Billy Joel is more than just a musician—he’s a storyteller, a poet, and one of the most influential singer-songwriters of all time. With a career spanning over five decades, his music has touched the hearts of millions, blending rock, pop, jazz, and classical influences into unforgettable melodies. From anthems that define generations to poignant ballads that capture life’s most intimate moments, Joel’s songs are timeless.
But which of his legendary tracks stand above the rest? In this list, we’re counting down the top 10 most popular Billy Joel songs of all time—the ones that have stood the test of time, dominated the airwaves, and continue to resonate with fans old and new. Whether it’s the nostalgic storytelling of Piano Man, the electrifying energy of We Didn’t Start the Fire, or the heartfelt romance of Just the Way You Are, these songs showcase Joel’s unparalleled ability to craft music that speaks to the soul.
So, whether you’re a lifelong fan or just discovering his brilliance, get ready to dive into the very best of the Piano Man himself. These are the songs that define Billy Joel’s legacy—turn up the volume and enjoy! 🎶🔥
1. Piano Man (1973)
Billy Joel’s “Piano Man” is the song that launched him into stardom, painting a vivid picture of a lonely yet intimate bar scene where a struggling musician provides the soundtrack for a cast of colorful patrons. Inspired by Joel’s real-life experience playing at a piano bar in Los Angeles, the song brings to life dreamers, drifters, and heartbroken souls, all seeking solace in music. With its waltz-like rhythm, harmonica intro, and detailed storytelling, the track immediately captures listeners, drawing them into its melancholic yet familiar world. The lyrics introduce unforgettable characters—the old man longing for lost days, the bartender who doubles as a psychologist, and the waitress practicing politics—each contributing to the song’s deeply nostalgic feel. The singalong chorus and haunting melody make it a song that resonates across generations, cementing its status as one of Joel’s most iconic compositions. Over the decades, “Piano Man” has remained a staple of his concerts and a fan favorite, symbolizing the power of music to bring people together, even in moments of solitude. It’s not just a song; it’s a cinematic experience, immortalizing the struggles and dreams of everyday people.
2. Uptown Girl (1983)
A stark contrast to Billy Joel’s signature piano ballads, “Uptown Girl” is an energetic, doo-wop-inspired anthem that pays tribute to the golden age of 1950s rock and roll. With its upbeat tempo, crisp harmonies, and infectious melody, the song captures the excitement and nervous energy of a working-class guy hoping to win the heart of a sophisticated, high-class woman. Many fans and critics believe the song was inspired by Joel’s then-girlfriend, supermodel Christie Brinkley, who later became his wife, making the track feel even more personal. The song’s lighthearted lyrics, paired with its retro sound, make it a standout in Joel’s discography. “Uptown Girl” became one of his biggest hits, earning massive radio play and a memorable music video featuring Brinkley herself. Even decades after its release, the song’s playful charm continues to resonate, making it a favorite at weddings, parties, and nostalgic throwback playlists. Whether it’s the catchy hook, the vintage vibe, or the feel-good story behind it, “Uptown Girl” remains one of Billy Joel’s most enduring and joyful songs.
3. We Didn’t Start the Fire (1989)
Unlike anything else in Billy Joel’s catalog, “We Didn’t Start the Fire” is a whirlwind of historical and cultural references set to a driving, urgent rhythm. The lyrics are a relentless list of events, figures, and milestones spanning from 1949 (the year Joel was born) to 1989, creating a snapshot of history in motion. Each verse rushes through names and moments—Harry Truman, Marilyn Monroe, Sputnik, Woodstock, Watergate—mirroring the fast-paced nature of world events. Joel has admitted that the song’s melody isn’t his favorite, but its powerful lyrical structure has given it a lasting appeal. It has often been used in classrooms to introduce students to 20th-century history, proving that music can be both entertaining and educational. While some fans see it as a nostalgic trip through the past, others view it as a reminder that history is cyclical and ever-evolving. Even today, listeners revisit the song, marveling at how relevant its themes remain. “We Didn’t Start the Fire” is more than just a song—it’s a time capsule capturing the chaos, triumphs, and turbulence of modern history.
4. Just the Way You Are (1977)
One of Billy Joel’s most beloved love songs, “Just the Way You Are” is a tender, jazz-infused ballad that beautifully expresses unconditional love and acceptance. The song, featuring a smooth saxophone solo and gentle piano arrangement, became Joel’s first major hit, earning him Grammy Awards for both Record of the Year and Song of the Year. It was originally written for his first wife, Elizabeth Weber, though Joel later admitted he didn’t think much of the song at first. It was producer Phil Ramone who convinced him to include it on the The Stranger album, and the rest is history. The song’s soft, romantic lyrics—promising love without the need for change—have made it a staple at weddings and anniversaries for decades. Despite Joel’s complicated feelings about its origins, “Just the Way You Are” remains one of his most cherished and frequently covered songs. Its message of devotion and sincerity continues to resonate with listeners, proving that sometimes, the simplest sentiments make the deepest impact.
5. Vienna (1977)
“Vienna” is one of those hidden gems that has grown in popularity over time, becoming a fan favorite for its deeply introspective lyrics and hauntingly beautiful melody. The song was inspired by Joel’s trip to Vienna, where he observed an elderly woman going about her daily life with dignity and purpose. This moment sparked a revelation—life isn’t a race, and slowing down to appreciate the journey is just as important as ambition and success. The song’s delicate piano arrangement and wistful tone perfectly complement its message, urging listeners to take their time and find meaning beyond constant striving. Over the years, “Vienna” has become an anthem for those seeking reassurance in a world that often pressures people to achieve more and move faster. Thanks to its emotional depth and relatability, it remains one of Joel’s most streamed songs, proving that sometimes, the quietest tracks leave the biggest impact.
6. She’s Always a Woman (1977)
A poetic and deeply personal ballad, “She’s Always a Woman” is an ode to the complexities of love. With its soft acoustic guitar, delicate piano, and Joel’s gentle vocals, the song paints a portrait of a woman who is both strong and vulnerable, fiercely independent yet endlessly captivating. Though originally written about his first wife, the song has transcended its personal origins, resonating with anyone who has experienced the depth and contradictions of love. The lyrics celebrate a woman who “steals like a thief but is always a woman to me,” highlighting both her flaws and her irresistible charm. The song’s emotional honesty and timeless melody have ensured its lasting appeal, making it a staple in Joel’s live performances.
7. Only the Good Die Young (1977)
A rebellious, upbeat rock song with a playful edge, “Only the Good Die Young” is one of Billy Joel’s most controversial tracks. The lyrics tell the story of a young man trying to persuade a Catholic girl to let loose and embrace life’s pleasures. The song’s infectious rhythm, lively piano, and mischievous lyrics sparked backlash upon its release, with some radio stations refusing to play it. However, this only added to its appeal, and it quickly became a fan favorite. With its catchy melody and carefree energy, the song remains a highlight of Joel’s rock catalog, embodying the youthful defiance and excitement of first love.
8. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant (1977)
A storytelling masterpiece, “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant” is an ambitious, nearly eight-minute track that feels more like a short film than a song. Shifting between musical styles and tempos, it tells the tale of Brenda and Eddie, a once-promising young couple whose marriage ultimately falls apart. The song’s vivid storytelling, intricate instrumentation, and theatrical structure make it one of Joel’s greatest compositions. Fans love how it captures the passage of time, the nostalgia of young love, and the bittersweet nature of growing older.
9. The Longest Time (1984)
A nostalgic throwback to doo-wop harmonies, “The Longest Time” is a unique addition to Joel’s catalog. The song is almost entirely a cappella, featuring layers of Joel’s own voice creating the harmonized backing vocals. Lyrically, it tells the story of rediscovering love after a long absence. Its warm, inviting melody and sincere lyrics make it an enduring favorite, often celebrated for its retro charm.
10. New York State of Mind (1976)
A love letter to New York City, “New York State of Mind” is a soulful, jazz-influenced ballad that captures the essence of the city’s energy and allure. Written upon Joel’s return to New York after living in Los Angeles, the song’s rich piano arrangement and heartfelt lyrics evoke a deep sense of nostalgia. Though not a major hit at the time, it has since become an anthem for New Yorkers and one of Joel’s most beloved songs.
Samuel Moore is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
