Broadway has long been the heart and soul of American theater, a dazzling realm where the magic of music and storytelling intertwine. Within this vibrant landscape, a select group of performers have risen to iconic status, captivating audiences with their extraordinary vocal talents and unforgettable stage presence. In this article, we delve into the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—those who have not only defined musical theater but have also set the standard for excellence in performance.
From the golden age of Broadway to contemporary hits, these artists have brought characters to life through their powerful voices, emotional depth, and unparalleled artistry. Whether belting out show-stopping ballads or delivering heartfelt solos, their performances echo through the halls of history, inspiring generations of theater lovers.
Join us as we celebrate these remarkable talents who have left an indelible mark on the stage. Discover the stories behind their rise to fame, their signature roles, and the incredible impact they’ve had on Broadway and beyond. Get ready to be transported into a world of music, passion, and pure theatrical brilliance as we count down the greatest Broadway singers of all time!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is often hailed as the quintessential Broadway diva, a title she earned through her immense talent and iconic voice that defined the sound of musical theater in its golden age. With her unmistakable brassy, powerful soprano, Merman’s voice could fill an entire theater without the aid of microphones. She is perhaps best known for her unforgettable performances in classic musicals like Annie Get Your Gun, Gypsy, and Anything Goes, where her vocal prowess was on full display.
What set Merman apart from many other Broadway stars of her time was her ability to deliver each note with such force and precision, while still infusing it with raw emotion. Her signature belt, which became her calling card, was not only a testament to her incredible vocal power but also to her impeccable control and technique. Merman’s ability to convey a wide range of emotions through song made her performances feel genuine and deeply personal, even when she was belting out some of Broadway’s most exuberant numbers.
Over her long career, Merman became the epitome of Broadway glamour, and her influence on musical theater singing cannot be overstated. Countless performers have cited her as a primary inspiration, and her legacy lives on through her recordings, which continue to serve as a benchmark for aspiring Broadway vocalists. Whether performing for a packed house on Broadway or recording in the studio, Merman’s larger-than-life persona and indomitable voice made her a legend, and her contributions to the musical theater world continue to inspire generations of artists.
2. Leonard Bernstein
Leonard Bernstein, one of the most important figures in 20th-century music, was much more than just a composer—he was a visionary. His contributions to Broadway, particularly in musicals like West Side Story and Candide, changed the landscape of musical theater forever. A true pioneer, Bernstein blended classical music with Broadway, creating scores that were as complex and innovative as they were accessible. His compositions reflected his deep understanding of both music and human emotion, as he seamlessly merged diverse musical styles.
West Side Story remains one of the most beloved musicals of all time, and Bernstein’s score, with its jazz-infused rhythms and lush melodies, is integral to its success. His ability to capture the pulse of New York City, with its streetwise energy and timeless romance, is apparent in every note of the score. Likewise, his work on Candide offered a blend of operatic complexity with Broadway flair, showcasing Bernstein’s gift for marrying sophistication with entertainment.
As a conductor, Bernstein was equally groundbreaking. His dynamic style, characterized by expressive gestures and an intense connection to the music, revolutionized how orchestras performed. He was a passionate advocate for the integration of music and storytelling, a concept that became a hallmark of his Broadway works. Bernstein’s legacy is not just in the enduring popularity of his musicals but in his influence on generations of composers, conductors, and performers who have been inspired by his ability to push boundaries and redefine what musical theater could be.
3. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand’s name is synonymous with musical excellence, and her incredible contributions to Broadway and beyond have cemented her as one of the most iconic performers of all time. Known for her soaring soprano and unmatched emotional depth, Streisand has captivated audiences in every medium she’s touched, from stage to film to concert halls. Her breakthrough role in Funny Girl was just the beginning of a career that would span over six decades, and her voice, with its remarkable range and clarity, has remained a defining force in the entertainment industry.
Streisand’s interpretation of Fanny Brice in Funny Girl is one of the most iconic performances in Broadway history. With her powerful voice and magnetic presence, she captured the heart of the audience with every note, making songs like “People” and “Don’t Rain on My Parade” unforgettable. Beyond Broadway, Streisand has become a multi-talented artist, earning acclaim for her work in film and her record-breaking concerts. Her ability to transcend genres—from jazz to pop to opera—further solidified her as a musical chameleon, capable of anything.
Her voice is not only technically flawless but emotionally resonant, and she brings a level of depth and sincerity to each song that few can match. Streisand’s incredible versatility allows her to shift effortlessly between comedic roles and deeply emotional, dramatic moments. Her performances resonate with authenticity, and her remarkable ability to make every lyric personal has made her a beloved figure in music. Today, Barbra Streisand continues to inspire new generations of artists, and her legacy as one of the greatest vocalists of all time remains firmly intact.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is nothing short of a Broadway legend, renowned for her powerhouse vocals, magnetic stage presence, and fierce dramatic intensity. With a career spanning over four decades, LuPone has established herself as one of the most iconic and versatile performers in musical theater history. Her unforgettable performances in Evita, Gypsy, and Anything Goes have solidified her as a true force in the world of Broadway, and her talent has earned her numerous accolades, including Tony Awards.
LuPone’s voice is a force to be reckoned with—her vocal control is impeccable, her range vast, and her ability to belt a show-stopping number is unparalleled. What truly sets her apart, however, is her emotional depth and her ability to fully inhabit the characters she portrays. Whether portraying the passionate and ambitious Eva Perón in Evita or the fiery, indomitable Mama Rose in Gypsy, LuPone brings an authenticity and vulnerability to her performances that resonates deeply with audiences.
What makes Patti LuPone’s performances so compelling is her fearless approach to the material. She pours every ounce of emotion into her characters, leaving nothing behind. Her dramatic intensity and her fearless commitment to her craft are what have made her a favorite among both theatergoers and fellow performers. Throughout her storied career, LuPone has continuously pushed the boundaries of musical theater, proving time and again that she is one of the greatest talents to ever grace the Broadway stage.
5. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald’s talent transcends the boundaries of Broadway, cementing her as one of the most celebrated and versatile performers of her generation. With an astonishing six Tony Awards to her name, McDonald’s contributions to the world of theater are unmatched. Her performances in Ragtime, Porgy and Bess, and The Gershwins’ Porgy and Bess have showcased not only her incredible vocal range but also her ability to bring profound emotional resonance to every role she tackles.
What makes Audra McDonald stand out is her sheer versatility. She effortlessly switches between different musical styles, from classical to jazz to gospel, all while maintaining a voice that is warm, rich, and powerful. Her ability to effortlessly navigate complex musical passages while still delivering an emotionally charged performance is a rare gift. McDonald’s performances never feel forced or artificial; she brings a natural ease and grace to her singing that immediately connects with her audience.
Her powerful stage presence is another defining feature of McDonald’s performances. She doesn’t just sing a song—she inhabits the character completely. Whether playing the dignified, tragic Bess in Porgy and Bess or the optimistic, fiercely determined Sarah in Ragtime, McDonald’s performances are always deeply nuanced and layered. Her remarkable ability to bring truth and depth to each character she plays ensures that she remains one of Broadway’s greatest treasures, and her legacy will continue to inspire future generations of theater artists.
6. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is one of the shining stars of Broadway, celebrated for her captivating stage presence, enchanting voice, and unparalleled artistry. With a career that has spanned over five decades, Peters has become a beloved figure in the theater world, bringing a rare blend of charm, sophistication, and emotional depth to every role she plays. From her standout performances in Into the Woods to Song and Dance, Peters has earned critical acclaim for her remarkable vocal range and ability to transform into her characters with ease.
Peters’s voice is often described as ethereal—smooth and rich, yet capable of cutting through the emotional complexity of her roles. Her ability to evoke tenderness, longing, and joy with such grace is one of the reasons why audiences have fallen in love with her time and again. Whether singing Stephen Sondheim’s intricate melodies or the more lighthearted tunes of other Broadway composers, Peters imbues every note with such depth and sincerity that it’s impossible not to be drawn into her world.
Her role as the Witch in Into the Woods remains one of her most iconic performances. Peters’s ability to balance both comedic timing and emotional vulnerability made her portrayal of the complex character unforgettable. She brought a humanity to the Witch, making her not just a villain but a fully realized, multi-dimensional character. Similarly, in Song and Dance, Peters demonstrated her ability to command the stage both vocally and physically, further proving her versatility as a performer.
Over the years, Bernadette Peters has become a living legend in the world of musical theater, inspiring countless aspiring artists with her impeccable technique, infectious enthusiasm, and undying passion for the stage. Her legacy is not just in her numerous accolades and Tony Awards but in the way she has made every performance an unforgettable experience.
7. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a trailblazer in the world of musical theater, known for her dynamic energy, groundbreaking performances, and incredible versatility. With a career that stretches back over 70 years, Rivera has been a key figure in the development of Broadway, especially when it comes to creating roles that are now considered iconic. Her work in West Side Story and Chicago has earned her a permanent place in Broadway history, and her influence extends far beyond her stunning performances.
Rivera’s most celebrated role was that of Anita in West Side Story, where her performance captured both the fiery spirit and vulnerability of the character. Her commanding presence, sharp dance moves, and fiery vocals made her a force to be reckoned with on stage. Similarly, her portrayal of Velma Kelly in Chicago is one of the defining moments of her career. Rivera’s combination of impeccable vocal technique, raw emotional expression, and dazzling stage presence elevated the role to new heights, and it’s no wonder that she became the gold standard for that character.
Known for her vibrant energy, Chita Rivera has always had a special way of connecting with her audience. Her performances are full of life and passion, whether she’s dancing, singing, or delivering a dramatic monologue. But beyond her physicality and vocal abilities, Rivera’s true gift lies in her ability to infuse each role with depth, making each character feel both authentic and larger than life.
Chita Rivera’s legacy extends far beyond the stage. She has been a mentor and inspiration to countless performers, and her groundbreaking achievements have helped to pave the way for future generations of artists. Her name is synonymous with excellence in musical theater, and she remains one of the greatest performers to ever grace the Broadway stage.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s journey from Broadway star to global pop culture icon is one of the most remarkable stories in modern theater. Known for her powerhouse vocals, emotional depth, and versatility, Menzel became a household name thanks to her iconic portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked. Her performance in the role, particularly her rendition of “Defying Gravity,” is considered one of the defining moments in the history of musical theater, and it catapulted her into the spotlight.
Menzel’s vocal range is extraordinary, and she has the unique ability to convey raw emotion through her singing, connecting deeply with her audience. As Elphaba, she captured the heart of the character—her strength, vulnerability, and resilience—and transformed the role into something unforgettable. Menzel’s rendition of “Defying Gravity” continues to resonate with audiences around the world, not just for its technical difficulty but for the sheer emotion she pours into every note.
Beyond Wicked, Menzel has continued to shine in a variety of roles across theater, film, and television. Her performance in the film adaptation of Rent garnered critical acclaim, and she also captured hearts with her role as the voice of Elsa in Disney’s Frozen. Her hit song “Let It Go” from the film became a worldwide phenomenon, further cementing her place in pop culture.
Menzel’s success can be attributed not only to her vocal abilities but also to her innate charisma and relatability. She has become a role model for aspiring performers, inspiring many with her ability to break barriers and achieve success on her own terms. Whether on stage or screen, Idina Menzel’s passion and talent continue to captivate audiences everywhere, ensuring her lasting place as one of Broadway’s modern icons.
9. Michael Crawford
Michael Crawford is best known for his legendary portrayal of the Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera, a role that became synonymous with his name and solidified him as one of the most beloved performers in musical theater history. His portrayal of the tortured genius Phantom, with his hauntingly beautiful voice and deeply emotional performance, captivated audiences from the first note. Crawford’s ability to express both the Phantom’s tragic vulnerability and his dark, obsessive passion made the role one of the most iconic in musical theater history.
His journey with The Phantom of the Opera was transformative, not only for the character but for Crawford himself. He brought a raw emotional intensity to the role that made the Phantom more than just a villain. His portrayal resonated with audiences on a deeply personal level, and his powerful renditions of songs like “Music of the Night” and “The Phantom of the Opera” are still remembered as some of the most stunning performances in theater.
Beyond Phantom, Crawford’s career includes a wide range of roles in both musical theater and television, showcasing his remarkable versatility as a performer. Whether in comedic roles or more dramatic pieces, Crawford always brought a sense of dedication and integrity to his performances. His voice, which is both operatic and full of nuance, has made him a standout in every role he has taken on.
Michael Crawford’s impact on musical theater extends far beyond his performance in The Phantom of the Opera. His career is a testament to his commitment to his craft and his ability to bring characters to life in ways that few others can. His legacy lives on through his unforgettable portrayal of the Phantom and his contributions to the world of musical theater as a whole.
10. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga is a global treasure, known for her breathtaking voice and unmatched emotional depth. From her Tony Award-winning performance as Kim in Miss Saigon to her roles in Les Misérables and Aladdin, Salonga has become one of the most respected and admired performers in musical theater. Her powerful soprano voice, which is both clear and full of resonance, has captivated audiences around the world, making her one of the most iconic voices in Broadway history.
Salonga’s role as Kim in Miss Saigon remains one of the defining moments of her career. Her portrayal of the tragic young woman caught between love and loss resonated with audiences deeply, and her performance of “I Still Believe” is still regarded as one of the most moving songs in musical theater. Salonga’s ability to convey such complex emotions with grace and authenticity made her an instant star, and her career has continued to flourish ever since.
Beyond her theater work, Lea Salonga has also enjoyed a successful career as a recording artist and television personality. Her participation as a judge on The Voice Philippines further solidified her place as a multifaceted talent who is equally at home in the world of television as she is on stage. Salonga’s warm, nurturing personality has made her a beloved figure to millions of fans worldwide, and her voice continues to inspire aspiring artists everywhere.
Lea Salonga’s legacy in musical theater is undeniable. She is not only a powerhouse vocalist but also a true artist, able to infuse every performance with sincerity and emotional depth. Her contributions to Broadway, film, and international theater have made her a beloved figure in the entertainment industry, and her place in musical theater history is firmly secured.
11. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is one of Broadway’s most celebrated and versatile performers, known for his rich baritone voice and commanding stage presence. With a career spanning over four decades, Mitchell has captivated audiences with his ability to seamlessly blend classical Broadway styles with contemporary flair. His performances in Kiss Me, Kate, Ragtime, and Man of La Mancha showcase not only his vocal prowess but also his skill at portraying deeply complex characters with emotional depth and authenticity.
Mitchell’s voice is one of the defining characteristics of his career. His baritone is rich and resonant, capable of filling a theater with warmth and power. Whether singing the classic show tunes of Broadway’s golden age or the more contemporary works of modern theater, Mitchell brings a sense of elegance and strength to every performance. His ability to tackle both dramatic roles and more lighthearted characters with equal skill has made him one of the most sought-after performers in the business.
His role as Coalhouse Walker Jr. in Ragtime is often considered one of his most powerful performances. In this role, Mitchell conveyed the deep pain and anger of his character, bringing to life the struggles of a man fighting for justice in a racially divided America. His performance of “Make Them Hear You” remains one of the most emotionally charged and stirring moments in the show, and it cemented his place as one of Broadway’s leading men.
Beyond his work on stage, Mitchell has also appeared in television and film, further proving his versatility as a performer. His appearances in shows like The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air and Trapper John, M.D. have showcased his ability to bring depth and charm to roles in different genres. Whether on Broadway or on screen, Mitchell’s contributions to the world of entertainment are significant, and his enduring legacy is one of excellence and passion.
12. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway star whose immense talent, infectious personality, and unparalleled vocal range have made her one of the most beloved performers of her generation. Known for her role as Glinda the Good Witch in Wicked, Chenoweth’s effervescent charm and impeccable comic timing have earned her a special place in the hearts of theatergoers. But her talents extend far beyond Wicked, and her work on stage, television, and in music showcases her versatility as an entertainer.
Chenoweth’s voice is a defining feature of her performances. With a range that spans from a light soprano to a powerful belt, she is capable of tackling any musical genre with ease. Whether performing show tunes, pop songs, or classical pieces, Chenoweth brings an authenticity to every note she sings. Her performance of “Popular” from Wicked is a testament to her ability to combine vocal excellence with humor and precision, delivering a performance that is both captivating and endlessly entertaining.
Beyond her vocal talent, Chenoweth is known for her infectious personality. Her stage presence is electric, and her ability to connect with audiences is one of the reasons she is so beloved. Her comedic timing is impeccable, and her roles often include a perfect blend of humor and heart. Whether she is playing a lighthearted role in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown or tackling a more serious part in On the Twentieth Century, Chenoweth brings a sense of warmth and joy that is unique to her.
In addition to her theater career, Chenoweth has enjoyed success in television and film, with memorable appearances on shows like Glee and The West Wing. Her work as a recording artist has also garnered attention, and her albums continue to showcase her vocal talent and wide-ranging musical abilities.
Kristin Chenoweth’s impact on Broadway and beyond is undeniable. Her combination of vocal talent, comedic skill, and infectious personality has made her a standout performer, and her place in musical theater history is firmly secured.
13. Vanessa Williams
Vanessa Williams is a performer whose talent knows no bounds. With her stunning vocal abilities, striking beauty, and powerful stage presence, Williams has become one of the most versatile and respected artists in both Broadway and pop music. Breaking barriers with her roles in Kiss of the Spider Woman and her accomplishments in music and film, Williams has proven that she is as comfortable in the spotlight of a Broadway stage as she is in a recording studio or on a movie set.
Williams’ role in Kiss of the Spider Woman marked a pivotal moment in her career, showcasing her vocal prowess and dramatic range. As the mysterious and seductive Spider Woman, Williams delivered a performance that was both haunting and deeply moving. Her ability to convey the complexity of her character, combined with her powerful voice, made her one of the standout performers of the show.
In addition to her Broadway success, Williams has enjoyed a stellar career in pop music, with hits like “Save the Best for Last” and “Dreamin’.” Her ability to seamlessly transition between the worlds of Broadway and pop music has made her a unique and influential figure in the entertainment industry. Williams’ voice, which combines richness with clarity, has made her one of the most recognizable and admired singers of her generation.
Beyond her music and theater work, Williams has also appeared in numerous television shows and films, showcasing her acting talents in a variety of genres. Whether portraying a strong and determined character or a more vulnerable figure, Williams brings depth and authenticity to every role she takes on.
Vanessa Williams’ career is a testament to her versatility and talent. Her contributions to both Broadway and popular culture have made her one of the most respected and enduring performers in entertainment, and her legacy continues to inspire both fans and fellow artists alike.
14. Norm Lewis
Norm Lewis is one of the most groundbreaking performers of his generation, known for his deep, rich voice and trailblazing contributions to Broadway. As one of the first African American actors to portray the Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera, Lewis has played a key role in increasing diversity and representation in musical theater. His remarkable vocal ability, coupled with his commanding stage presence, has made him one of the most respected and sought-after talents in the industry.
Lewis’s portrayal of the Phantom remains a defining moment in his career. His ability to convey the character’s internal conflict and deep emotional pain while maintaining an air of mystery and elegance was groundbreaking. His performance of “Music of the Night” remains one of the most breathtaking renditions of the song ever performed, and his interpretation of the role earned him critical acclaim and a devoted fan base.
Beyond The Phantom of the Opera, Lewis has delivered memorable performances in shows like Porgy and Bess, The Little Mermaid, and Chicago. His powerful baritone and ability to imbue every song with emotional depth have made him a standout performer in every role he’s tackled. Lewis’s voice is both commanding and expressive, allowing him to connect with audiences on a profound level.
In addition to his work on Broadway, Lewis has appeared in various television shows and concert performances, further proving his versatility as an artist. His contributions to musical theater have helped pave the way for greater representation of African American performers on Broadway, and his legacy is one of breaking barriers and elevating the art form.
Norm Lewis’s career is a testament to his incredible talent, passion for the stage, and commitment to expanding the boundaries of musical theater. His achievements have made him a trailblazer and an inspiration to countless performers who follow in his footsteps.
15. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is one of Broadway’s brightest stars, known for her infectious energy, impeccable comic timing, and dazzling vocal abilities. A two-time Tony Award winner, Foster has captured the hearts of audiences with her performances in Thoroughly Modern Millie and Anything Goes, where she has become known for her ability to embody the charm and sophistication of classic musical theater roles while bringing a modern, refreshing flair to the stage.
Foster’s voice is one of her most distinctive qualities. Her bright, clear soprano, combined with her impeccable diction and phrasing, allows her to bring a unique freshness to every role she plays. Whether performing in an upbeat, high-energy number or delivering a tender ballad, Foster’s vocal abilities allow her to connect with her audience in a way that few performers can. Her portrayal of Millie Dillmount in Thoroughly Modern Millie earned her critical acclaim and a Tony Award, showcasing her ability to bring both humor and heart to her characters.
In addition to her success on Broadway, Foster has also become a television star, starring in the hit show Younger, where she plays the lead role of Liza Miller. Her ability to transition seamlessly between Broadway and television has made her one of the most versatile performers of her generation. Whether on stage or screen, Foster brings an energy and joy that is impossible to ignore.
Sutton Foster’s career is a celebration of talent, hard work, and dedication to her craft. Her performances continue to inspire and entertain, and her place in Broadway history is firmly cemented as one of the most beloved stars of the stage.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
