a sonic symbol of rejection and rebellion. Joel’s message is clear: if chasing someone else’s version of success is making you miserable, maybe it’s time to move out — emotionally and physically. Though the song charted well, its legacy extended beyond radio — it became the title track of the Broadway musical Movin’ Out, based entirely on Joel’s music. It remains a fan favorite, celebrated for its raw honesty, rhythmic drive, and its empowering message to live life on your own terms.
8. My Life (1978)
Released in 1978 as part of 52nd Street, “My Life” is Billy Joel at his most self-assured and unapologetic. The song opens with a bright, catchy keyboard riff that instantly grabs your attention, leading into a bold declaration of independence: “I don’t care what you say anymore, this is my life.” It’s a defiant anthem for anyone who’s ever felt the need to break away from expectations or assert their freedom. Lyrically, it’s sharp and personal, reflecting Joel’s insistence on living life by his own rules. Musically, it blends pop-rock with polished production, and it even features backing vocals from Peter Cetera and Donnie Dacus of the band Chicago, adding a lush harmonic layer. The song became a Top 5 hit and was later used as the theme for the TV sitcom Bosom Buddies, bringing it to an even wider audience. What makes “My Life” stand out is its empowering tone — confident but not arrogant, catchy but not superficial. It’s one of those rare songs that can lift your mood instantly, reminding you that you don’t owe anyone an explanation for being who you are. It’s Joel’s musical mic drop — bold, brash, and completely on his own terms.
9. Only the Good Die Young (1977)
“Only the Good Die Young,” from Billy Joel’s 1977 album The Stranger, walks a fine line between controversy and catchy brilliance — and that’s exactly what makes it unforgettable. The song pairs a bouncy, upbeat rhythm with lyrics that challenge traditional religious and moral expectations. Joel takes on the voice of a cheeky narrator trying to convince a Catholic girl to let go of her inhibitions and embrace life’s pleasures, much to the dismay of religious groups who tried to get the song banned. Ironically, those bans only increased its popularity. Joel has insisted the song isn’t anti-religion — it’s a statement about youthful desire and the pushback against repression. Musically, it’s a masterclass in contrast: a reggae-influenced groove, bright piano chords, and an irresistible hook that makes the song feel joyful, even as it ruffles feathers. “Only the Good Die Young” became one of Joel’s most talked-about tracks, cementing his reputation as a songwriter unafraid to tackle taboo topics with wit and melody. Decades later, it still sparks debate, but above all, it gets people singing — and thinking. Provocative, playful, and endlessly catchy, it’s Joel at his most rebellious and charming.
10. The Longest Time (1983)
“The Longest Time,” released in 1983 on An Innocent Man, is Billy Joel’s heartfelt throwback to the doo-wop sounds of the late 1950s. In a bold stylistic move, Joel constructed the track almost entirely with his own voice — from lead vocals to layered harmonies and even vocal percussion. There’s no traditional instrumentation here, just Joel channeling the spirit of street-corner serenades with a warmth and sincerity that’s hard to resist. Lyrically, the song captures the gentle surprise of finding love again after a long dry spell. It’s hopeful without being naïve, sweet without being saccharine. With its stripped-down sound and nostalgic flair, “The Longest Time” stood out in the synthesizer-heavy pop landscape of the early ’80s and became an instant favorite. It climbed to No. 14 on the Billboard Hot 100 and has remained popular with a cappella groups and choirs for its simplicity and charm. The song is a beautiful example of Joel’s versatility — proof that even in an era of flashy production, a great melody and heartfelt sentiment can still steal the show. “The Longest Time” feels like a love letter to a bygone era, wrapped in a voice that never goes out of style.
Samuel Moore is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
