The lights dim, the orchestra swells, and a singular voice pierces through the silence, sending shivers down your spine. Broadway has always been the heartbeat of musical theatre, where dreams are sung into reality and legends are born. Throughout its storied history, Broadway has introduced us to voices that transcend time, leaving an indelible mark on the world of entertainment. From the golden age of musicals to the modern era of boundary-pushing productions, these performers have brought unforgettable characters to life with their unparalleled vocal prowess, emotional depth, and magnetic stage presence.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—artists whose voices have become synonymous with the Great White Way. These are the performers who’ve made us laugh, cry, and cheer, whether belting out show-stopping anthems or delivering hauntingly beautiful ballads. From iconic pioneers who shaped Broadway’s golden legacy to contemporary stars redefining the genre, these singers have captivated audiences and inspired generations. So, grab your Playbill and settle in as we take a journey through the voices that have defined Broadway’s history and continue to light up stages worldwide. Curtain up, and let the show begin!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is nothing short of an icon in the history of Broadway. Often called “The Grande Dame of the Broadway Stage,” her voice was truly one of a kind—booming and crystal-clear, able to fill even the largest theaters without the help of a microphone. Merman’s vocal strength and commanding presence made her a force to be reckoned with, leaving an unforgettable mark on the stage. She is best remembered for her performances in timeless Broadway hits such as Gypsy and Annie Get Your Gun. Her role as Mama Rose in Gypsy, in particular, is considered one of the most powerful and compelling performances in musical theater history. Merman had a special gift for taking on roles that demanded sheer vocal power and emotional intensity. Her rendition of “There’s No Business Like Show Business,” which she performed in Annie Get Your Gun, has become the anthem of Broadway itself, symbolizing the excitement and magic of live theater. Throughout her career, Merman’s larger-than-life persona and fearless commitment to her craft brought a new level of energy and excitement to musical theater, inspiring generations of performers. She was the epitome of Broadway bravado, a woman who could command the stage with just a note. Her unparalleled ability to sing with both strength and precision allowed her to create roles that have remained etched in the minds of theatergoers for decades. Merman’s legacy as the Queen of Broadway’s Golden Age lives on, her recordings and performances still cherished by those who love musical theater.
2. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews is a name synonymous with grace, elegance, and timeless talent. From her very first Broadway performance as Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady to her later performances on screen, Andrews quickly became a beloved figure in the world of musical theater. Her angelic soprano voice was a perfect match for her charm and poise, making her a star both on stage and in film. In addition to My Fair Lady, Andrews’ portrayal of Queen Guinevere in Camelot solidified her status as a Broadway icon. She became a household name after starring in The Sound of Music and Mary Poppins, both of which became cinematic masterpieces. But her contributions to Broadway were profound long before she became a film star. Andrews’ performances on stage were marked by her precision, her warmth, and her ability to connect with audiences on an emotional level. She was the perfect combination of vocal brilliance and down-to-earth charm, winning the hearts of theatergoers everywhere. Throughout her career, Julie Andrews showcased not only her vocal mastery but also her ability to inhabit her roles with depth and sincerity. She effortlessly navigated the delicate balance between elegance and humor, always delivering her performances with grace and sincerity. Whether on the stage or on the big screen, Julie Andrews’ contributions to musical theater remain an enduring legacy. She helped define what it means to be a Broadway star, and her influence is still felt in the performances of actors and singers today.
3. Bernadette Peters
With her fiery red curls, unmistakable voice, and undeniable charm, Bernadette Peters is one of Broadway’s most cherished performers. Known for her ability to infuse vulnerability and strength into her roles, Peters has captured the hearts of audiences for decades. A two-time Tony Award winner, her work with legendary composer Stephen Sondheim has become the stuff of Broadway legend. Peters’ portrayals of characters in Sunday in the Park with George, Into the Woods, and Gypsy have earned her a reputation as one of the greatest interpreters of Sondheim’s complex, emotionally rich material. What sets Peters apart is her ability to balance lighthearted comedy with deep emotional resonance, creating characters that feel simultaneously real and larger-than-life. In Gypsy, for instance, her portrayal of the iconic role of Louise became a performance of both tenderness and fierce determination, an unforgettable blend of humanity and theatricality. As a singer, Peters is known for her clear, expressive voice, which can move seamlessly from delicate, nuanced moments to powerful, show-stopping high notes. She has also become a favorite of theatergoers for her performances in Annie Get Your Gun and The Goodbye Girl, showing her incredible range as a performer. But it’s her rare ability to evoke deep emotion in each performance that has made her a standout in musical theater. Bernadette Peters’ influence on Broadway and her legacy as a powerhouse performer and interpretive artist will continue to be felt for years to come.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is a force of nature on the Broadway stage. Known for her commanding voice, fierce stage presence, and unparalleled emotional depth, LuPone has become one of the most celebrated actresses in musical theater. Her Tony-winning performances in Evita as Eva Perón and in Gypsy as Rose solidified her status as a Broadway legend. LuPone’s vocal prowess is matched only by her ability to delve deep into the emotional heart of every character she plays. Whether she’s belting out a powerful anthem or singing a quiet, intimate ballad, LuPone’s voice is one that demands attention and never fails to leave a lasting impact. Her role as Eva Perón in Evita remains one of her most iconic, with her portrayal of the complex character bringing a fierce intensity to the stage that was unmatched. In Gypsy, LuPone’s portrayal of Rose, the ambitious and relentless stage mother, is nothing short of breathtaking, capturing both the vulnerability and the unyielding determination of the character. Known for her fearless attitude and willingness to take on challenging roles, LuPone has become a symbol of Broadway’s raw energy and emotional depth. Her work spans beyond these iconic roles, with memorable performances in Anything Goes, Les Misérables, and The Robber Bridegroom all showcasing her vocal range and ability to connect with her audience. With her uncompromising approach to her craft, Patti LuPone continues to inspire and captivate theatergoers with each performance.
5. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a true gem of Broadway, whose unparalleled talent has made her one of the most revered performers in musical theater. With a record-breaking six Tony Awards—more than any other performer—McDonald has redefined what it means to be a Broadway star. Her transcendent soprano voice is pure magic, and her ability to seamlessly blend operatic excellence with emotional storytelling sets her apart as one of the finest voices of her generation. McDonald’s roles in Ragtime, Carousel, and Porgy and Bess are just a few examples of her remarkable range and versatility. In Ragtime, she gave a stunning performance as Sarah, capturing the emotional depth and raw power of the character’s journey. Her role as Bess in Porgy and Bess cemented her status as a leading lady in both the worlds of opera and musical theater, with her vocal prowess and dramatic intensity making the role uniquely her own. McDonald’s performances are never just about the notes she sings—they are about the emotions she evokes, the stories she tells, and the connections she builds with her audience. Her impeccable technique, coupled with her innate ability to bring depth and humanity to each character, ensures that every performance is a memorable experience. Beyond her Broadway accomplishments, McDonald has also graced the concert stage, television, and film, proving her versatility as an artist. Her passion for music and her dedication to her craft continue to inspire a new generation of performers, and her legacy as one of Broadway’s finest continues to shine brightly.
6. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury is a true Broadway legend, beloved for her charm, wit, and extraordinary versatility. With a career that spans over seven decades, Lansbury has become one of musical theater’s most beloved performers, known for her ability to reinvent herself with each role. Her performances have ranged from the zany, comedic Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd to the elegant and sophisticated Mame Dennis in Mame, showcasing her vast range as an actress and singer. Lansbury’s portrayal of Mrs. Lovett remains one of her most iconic, capturing the character’s dark humor, obsessive energy, and tragic vulnerability. Her performance in Sweeney Todd became a defining moment in Broadway history, with her interpretation of the role earning her critical acclaim and making her one of the most memorable actresses in the musical theater canon. But Lansbury’s talents go far beyond her Broadway performances. She is a true character actress, able to bring depth, humor, and humanity to every role she tackles. Whether she’s on stage, in film, or on television, Lansbury has a knack for creating unforgettable characters that resonate with audiences. Her career has been a masterclass in reinvention, showing that a true artist can adapt and thrive in an ever-changing entertainment landscape. Angela Lansbury’s legacy is one of boundless creativity, and her influence on Broadway and beyond will continue to inspire artists for generations to come.
7. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is one of Broadway’s brightest stars, known for her infectious energy, vocal agility, and comedic brilliance. She first caught the public’s attention with her Tony Award-winning performance in Thoroughly Modern Millie, a role that immediately established her as a force to be reckoned with in the world of musical theater. Foster’s ability to shine in both comedic and dramatic roles has made her one of the most versatile performers of her generation. Her portrayal of Millie Dillmount in Thoroughly Modern Millie earned her widespread acclaim for her impeccable timing, boundless enthusiasm, and extraordinary singing voice. Her career continued to soar with performances in Anything Goes, where she brought elegance and exuberance to the role of Reno Sweeney, and The Music Man, where her portrayal of Marian Paroo was both charming and heartfelt. Foster’s vocal range and skill in navigating complex musical numbers have made her a favorite among Broadway fans, and her performances are known for their precision and joy. Beyond her incredible vocal talent, Foster is also celebrated for her natural comedic timing and her ability to bring a sense of fun to every performance. She has a rare gift for making audiences feel like they are part of the show, and her energetic stage presence is a hallmark of her career. Sutton Foster is a Broadway treasure, and her ongoing work continues to inspire and captivate theatergoers all over the world.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is a Broadway powerhouse whose voice has captivated audiences worldwide. Known for her soaring vocals and emotional depth, Menzel became a global star with her Tony Award-winning performance as Elphaba in Wicked. Her rendition of “Defying Gravity,” the iconic anthem of the show, has become one of Broadway’s most unforgettable moments. Menzel’s rise to fame didn’t stop at Wicked—her performance as Maureen in Rent established her as a bold new voice in musical theater, blending fierce energy with heartfelt emotion. What sets Menzel apart is her unique ability to convey both power and vulnerability in every performance. Her voice, rich and commanding, can soar effortlessly to breathtaking heights, while still maintaining a sense of warmth and connection with her audience. Menzel’s influence extends far beyond the stage, with her career expanding into film and television. Her role as the voice of Elsa in Disney’s Frozen introduced her to a new generation of fans, and her song “Let It Go” became an anthem for millions. Yet, it is her Broadway performances that continue to be at the heart of her artistic legacy. Whether belting out show-stopping numbers or delivering emotionally charged ballads, Menzel’s performances are always filled with passion and authenticity. Her journey from Rent to Wicked to Frozen proves that Idina Menzel is not only one of Broadway’s most talented performers but also one of its most enduring stars.
9. Lin-Manuel Miranda
Lin-Manuel Miranda is not just a performer, but a revolutionary force in musical theater, known for his ingenious ability to blend hip-hop, Latin rhythms, and traditional musical theater styles. Miranda’s impact on Broadway began with his groundbreaking show In the Heights, where he created a vibrant, pulse-quickening musical about the lives of Washington Heights residents. The show’s success helped pave the way for Hamilton, a cultural phenomenon that changed the face of musical theater. As the creator, writer, and star of Hamilton, Miranda’s sharp lyricism, revolutionary approach to storytelling, and passion for history captivated audiences across the globe. His portrayal of Alexander Hamilton is one of Broadway’s most iconic performances, where he delivered his character’s complex journey with a mix of wit, emotion, and powerful energy. Miranda’s lyrical skill and ability to craft rapid-fire raps while conveying deep emotional depth is nothing short of extraordinary. He redefined what it means to be a Broadway star by offering a fresh and dynamic approach to musical theater. Beyond his stage roles, Miranda’s influence has expanded into film and television, as he worked on projects like Moana and the film adaptation of In the Heights. His involvement in these projects, combined with his ongoing work in Hamilton, proves that Miranda’s creativity knows no bounds. Lin-Manuel Miranda is an artist who has reshaped Broadway and popular culture, and his work will continue to inspire artists and fans for years to come.
10. Carol Channing
Carol Channing was one of Broadway’s most beloved and enduring stars, known for her larger-than-life persona, infectious humor, and distinct, high-pitched voice. Best remembered for her iconic portrayal of Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, Channing’s performance became synonymous with the role, and her joy-filled interpretation of the character captured the hearts of audiences worldwide. Hello, Dolly! was a defining moment in Channing’s career, and her vibrant energy and unique charm lit up the stage, earning her a Tony Award and cementing her place in Broadway history. Channing was more than just a performer; she was a force of nature, whose warmth and comedic timing made her one of the most beloved figures in American theater. Her performances were always filled with a sense of joy and optimism, making her a natural fit for roles that called for larger-than-life characters with heart and humor. In addition to her work in Hello, Dolly!, Channing appeared in a wide variety of other Broadway shows, including Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, where she charmed audiences with her portrayal of the lovable showgirl Lorelei Lee. Offstage, her distinctive voice and unforgettable presence made her a favorite in interviews and television appearances, where her wit and charm shone just as brightly as it did on stage. Carol Channing’s legacy lives on as a symbol of Broadway’s golden age, and her joyful spirit continues to inspire theatergoers around the world.
11. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is a Broadway star whose performances are filled with emotional depth and intensity, establishing him as one of the most respected and cherished voices in musical theater. Known for his striking tenor voice and dramatic skill, Patinkin’s career spans decades, with standout roles in Evita, Sunday in the Park with George, and The Princess Bride. His portrayal of Che in Evita is a defining moment in Broadway history, with Patinkin’s voice effortlessly navigating the demanding vocal lines and delivering the role with a perfect blend of passion and political fervor. In Sunday in the Park with George, Patinkin’s portrayal of the tortured artist George Seurat revealed his exceptional ability to bring vulnerability and complexity to his characters. His talent for balancing vocal power with emotional truth made every song feel deeply personal, and he brought an unmatched sense of intimacy to his performances. Patinkin’s artistry extends beyond Broadway as well, with notable work in television and film. His role as Saul Berenson in Homeland earned him widespread critical acclaim, showcasing his ability to bring depth and nuance to a wide variety of characters. Mandy Patinkin’s career is a masterclass in combining vocal mastery with emotional storytelling, and his profound impact on both Broadway and the wider entertainment industry continues to be felt today. His ability to connect with audiences through both music and performance remains unparalleled.
12. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway favorite whose sparkling soprano voice and infectious personality have made her one of the most beloved stars of the musical theater world. From her Tony Award-winning role as Glinda in Wicked to her many appearances on television, Chenoweth’s career has been defined by her incredible vocal talent, impeccable comic timing, and larger-than-life stage presence. Her portrayal of Glinda, the bubbly, naïve witch in Wicked, quickly became iconic, as her voice soared through the show’s complex musical numbers with a perfect balance of humor and sincerity. Chenoweth’s bright, effervescent personality shone through, making Glinda a character that audiences could not help but fall in love with. Beyond Wicked, Chenoweth has made her mark in numerous Broadway shows, including You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, where her performance as the eternally optimistic and sweet Sally Brown earned her a Tony Award. She’s also been a prominent figure in television, starring in Pushing Daisies and Glee, where her sharp wit and musicality allowed her to stand out in the entertainment world. Chenoweth’s career is a testament to her versatility, with her ability to seamlessly switch between comedic and dramatic roles, all while maintaining a commitment to excellence in her vocal performance. With a powerful combination of humor, vocal skill, and charm, Kristin Chenoweth continues to be one of Broadway’s brightest stars.
13. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a Broadway legend known for her sharp wit, commanding presence, and no-nonsense approach to performing. Her raw, emotional performances and distinctive voice made her a standout in every role she took on, and her remarkable career spanned multiple decades, leaving a lasting mark on the world of musical theater. Stritch’s most iconic role was as the brash, cynical, but ultimately lovable character of the sharp-tongued and strong-willed woman, with her unforgettable performance as “The Ladies Who Lunch” in Company. The song became synonymous with Stritch’s persona — part humor, part melancholy, and all heart. Her ability to mix humor with pathos was unparalleled, giving depth and authenticity to every performance. Beyond Company, Stritch’s career was filled with a variety of Broadway roles, and she captivated audiences with her commanding stage presence in A Little Night Music and The Show Goes On. Stritch was a woman who wasn’t afraid to embrace the darker side of life, and this fearlessness translated into her performances, which were always filled with raw emotion and vulnerability. Her ability to make every character her own, from leading ladies to comic roles, earned her immense respect from both critics and audiences. Offstage, Stritch was known for her candid and unapologetic nature, which only added to her charm and allure. In addition to her Broadway career, she had a memorable presence in television and film, where her no-holds-barred attitude and fearless approach to acting remained consistent. Elaine Stritch’s legacy is one of honesty, wit, and emotional depth — qualities that she brought to every performance, making her an enduring figure in the world of theater.
14. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a trailblazer in Broadway history, known for her electrifying energy, dynamic dancing, and unforgettable performances. A two-time Tony Award winner, Rivera has left an indelible mark on musical theater through her work in iconic productions like West Side Story and Chicago. Rivera’s portrayal of Anita in West Side Story remains one of the defining performances in Broadway history, where her fierce energy and stunning choreography helped elevate the show to legendary status. Her passion for dance and dramatic expression turned every performance into an electrifying experience. After West Side Story, Rivera continued to dazzle audiences with her role as Velma Kelly in Chicago. Her portrayal of the glamorous, sharp-tongued diva helped define the role and solidified Rivera as a leading lady in musical theater. Rivera’s performances were always marked by a stunning combination of grace, power, and style, which set her apart from her peers and made her a star. Throughout her career, Rivera has displayed unmatched versatility, tackling a wide range of roles in both Broadway and film, with performances in Kiss of the Spider Woman and The Rink. Her ability to balance her breathtaking dance skills with her emotive acting and vocal talent has made her a true triple threat. Chita Rivera’s career is a testament to her dedication to the craft of theater, and she continues to inspire performers to this day with her bold, passionate performances and her incredible contributions to the world of musical theater.
15. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s career has transcended boundaries, making her one of the most influential figures in musical theater across the globe. With her crystalline soprano voice, Salonga has captivated audiences in productions that range from Miss Saigon to Les Misérables and Aladdin, breaking barriers as an Asian actress and performer in a predominantly Western industry. Salonga first gained international recognition when she won a Tony Award for her portrayal of Kim in Miss Saigon. Her performance in this role, which calls for incredible vocal range and emotional depth, earned her widespread acclaim and marked the beginning of a long and successful career on both stage and screen. Following Miss Saigon, Salonga’s career blossomed with notable roles in Les Misérables, where she played the role of Fantine, and Aladdin, where she voiced the role of Princess Jasmine. Her ability to embody both emotional complexity and vocal precision has made her a celebrated performer, beloved by fans around the world. Salonga’s achievements have extended beyond the stage, with her appearances on international talent shows like The Voice in the Philippines, where she continued to inspire new generations of performers. Her powerful voice and ability to connect with her audience remain unmatched, and her work continues to be a shining example of what it means to be a global ambassador for musical theater. Lea Salonga has become a trailblazer, breaking down cultural and professional boundaries while inspiring audiences with her unwavering commitment to the craft of performance.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
