Broadway has long been the beating heart of musical theater, dazzling audiences with its larger-than-life performances, unforgettable melodies, and, most importantly, its legendary singers. From the electrifying belts that bring audiences to their feet to the delicate, emotional notes that leave us in tears, Broadway singers are true masters of their craft. These performers don’t just sing; they embody characters, tell stories, and transport us to entirely new worlds—all while hitting notes that seem impossible.
In this article, we celebrate the crème de la crème of Broadway, the artists whose voices not only defined the Great White Way but also became cultural touchstones that inspire generations. These are the singers who made us believe in love, hope, and the power of a single, breathtaking note. From golden-era icons to contemporary trailblazers, each name on this list represents a unique blend of vocal brilliance, stage presence, and an indelible mark on the history of musical theater.
Whether you’re a lifelong theater aficionado or new to the magic of Broadway, prepare to relive the magic, charisma, and unmatched talent of the Top 15 Best Broadway Singers of All Time. Let the spotlight shine on these legends, and let their voices echo forever!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman wasn’t just a Broadway star—she was Broadway. Dubbed the “Queen of Broadway,” she possessed a voice that could cut through an orchestra, filling theaters with a bold, brassy sound that became her trademark. Before microphones were common in musical theater, Merman’s powerful projection ensured that every lyric reached the back row. Her unmistakable vibrato and commanding stage presence made her an unforgettable force in the golden age of Broadway.
Merman rose to fame in the 1930s and quickly became the go-to leading lady for composers like Irving Berlin, Cole Porter, and George Gershwin. Her performance in Anything Goes solidified her status as a Broadway legend, but it was her portrayal of Annie Oakley in Annie Get Your Gun that gave her one of her most iconic anthems: “There’s No Business Like Show Business.” No one could sell a song quite like Merman—her delivery was crisp, punchy, and filled with unwavering confidence.
In 1959, Merman starred as Mama Rose in Gypsy, widely considered one of the greatest musicals of all time. Her performance of “Everything’s Coming Up Roses” was so electrifying that it remains the definitive version of the song. Though she never transitioned into Hollywood superstardom, her Broadway legacy was so immense that it hardly mattered.
Even today, Merman’s influence can be felt in every powerhouse belter who dares to take center stage. Her larger-than-life presence, impeccable comedic timing, and unparalleled vocal strength set a standard that few have matched. She was, in every sense, a Broadway institution—bold, fearless, and utterly unforgettable.
2. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews embodies grace, elegance, and an almost otherworldly vocal purity that has captivated audiences for decades. Though she became a global household name through film, her roots in Broadway were just as significant, helping to define the golden era of musical theater. Her pristine, bell-like soprano voice set her apart, making her one of the most beloved performers of all time.
Her Broadway breakthrough came in 1956 when she starred as Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady. At just 20 years old, she delivered an unforgettable performance, mastering both the comedic charm and emotional depth of the role. Songs like “I Could Have Danced All Night” and “Wouldn’t It Be Loverly” showcased her crystal-clear vocal tone and impeccable phrasing. Though she didn’t get to reprise the role in the film adaptation, her performance on stage remains legendary.
Andrews followed up with another triumph in Camelot (1960), playing Queen Guinevere opposite Richard Burton. Her rendition of “The Simple Joys of Maidenhood” and “Before I Gaze at You Again” further cemented her reputation as one of Broadway’s finest vocalists. However, it was her transition to film that made her a worldwide icon, beginning with Mary Poppins (1964), which won her an Academy Award.
Despite moving away from Broadway, Andrews’ influence on musical theater never waned. Her exquisite voice, impeccable diction, and unmatched storytelling ability have inspired countless performers. Even after losing her singing voice due to a surgical mishap, her legacy remains untouchable. Whether in the grand theaters of Broadway or the magical landscapes of Hollywood, Julie Andrews’ performances continue to set the gold standard for musical excellence.
3. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a Broadway powerhouse whose unparalleled vocal ability and emotional depth have solidified her place as one of the greatest performers in theater history. With a record-breaking six Tony Awards to her name, she has dominated the stage in a way few others have, seamlessly moving between classical, jazz, and musical theater with breathtaking skill.
McDonald first gained widespread recognition in Carousel (1994), where her portrayal of Carrie Pipperidge earned her the first of many Tony Awards. Her voice, a rich and expressive soprano, instantly captivated audiences, and her ability to bring layered emotion to every lyric set her apart. She continued to showcase her versatility in Ragtime (1998), playing Sarah, a role that required her to balance delicate vulnerability with overwhelming passion. Her rendition of “Your Daddy’s Son” remains one of the most moving performances in Broadway history.
Throughout her career, McDonald has taken on roles that challenge conventions, including Bess in Porgy and Bess (2012), where she redefined the character with a performance full of grit, warmth, and sheer vocal power. Her portrayal of Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill (2014) was nothing short of transformative, earning her yet another Tony Award. She fully embodied the troubled jazz singer, her voice trembling with pain one moment and soaring with defiant beauty the next.
Beyond Broadway, McDonald has made a lasting impact in television, film, and concert performances, further proving her versatility and artistry. But no matter the stage or setting, her ability to blend flawless technique with raw emotion makes every performance unforgettable. With each role she takes on, Audra McDonald continues to push boundaries, proving that she is truly one of a kind in the world of theater.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is the embodiment of Broadway stardom, a true diva who has captured audiences with her electrifying presence and powerhouse voice. Known for her larger-than-life performances, LuPone has made a mark on the theater world through her dynamic range, impeccable delivery, and emotional intensity. Her career spans over four decades, and she remains one of the most revered names in musical theater.
LuPone’s breakthrough came with her portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita (1979), which earned her a Tony Award. Her rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” is still considered one of the most iconic performances in Broadway history. LuPone’s ability to transform into a character with such depth and passion made her an instant star, and she has maintained that same level of brilliance throughout her career.
Her role as Mama Rose in Gypsy (2008) is another highlight, showcasing her commanding stage presence and her ability to deliver a deeply emotional performance. The character of Rose demands a combination of raw emotion, vulnerability, and strength, and LuPone embodied all of these traits with ease. Her performance of “Everything’s Coming Up Roses” remains one of the most rousing and unforgettable moments in Broadway history.
LuPone’s Broadway credits also include Les Misérables, War Paint, Sweeney Todd, and many others. Her ability to excel in both dramatic and comedic roles has made her one of the most versatile and respected actresses in musical theater. Off the stage, LuPone has become known for her candid personality and willingness to speak her mind, further cementing her status as a true Broadway icon. Her impact on the industry cannot be overstated, and her legendary performances continue to captivate audiences everywhere.
5. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is a Broadway legend whose ethereal voice and extraordinary talent have made her a beloved figure in musical theater for over five decades. Known for her delicate yet powerful soprano voice, Peters brings both vulnerability and strength to every role she takes on, delivering performances that resonate deeply with audiences.
Peters rose to fame with her performances in Stephen Sondheim musicals, particularly Into the Woods (1987) and Sunday in the Park with George (1984). In Into the Woods, she portrayed the Witch, a role that demanded a balance of fearsome authority and emotional depth. Peters’ delivery of “Children Will Listen” remains one of the most poignant moments of the production, showcasing her ability to convey deep emotional resonance through song.
Her collaborations with Sondheim have defined much of her career, but her talent extends far beyond one composer. Peters has shown her versatility in roles like the title character in Annie Get Your Gun (1999), where she brought both humor and charm to the role of the iconic sharpshooter, and in Gypsy (2003), where she played the quintessential stage mother, Rose. Her portrayal of Rose, like LuPone’s, was a masterclass in emotional complexity, capturing the ambition and love behind the character’s demanding nature.
Beyond her stage work, Peters has also made a name for herself in television and film, further proving her range as an artist. But it is on the Broadway stage where she truly shines, and her performances continue to inspire and captivate new generations of theatergoers.
6. Lin-Manuel Miranda
Lin-Manuel Miranda is one of the most innovative and influential voices in modern Broadway. As the creator and star of Hamilton, Miranda redefined what musical theater could be by blending hip-hop, jazz, and traditional musical theater in groundbreaking ways. His ability to merge storytelling with diverse musical styles has earned him acclaim across all artistic disciplines, and his impact on Broadway is nothing short of revolutionary.
Miranda’s journey began with his first musical, In the Heights (2008), which he wrote and starred in. The show was a huge success, earning Miranda his first Tony Award and establishing him as a major creative force in musical theater. The story of a tight-knit Latinx community in Washington Heights resonated with audiences, and Miranda’s dynamic, rhythm-driven music became an integral part of the show’s charm.
However, it was Hamilton (2015) that truly catapulted Miranda into the global spotlight. The musical’s unconventional blend of historical storytelling and modern-day music captured the imagination of audiences around the world. Miranda’s portrayal of Alexander Hamilton in the show was both energetic and emotional, while his writing pushed boundaries and addressed themes of identity, legacy, and revolution. “My Shot” and “The Room Where It Happens” became anthems, and Hamilton broke records, winning multiple Tony Awards and a Pulitzer Prize for Drama.
In addition to his Broadway work, Miranda has contributed to film and television, writing music for Disney’s Moana (2016) and appearing in films like Mary Poppins Returns (2018). His impact extends beyond the theater world, influencing an entire generation of artists and theatergoers. With his bold, innovative approach to storytelling, Lin-Manuel Miranda has permanently changed the landscape of Broadway.
7. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury’s career spanned over 70 years, and throughout that time, she became one of the most beloved and versatile actresses in the history of theater and television. Known for her remarkable ability to tackle a wide variety of roles, Lansbury’s Broadway career cemented her place as a true icon. From comedy to drama, Lansbury’s performances captivated audiences with her skillful acting, impeccable timing, and warmth.
Her most iconic Broadway roles include the roles of Mame Dennis in Mame (1966) and Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (1979). Lansbury’s performance as Mame, the free-spirited woman with a heart of gold, won her a Tony Award and showcased her knack for combining humor and depth. However, it was her portrayal of Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd that truly displayed Lansbury’s acting range. Her sharp comedic timing, combined with a dark, haunting portrayal of the character, earned her another Tony Award and solidified her legacy as a masterful performer.
Lansbury’s career also included notable film and television roles, with her most famous being her portrayal of Jessica Fletcher in the long-running TV series Murder, She Wrote (1984-1996). Her ability to bring charm, wit, and intelligence to the role made her a household name, and the show’s success demonstrated her immense popularity beyond the stage.
Angela Lansbury was a true triple threat, known for her ability to sing, act, and dance with grace and professionalism. Her impact on Broadway and the entertainment world cannot be overstated, and her performances continue to resonate with audiences even after her passing in 2022.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is one of Broadway’s most powerful and beloved voices. Known for her commanding stage presence and exceptional vocal ability, Menzel first rose to fame with her role as Elphaba in Wicked (2003), where her performance of “Defying Gravity” became an anthem for fans around the world. Her ability to sing with both power and nuance made her the perfect fit for the role of the misunderstood witch, and her portrayal remains one of the most iconic in recent Broadway history.
Menzel’s Broadway career also includes memorable performances in Rent (1996), where she played the role of Maureen Johnson, an eccentric and bold character whose solo “Over the Moon” became an instant fan favorite. She later went on to star in If/Then (2014), a show that allowed her to explore the complexities of a woman’s life choices, balancing the personal and professional in a deeply moving way.
Beyond Broadway, Menzel’s career reached new heights with her role as the voice of Elsa in Disney’s Frozen (2013), where her performance of “Let It Go” became a worldwide phenomenon. The song became a rallying cry for independence and self-expression, showcasing Menzel’s vocal range and emotional resonance.
Idina Menzel’s voice is a force to be reckoned with, and her performances continue to captivate audiences around the world. Whether on stage or in the recording studio, she is a true Broadway icon, and her contributions to musical theater and film have solidified her as one of the most influential performers of her generation.
9. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is one of Broadway’s brightest stars, known for her sparkling personality and exceptional vocal range. With a voice that blends operatic clarity and musical theater warmth, she has captivated audiences in a variety of roles across Broadway, television, and film. Best known for her role as Glinda in Wicked (2003), Chenoweth brought a lighthearted yet deeply human touch to the character of the good witch. Her portrayal of Glinda was marked by impeccable comedic timing, charm, and a voice that could soar through both high notes and tender moments with ease.
Chenoweth’s success on Broadway extends far beyond Wicked. Her Tony Award-winning performance as the flighty and lovable Sally in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown (1999) showcased her ability to play both sweet and complex characters with finesse. She also starred in Promises, Promises (2010), earning rave reviews for her portrayal of the feisty secretary, Fran Kubelik, originally played by Shirley MacLaine in the film version. Chenoweth’s versatile voice allowed her to effortlessly glide through ballads, belting out high notes with precision, while also delivering comedic lines with expert timing.
In addition to her stage work, Chenoweth has built a notable career in television, including starring in Pushing Daisies (2007-2009), for which she won an Emmy Award. Her career spans both the stage and the small screen, showcasing her versatility as a performer who excels in both comedic and dramatic roles.
Kristin Chenoweth’s infectious energy, incredible vocal talent, and ability to connect with audiences make her one of the most beloved performers of her generation. Whether she is on Broadway or in front of the camera, her performances continue to be a testament to her remarkable skill and boundless charisma.
10. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is a powerhouse baritone whose rich voice and emotional depth have made him one of Broadway’s most respected and beloved performers. With his commanding presence and exceptional vocal artistry, Patinkin has captured audiences’ hearts in a career that spans decades. His ability to convey intense emotion through song, coupled with his dramatic prowess, has made him a standout in both theater and television.
Patinkin’s career took off with his portrayal of Che in Evita (1979), where he brought both passion and conviction to the role of the Argentine revolutionary. His performance of “Oh What a Circus” is still considered one of the most stirring renditions of any Broadway song. His time in Evita helped establish him as a major Broadway talent, but it was his portrayal of the title character in Sunday in the Park with George (1984) that truly showcased his depth as an actor. In this Stephen Sondheim musical, Patinkin brought to life the artist Georges Seurat, a role that demanded both vulnerability and artistry. His song “Finishing the Hat” remains a powerful moment in musical theater history.
Beyond Broadway, Patinkin has enjoyed success in television, most notably in Homeland (2011-2019), where his portrayal of Saul Berenson earned him critical acclaim. Patinkin’s ability to transition between musical theater and dramatic television further showcases his immense talent.
What sets Patinkin apart is his ability to make every performance feel deeply personal. His emotive delivery, combined with a voice that resonates with both strength and tenderness, has made him a respected figure in the entertainment world. Mandy Patinkin is a true artist whose performances continue to move audiences across various mediums.
11. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga is a star whose voice transcends the stage and resonates with fans across the globe. Known for her crystal-clear soprano and ability to deliver songs with both power and subtlety, Salonga has earned international acclaim for her Broadway performances, as well as her contributions to film and television.
Salonga’s Broadway career began with her Tony Award-winning performance as Kim in Miss Saigon (1991), where she portrayed the tragic character of a young Vietnamese woman caught in the throes of war. Salonga’s performance of “I Still Believe” and “Sun and Moon” brought immense emotional depth to the show, and her role in Miss Saigon earned her critical praise and the prestigious Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical.
Salonga’s talent extends beyond the Broadway stage, as she has also been the voice of two beloved Disney princesses: Jasmine in Aladdin (1992) and Mulan in Mulan (1998). Her performances of “A Whole New World” and “Reflection” became iconic, further solidifying her place in the hearts of fans worldwide.
In addition to her work in musical theater and animation, Salonga has found success as a television personality and recording artist. Her appearances on The Voice (Philippines) and her solo concerts have allowed her to showcase her versatility, connecting with audiences both young and old.
Lea Salonga’s voice remains one of the most recognizable and celebrated in musical theater. Her unparalleled vocal skill, combined with her grace and presence, makes her a true icon whose influence continues to inspire the next generation of performers.
12. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is one of the most iconic performers in Broadway history, known for her dazzling dance moves, fierce stage presence, and powerful singing voice. A true trailblazer, Rivera made her Broadway debut in the original production of West Side Story (1957), where she played Anita, the fiery and passionate member of the Puerto Rican community. Rivera’s electrifying portrayal of Anita became a defining moment in musical theater, and her performance of “America” is still regarded as one of the greatest dance numbers in Broadway history.
Rivera went on to become a Broadway legend, starring in some of the most memorable shows of the 20th century, including Chicago (1975) and Kiss of the Spider Woman (1993). In Chicago, Rivera’s portrayal of Velma Kelly was the epitome of sultry sophistication, and her performance of “All That Jazz” became a signature number for the production. In Kiss of the Spider Woman, Rivera’s portrayal of the enigmatic Spider Woman earned her a Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical, solidifying her place in Broadway history.
Known for her stamina and ability to captivate audiences with both her dancing and singing, Rivera remains a living legend in musical theater. Her contributions to Broadway have paved the way for generations of performers, and her indelible influence can still be felt today. Rivera’s performances continue to inspire and awe audiences, making her a true Broadway treasure.
13. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is widely regarded as one of Broadway’s last true leading men, known for his powerful baritone and commanding stage presence. His rich, soulful voice and charismatic performances have made him a fixture in the world of musical theater. Mitchell’s vocal prowess and emotional depth have earned him critical acclaim in a wide variety of roles, but it is his work in shows like Ragtime (1998) and Kiss Me, Kate (1999) that truly cemented his status as one of the premier Broadway artists of his generation.
In Ragtime, Mitchell played the role of Coalhouse Walker Jr., a proud African-American man whose life is shattered by tragedy and racial injustice. His performance of the iconic song “Make Them Hear You” became one of the emotional highlights of the show, with Mitchell’s resonant baritone filling the theater with both power and hope. His ability to convey profound emotion while maintaining technical precision is a hallmark of his artistry.
Mitchell’s performance in Kiss Me, Kate, where he starred as the dashing Fred Graham, also demonstrated his versatility. He seamlessly blended his dramatic talents with his impressive vocal technique, creating a portrayal of Fred that was both humorous and heartfelt. Mitchell’s ability to balance comedy with the emotional weight of his roles is one of the reasons why he remains such a respected figure in musical theater.
Beyond the stage, Brian Stokes Mitchell has also had success in television and film, showcasing his vocal talent and dynamic range. His recordings, concerts, and various performances continue to garner admiration from both fans and critics alike. Mitchell’s legacy as a leading man of Broadway is undeniable, and his influence on the stage will undoubtedly inspire future generations of performers.
14. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand is a name that needs little introduction. Known for her incomparable voice, remarkable versatility, and groundbreaking career, Streisand has solidified herself as one of the most influential entertainers of all time. While her Broadway career was relatively brief compared to her achievements in film and music, her performances in Funny Girl (1964) and I Can Get It for You Wholesale (1962) are among the most iconic in theater history.
In Funny Girl, Streisand’s portrayal of Fanny Brice, the pioneering comedic actress and singer, became an instant sensation. Her voice, with its unique blend of power, vulnerability, and emotional depth, brought Brice to life in a way that was both humorous and deeply moving. The song “Don’t Rain on My Parade” became synonymous with Streisand’s bold, show-stopping performance, and the role earned her the Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical.
Streisand’s influence, however, extends far beyond Broadway. Her career in film and music has earned her numerous accolades, including multiple Grammy Awards, Oscars, and Golden Globes. From her iconic performances in films like Funny Girl and Yentl to her successful recording career, Streisand has remained a cultural touchstone for decades. Her voice, characterized by its ability to convey profound emotion, continues to resonate with listeners around the world.
Barbra Streisand is a true legend, and her impact on both the stage and the music industry is immeasurable. She remains a trailblazer for future generations of performers, and her unparalleled artistry ensures her place in the pantheon of musical theater greats.
15. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster has earned her place as one of Broadway’s brightest stars with her exuberant personality, versatile voice, and remarkable technical skill. Known for her incredible range and remarkable ability to bring both humor and heart to her roles, Foster has captured the hearts of audiences with her performances in Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002), Anything Goes (2011), and Violet (2014). Foster’s performances are always full of energy, charm, and the kind of technical brilliance that keeps audiences on the edge of their seats.
Foster’s role in Thoroughly Modern Millie, where she portrayed the wide-eyed Millie Dillmount, earned her a Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical. Her portrayal was a masterclass in comedic timing and vocal dexterity, as she effortlessly navigated through the show’s catchy tunes and comedic moments. She brought a sense of joy and innocence to Millie, making her one of Broadway’s most beloved characters.
In Anything Goes, Foster demonstrated her ability to balance high-energy numbers with heartfelt moments. As the ambitious but charming Hope Harcourt, Foster’s performance of the show’s title song, “Anything Goes,” was one of the show’s highlights, showcasing her vocal range and ability to hold the stage with an electric presence.
Beyond her Broadway performances, Sutton Foster is also known for her television roles, most notably in the hit show Younger (2015-2021), where she starred as Liza Miller, a 40-year-old woman navigating life and love in the world of publishing. Her portrayal brought her even more fans, who continue to appreciate her humor, warmth, and incredible talent.
Sutton Foster is a Broadway mainstay whose voice, personality, and immense range have made her a favorite among fans and critics alike. With each new role, Foster continues to demonstrate why she is one of the most talented and beloved performers of her generation.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
