Broadway has long been the heartbeat of American musical theater, where extraordinary talent meets unforgettable storytelling. The stage has welcomed countless performers, but only a select few have achieved the iconic status of Broadway’s best singers. These artists have not only dazzled audiences with their vocal prowess but have also left indelible marks on the theatrical landscape, transforming the way we experience musicals.
From the golden age of Broadway to the modern masterpieces, these vocalists have captivated hearts with their emotion, range, and charisma. Each note sung has the power to transport us to different worlds, evoke deep feelings, and create lasting memories. Whether belting out show-stopping anthems or delivering heart-wrenching ballads, these singers possess an unmatched ability to connect with their audience, making each performance an unforgettable experience.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time, exploring their remarkable careers, iconic performances, and the legacies they’ve built. Join us as we take a thrilling journey through the highs and lows of Broadway’s finest, shining a spotlight on the voices that have defined generations and continue to inspire future artists.
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman, affectionately known as the “First Lady of the American Musical Theater,” reigned as one of Broadway’s brightest stars for decades. Her unmistakable, brassy voice had the power to captivate entire theaters without the need for a microphone—a testament to her vocal prowess and commanding presence. Signature songs like “There’s No Business Like Show Business” and “I Got Rhythm” not only showcased her range but also defined an era of musical theater, embodying the glitz, glamour, and exuberance of the stage.
Merman’s natural ability to connect with audiences was unparalleled, and her energy and confidence made her an icon of her time. Whether belting out a show-stopping tune or delivering witty dialogue, she had an instinctive feel for timing and drama, ensuring that every performance felt fresh and alive. Her career highlights include starring roles in legendary productions such as Annie Get Your Gun, Gypsy, and Anything Goes, each cementing her reputation as an unstoppable force in the theater world.
Beyond her vocal and acting talents, Merman’s work ethic and unshakable professionalism made her a respected figure among her peers. Her influence on Broadway is immeasurable, as she set a standard for performance that continues to inspire generations of performers. Ethel Merman’s contributions to musical theater are timeless, ensuring her legacy as one of the greatest entertainers in American history.
2. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone, a powerhouse performer with an electrifying presence, has become synonymous with some of Broadway’s most demanding and iconic roles. Known for her magnetic stage energy and unmistakable voice, LuPone has delivered unforgettable performances in shows like Evita and Gypsy. Her portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita earned her a Tony Award and showcased her ability to balance ferocity and vulnerability, bringing depth to a role that demands nothing less than perfection.
LuPone’s voice, rich and dramatic, is one of her most defining features. Whether belting out the fiery anthem “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” or delivering the heartbreaking ballad “Rose’s Turn,” her performances are raw, emotional, and utterly captivating. She has a gift for transforming her characters into complex, multi-dimensional figures, making each role she inhabits uniquely her own.
Offstage, LuPone is a vocal advocate for the arts and a beloved figure in the theater community, known for her wit and fearless outspokenness. Her career has spanned decades, yet she continues to push boundaries, taking on new challenges and roles that showcase her versatility. Patti LuPone’s impact on Broadway is undeniable, and her legendary performances ensure she remains a touchstone for excellence in musical theater.
3. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters has enchanted audiences with her signature blend of charm, wit, and unparalleled vocal ability for over five decades. Known for her luminous curls and distinct voice, Peters has brought a unique warmth and emotional depth to every role she’s played. Her performances in Into the Woods and Song and Dance stand as two of her most celebrated achievements, showcasing her ability to seamlessly combine vulnerability and strength.
In Into the Woods, Peters’ portrayal of the Witch was equal parts menacing and heartbreaking, bringing humanity to a character often seen as merely a villain. In Song and Dance, she delivered a Tony-winning performance, masterfully conveying complex emotions through song and movement. Her ability to connect with her audience, whether in joyous or heart-wrenching moments, has made her a standout in the world of musical theater.
Peters is also a dedicated advocate for animal rights and frequently lends her voice to philanthropic efforts, further endearing her to fans worldwide. Her extensive career includes countless accolades, including multiple Tony and Grammy Awards, and she continues to dazzle audiences in concert performances and revivals. Bernadette Peters’ timeless artistry and heartfelt performances ensure her place as one of Broadway’s most beloved stars.
4. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a true phenomenon in the world of musical theater, celebrated for her extraordinary vocal range, emotional intelligence, and ability to tackle roles across a wide spectrum of genres. With six Tony Awards to her name—more than any other performer—McDonald has cemented her status as one of Broadway’s greatest talents. From her riveting portrayal of Bess in Porgy and Bess to her stunning transformation into Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, McDonald’s performances are unforgettable.
Her four-octave range allows her to take on everything from soaring operatic arias to soulful jazz standards, bringing a rare versatility to the stage. As Bess, she infused the role with both strength and fragility, capturing the complexities of a woman yearning for freedom and redemption. In Lady Day, McDonald disappeared into the role of Billie Holiday, delivering a performance so raw and real that audiences felt as though they were witnessing Holiday herself.
In addition to her theatrical accomplishments, McDonald is a tireless advocate for diversity and inclusion in the arts, using her platform to promote social change. Her influence extends far beyond the stage, as she inspires both audiences and aspiring performers alike. Audra McDonald’s unparalleled talent and dedication have redefined what it means to be a Broadway star.
5. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s remarkable voice and heartfelt performances have made her a global sensation in musical theater. Her breakout role as Kim in Miss Saigon earned her a Tony Award, making her the first Asian actress to win this prestigious honor. Salonga’s portrayal of Kim, a young Vietnamese woman caught in the throes of love and war, was both gut-wrenching and inspiring. Her crystal-clear soprano, showcased in songs like “I’d Give My Life for You” and “The Last Night of the World,” brought unparalleled emotional depth to the character, leaving audiences spellbound.
Salonga’s star continued to rise as she took on the role of Éponine in Les Misérables, delivering a hauntingly beautiful rendition of “On My Own.” Her ability to embody the essence of her characters, coupled with her powerful and expressive voice, has made her one of the most beloved performers in musical theater history. Beyond Broadway, Salonga gained further acclaim as the singing voice of Disney princesses Jasmine and Mulan, solidifying her place in pop culture and introducing her talent to millions of fans worldwide.
Known for her warmth and humility, Salonga is a trailblazer for Asian performers in the theater world. Her influence extends beyond her performances as she continues to mentor young artists and advocate for diversity and representation in the arts. Lea Salonga’s extraordinary talent, combined with her genuine connection to audiences, ensures her lasting legacy as a Broadway icon.
6. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is a force to be reckoned with, bringing her powerhouse vocals and commanding stage presence to every role she plays. She skyrocketed to fame with her Tony-winning portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked, where her soaring performance of “Defying Gravity” became an anthem of empowerment and resilience. As the misunderstood green witch, Menzel brought a raw vulnerability and strength to the role, earning her legions of devoted fans and cementing her status as a Broadway superstar.
Before Wicked, Menzel gained recognition as Maureen in the groundbreaking musical Rent. Her fiery and unapologetic portrayal of the bohemian performance artist was a standout in an already stellar cast. Songs like “Take Me or Leave Me” showcased her incredible vocal range and her ability to channel deep emotion through music.
Menzel’s reach extended to an even broader audience when she lent her voice to Elsa in Disney’s Frozen, performing the Oscar-winning hit “Let It Go.” The song’s universal message of self-acceptance resonated with millions, solidifying her place in pop culture history. Despite her success, Menzel remains grounded, often reflecting on her journey and advocating for aspiring performers to pursue their dreams fearlessly.
Whether on stage, screen, or in the recording studio, Idina Menzel continues to inspire with her talent, passion, and authenticity. Her contributions to musical theater and beyond have firmly established her as one of the greatest performers of her generation.
7. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury was a true Renaissance woman in the world of entertainment, leaving an indelible mark on Broadway, film, and television. Her illustrious stage career included unforgettable performances in Mame and Sweeney Todd, roles that showcased her versatility as both a singer and an actress. In Mame, Lansbury brought infectious energy and charm to the role of the eccentric socialite, earning her first Tony Award. Her rendition of “We Need a Little Christmas” remains a quintessential holiday classic, brimming with warmth and optimism.
In Sweeney Todd, Lansbury’s portrayal of Mrs. Lovett was a masterclass in dark humor and musical precision. Her performance of “The Worst Pies in London” perfectly balanced comedic timing with a touch of pathos, making the role one of her most celebrated. Lansbury’s ability to fully inhabit her characters, regardless of their complexity, set her apart as a performer of extraordinary depth.
Outside of Broadway, Lansbury became a beloved figure in television as the star of Murder, She Wrote, where she captivated audiences with her wit and intelligence. Her contributions to the arts earned her numerous accolades, including five Tony Awards, six Golden Globes, and an Honorary Academy Award.
Angela Lansbury’s career spanned over seven decades, and her impact on the world of musical theater remains immeasurable. Her grace, talent, and dedication to her craft continue to inspire performers and audiences alike, ensuring her legacy as a true Broadway treasure.
8. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell, often referred to as “The Last Leading Man” of Broadway, is celebrated for his commanding presence, rich baritone voice, and unmatched charisma. A Tony Award winner for his role in Kiss Me, Kate, Mitchell’s performance was a tour de force, blending humor, charm, and vocal excellence. Songs like “So in Love” and “Where Is the Life That Late I Led?” demonstrated his ability to bring depth and nuance to both comedic and romantic moments.
Another career-defining role came in Ragtime, where Mitchell portrayed Coalhouse Walker Jr., a pianist seeking justice in the face of racial inequality. His powerful rendition of “Make Them Hear You” became an anthem for hope and perseverance, leaving audiences deeply moved. His portrayal captured the pain, dignity, and unyielding resolve of his character, earning him widespread acclaim.
Mitchell’s talents extend beyond the stage, as he is also a sought-after concert performer and a champion of arts education. He frequently collaborates with symphonies and opera companies, showcasing his versatility and love for music in all its forms. His leadership as chairman of The Actors Fund further underscores his commitment to supporting the theater community.
With his magnetic stage presence and remarkable voice, Brian Stokes Mitchell has become one of the most respected figures in musical theater. His contributions continue to elevate the art form, inspiring both his peers and the next generation of performers.
9. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a powerhouse performer who combines comedic brilliance, heartfelt emotion, and extraordinary vocal talent. Her breakout role as Glinda the Good Witch in Wicked catapulted her to Broadway superstardom. With her sparkling soprano and bubbly personality, Chenoweth brought Glinda to life, delivering show-stopping numbers like “Popular” with a perfect blend of humor and charm. Her portrayal added depth to what could have been a one-dimensional character, making Glinda an audience favorite.
Chenoweth’s talent isn’t limited to the Broadway stage. She earned a Tony Award for her role as Sally in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, where her rendition of “My New Philosophy” showcased her comedic timing and vocal agility. On screen, she has appeared in beloved shows such as Pushing Daisies and Glee, proving her versatility as an actress and singer.
Beyond her iconic roles, Chenoweth’s warmth and relatability have made her a beloved figure in the theater community. Whether performing on concert stages, releasing albums, or appearing in television specials, she brings a personal touch to every performance. A trained opera singer with roots in gospel music, she effortlessly moves between genres, showcasing her versatility and passion for the arts.
Kristin Chenoweth’s unique combination of vocal prowess, comedic talent, and genuine charm ensures her legacy as one of the most memorable performers in Broadway history. Her influence continues to inspire countless young artists to pursue their dreams with the same enthusiasm and dedication she brings to her craft.
10. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a trailblazer and a living legend in the world of musical theater. Known for her electrifying performances and unmatched dance skills, Rivera has captivated audiences in iconic roles such as Anita in West Side Story and Velma Kelly in Chicago. Her work in West Side Story established her as a star, with her fiery portrayal of Anita and unforgettable performances of songs like “America” becoming career-defining moments.
In Chicago, Rivera brought her signature flair and charisma to the role of Velma Kelly, showcasing her remarkable talent for combining acting, singing, and dancing into one unforgettable package. Her performance of “All That Jazz” remains one of the most iconic moments in Broadway history, cementing her status as a force to be reckoned with.
Throughout her career, Rivera has broken barriers, becoming one of the first Latina actresses to achieve widespread acclaim on Broadway. Her dedication to her craft and her fearless approach to challenging roles have earned her numerous accolades, including two Tony Awards and the Presidential Medal of Freedom.
Rivera’s contributions to musical theater extend far beyond her performances. She has paved the way for future generations of performers, inspiring artists with her resilience, passion, and groundbreaking achievements. Even after decades in the spotlight, Rivera continues to perform with the same energy and brilliance that made her a legend. Her influence on the theater world is immeasurable, and her legacy is one of talent, perseverance, and an unrelenting love for the stage.
11. Norm Lewis
Norm Lewis is a Broadway powerhouse whose rich baritone voice and magnetic stage presence have made him a standout star. As the first African American to play the title role in The Phantom of the Opera on Broadway, Lewis made history while delivering a deeply nuanced and haunting portrayal of the Phantom. His vocal performance of “The Music of the Night” brought a fresh, emotional depth to the iconic song, earning him widespread acclaim.
Lewis’s career spans an impressive range of roles, showcasing his versatility as both a singer and an actor. In Porgy and Bess, he starred as Porgy alongside Audra McDonald, delivering a heartfelt and commanding performance that earned him a Tony Award nomination. His work in productions like Les Misérables, where he played Javert, further demonstrated his ability to bring complexity and humanity to his characters.
In addition to his stage work, Lewis is a celebrated concert performer, frequently appearing with symphonies and orchestras around the world. His warmth, charisma, and impeccable vocal technique have made him a beloved figure both on and off the stage. He is also deeply committed to mentorship and advocacy, using his platform to support aspiring performers and promote diversity in the arts.
Norm Lewis continues to inspire audiences with his extraordinary talent, professionalism, and dedication to his craft. His groundbreaking achievements and captivating performances have solidified his place as one of Broadway’s most respected and admired artists.
12. Vanessa Williams
Vanessa Williams is a multi-talented performer whose stunning voice and magnetic stage presence have left an indelible mark on Broadway and beyond. Her turn as Aurora in Kiss of the Spider Woman earned her critical acclaim, with her powerful vocals and dramatic interpretation of the role bringing new life to the production. Her performance of “Where You Are” showcased her ability to blend emotional depth with technical precision, leaving audiences mesmerized.
Williams’s versatility is evident in her work across genres. In Into the Woods, she took on the role of the Witch, delivering a compelling performance that balanced humor, menace, and vulnerability. Her rendition of “Last Midnight” was a show-stopper, highlighting her powerful voice and impeccable phrasing.
In addition to her Broadway success, Williams has enjoyed a thriving career as a recording artist, actress, and humanitarian. Songs like “Save the Best for Last” and “Colors of the Wind” from Disney’s Pocahontas have cemented her reputation as a gifted vocalist with a unique ability to connect with her audience.
A trailblazer in her own right, Williams was the first African American woman to be crowned Miss America, breaking barriers and setting the stage for a career defined by excellence and resilience. Her ability to reinvent herself across mediums and her unwavering dedication to her craft make her a true icon in the performing arts. Vanessa Williams’s contributions to Broadway and beyond continue to inspire and captivate audiences worldwide.
13. Tommy Tune
Tommy Tune is a true Broadway renaissance man, celebrated not only for his remarkable performances but also for his extraordinary contributions as a choreographer and director. Standing at an impressive height of 6’6″, his graceful movements and commanding stage presence have dazzled audiences in iconic productions such as The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas and My One and Only.
In The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, Tune’s portrayal of the Sheriff highlighted his charm and natural charisma, blending humor and heart into a performance that won over critics and audiences alike. His role in My One and Only earned him a Tony Award for Best Actor in a Musical, as he delivered show-stopping numbers that showcased his dancing prowess and vocal talent.
As a choreographer and director, Tune’s creative vision has redefined Broadway. He helmed hits like Grand Hotel and Nine, crafting visually stunning productions with innovative choreography and emotional depth. His work earned him a total of 10 Tony Awards, making him one of the most decorated artists in Broadway history.
Tune’s influence extends beyond his performances and productions. As a mentor and advocate for the arts, he has inspired countless performers to pursue their dreams. His dedication to his craft and his ability to bring joy and artistry to every project have solidified his place as a legend in musical theater.
Tommy Tune’s career exemplifies the magic of Broadway, where talent, creativity, and passion come together to create unforgettable moments. His legacy continues to shine brightly, reminding audiences of the transformative power of live performance.
14. Joshua Henry
Joshua Henry has emerged as one of the most electrifying talents on Broadway, captivating audiences with his powerful voice, commanding stage presence, and profound emotional depth. His standout performances in productions like Hamilton and Carousel have solidified his reputation as one of the most versatile performers of his generation.
In Hamilton, Henry portrayed Aaron Burr in the national tour, bringing a fresh and nuanced interpretation to the character. His rendition of “The Room Where It Happens” showcased his vocal brilliance and his ability to convey the ambition and complexity of Burr’s character. His performance was hailed as both dynamic and deeply human, earning him widespread acclaim.
In Carousel, Henry’s portrayal of Billy Bigelow earned him a Tony Award nomination. His heartfelt rendition of “Soliloquy” was a tour de force, blending raw emotion with technical precision. The role required a balance of vulnerability and intensity, and Henry delivered a performance that was both captivating and unforgettable.
Beyond his stage work, Henry is a celebrated concert performer and recording artist. His ability to connect with audiences through storytelling and song has made him a sought-after talent in the theater world. He is also deeply committed to advocating for diversity and inclusion in the arts, using his platform to inspire and uplift future generations of performers.
Joshua Henry’s career continues to soar, and his contributions to Broadway are nothing short of extraordinary. His passion, artistry, and dedication ensure that his performances will be remembered as some of the most powerful in modern theater history.
15. Sara Bareilles
Sara Bareilles, a Grammy-winning singer-songwriter, has seamlessly transitioned from the world of pop music to Broadway, leaving an indelible mark with her heartfelt performances and compelling compositions. Her work in Waitress as both the composer and star has earned her critical acclaim and a devoted following.
Bareilles’s score for Waitress is a masterclass in storytelling through music. Songs like “She Used to Be Mine” and “What Baking Can Do” resonate with audiences on a deeply emotional level, blending vulnerability and strength in a way that feels both personal and universal. When she stepped into the role of Jenna, the show’s protagonist, she brought an authenticity and warmth to the character that elevated the production to new heights. Her portrayal captured the struggles and resilience of a woman seeking to reclaim her happiness, making her performance both relatable and inspiring.
In addition to her work in Waitress, Bareilles has continued to explore opportunities in musical theater, composing music for television productions like Jesus Christ Superstar Live in Concert, where she also starred as Mary Magdalene. Her ability to bridge the gap between pop and theater has brought a fresh perspective to Broadway, introducing new audiences to the magic of live performance.
Bareilles’s influence extends beyond her work on stage. She is a passionate advocate for self-expression and creativity, encouraging others to find their voice and tell their stories. Her journey from chart-topping pop star to celebrated Broadway composer and actress is a testament to her incredible talent and unrelenting dedication to her craft.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
