Broadway is more than just a stage—it’s a realm where dreams take flight, stories come alive, and voices echo through history. Over the years, it has been graced by an extraordinary lineage of performers whose talent transcends time. These singers didn’t just perform; they transformed their characters into living, breathing emotions, leaving audiences spellbound. From soul-stirring ballads to show-stopping anthems, these iconic voices have defined eras, broken boundaries, and inspired generations of theatergoers.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—artists who have shaped the very essence of musical theater. Whether it’s the soaring vibrato of a timeless classic or the electrifying belt of a modern-day legend, these performers have left an indelible mark on the Great White Way. We’ll explore their groundbreaking performances, unforgettable roles, and the magic they brought to the stage.
So, get ready to revisit the voices that made your heart race and your spirit soar. From golden-age greats to contemporary powerhouses, these Broadway icons are the heartbeat of theater, proving that the right voice can make a moment unforgettable—and a legacy eternal. Let the curtain rise on this star-studded tribute!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman, forever known as the “Queen of Broadway,” was a force of nature whose voice and presence transformed musical theater forever. Her booming, brassy belt, which could fill an entire theater without the aid of a microphone, became the hallmark of Broadway itself. Merman’s unparalleled vocal power and her ability to convey a wealth of emotion through her performances made her an icon of the stage. She didn’t just sing; she inhabited every role she took on, from her unforgettable portrayal of Reno Sweeney in Anything Goes to the passionate, larger-than-life Mama Rose in Gypsy. As the “First Lady of Musical Comedy,” Merman’s unique voice became synonymous with the Broadway sound, setting a standard for future generations of performers. One of her most enduring songs, “There’s No Business Like Show Business,” is practically a Broadway anthem and continues to be associated with her unmatched style. Merman’s contributions to musical theater went far beyond her vocal technique; her magnetic stage presence and bold personality left an indelible mark on the world of Broadway. Her style was no-frills, no-nonsense, and delivered with a vivacity that commanded attention. Audiences loved her for her pure showmanship, her humor, and her deep understanding of the roles she played. Merman was more than just a singer; she was a cultural icon, and her influence continues to shape Broadway to this day. Whether in Annie Get Your Gun or Call Me Madam, Ethel Merman wasn’t just performing; she was embodying the very essence of the Broadway experience, and her legacy remains untouchable.
2. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews brought a rare blend of grace, vocal brilliance, and emotional depth to the Broadway stage, making her one of the most cherished figures in musical theater. With a crystalline soprano voice that seemed to capture both purity and power, Andrews enchanted audiences from her early performances. Her portrayal of Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady is still considered one of Broadway’s most iconic performances, as she perfectly captured Eliza’s transformation from a flower girl to a refined lady. Andrews’ vocal precision was matched by her ability to imbue every song with emotional resonance, making her performances not only technically stunning but deeply moving. Beyond the Broadway stage, her film roles solidified her status as a global star, most notably in The Sound of Music and Mary Poppins. In these films, Andrews’ warmth and charm transcended the screen, captivating generations of audiences with her performances. Her Mary Poppins, in particular, became the benchmark for the perfect combination of joy, magic, and maternal care. Whether on stage or on screen, Julie Andrews’ effortless vocal technique, paired with her ability to make each song feel deeply personal and genuine, made her a Broadway legend. Her elegance was always underlined with a sense of relatability, which endeared her to audiences both young and old. Through her career, she became a symbol of musical theater excellence, beloved for her timeless voice and the emotional depth she brought to every role. Julie Andrews continues to inspire, with her legacy standing as a shining example of Broadway’s Golden Age.
3. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a true powerhouse of Broadway, a six-time Tony Award winner who has redefined what it means to be a Broadway leading lady. Her incredible versatility spans opera, jazz, and musical theater, making her one of the most celebrated voices in the theater world today. McDonald’s performances have always been marked by her ability to transcend genres and styles, seamlessly moving between them while maintaining her singular voice. Her portrayal of Carrie Pipperidge in Carousel, her breathtaking performance in Ragtime as the determined and dignified Sarah, and her poignant role as Bess in Porgy and Bess showcase her vast range and emotional depth. Each of these roles allowed McDonald to showcase not only her exceptional vocal technique but her extraordinary ability to convey raw, powerful emotion. Her soaring soprano voice is capable of immense power, yet it is equally adept at conveying tenderness and vulnerability. Audra McDonald’s ability to connect with her audience on a deeply emotional level is one of the reasons why she has become a true Broadway icon. Whether she is singing the beautiful arias of Porgy and Bess or delivering a passionate and heartfelt rendition of “Back to Before” from Ragtime, McDonald’s presence on stage is nothing short of mesmerizing. Few performers can command the stage in the way she does, effortlessly blending technical mastery with emotional truth. McDonald continues to inspire with each performance, proving that Broadway is still capable of producing powerful, groundbreaking theater.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone’s name has become synonymous with Broadway brilliance. A towering figure in musical theater, LuPone has captured the hearts of audiences with her commanding voice, fiery presence, and unrelenting dedication to her craft. Her career has been marked by unforgettable, career-defining performances in some of Broadway’s most iconic musicals. Perhaps most notably, LuPone’s portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita cemented her status as a Broadway legend. Her rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” became an iconic moment in Broadway history, with her bold, passionate delivery making it one of the defining songs of the musical theater canon. LuPone’s fierce commitment to her roles is evident in every performance, whether she’s playing the tough-as-nails Mama Rose in Gypsy, the spirited vocal powerhouse in Sunset Boulevard, or the tortured Fantine in Les Misérables. She brings a level of intensity and vulnerability to her characters that few can match, creating performances that are both breathtaking and deeply moving. LuPone is also known for her deep connection with her audiences. Her willingness to bare her soul on stage and her fearless approach to her roles have made her a beloved figure in the world of musical theater. Her raw power and devotion to storytelling make her one of Broadway’s most influential figures, and her contributions to the stage will continue to inspire new generations of performers for years to come. Patti LuPone’s career is a testament to the transformative power of theater and her ability to bring both heart and fire to every role she takes on.
5. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is the epitome of Broadway charm and sophistication, a performer whose unique voice and deep emotional range have made her one of the most beloved stars of the stage. With her signature curly hair and her ability to convey both vulnerability and strength, Peters has captivated audiences for decades. Her work with legendary composer Stephen Sondheim has been particularly noteworthy, as she has brought a rare level of nuance and understanding to his complex, intricate roles. In Sunday in the Park with George, Peters’ portrayal of Dot brought both tenderness and depth to the character, capturing the spirit of Sondheim’s work with precision and emotion. Similarly, in Into the Woods, she brought a powerful sense of transformation to her role as the Witch, balancing humor, horror, and pathos. Peters’ vocal technique is impeccable, and she has the rare ability to express complex emotions through the smallest nuances of her voice. Her performances are always infused with a level of authenticity that makes them feel deeply personal, and her ability to connect with her audience is unparalleled. Whether she’s singing the hauntingly beautiful “Children Will Listen” in Into the Woods or the poignant “Losing My Mind” in Follies, Peters brings a sense of intimacy and raw emotion to each piece she performs. She has remained one of the most consistent and respected figures on Broadway, and her legacy is one of timeless talent, emotional depth, and a deep love for the art of musical theater.
6. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury was one of Broadway’s most beloved and versatile performers, a true treasure whose stage presence and multifaceted talent left an indelible mark on the world of musical theater. Lansbury’s career spanned several decades, during which she played a wide range of roles that showcased her incredible adaptability and depth as an actress and singer. Her portrayal of the brash and exuberant Mame in Mame earned her one of her many Tony Awards, while her role as the scheming and chilling Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd demonstrated her extraordinary ability to inhabit darker, more complex characters. Lansbury’s voice was warm and rich, with an underlying power that made her one of the most compelling singers on the stage. Her performance in Gypsy as the scheming and ambitious Mama Rose remains iconic, as she effortlessly brought the character’s fire and vulnerability to life. Yet, it was her ability to combine humor, pathos, and a deep understanding of her characters that set her apart. While she became a household name with her portrayal of Jessica Fletcher in the TV series Murder, She Wrote, Lansbury’s Broadway legacy is unmatched. Her extraordinary stage work continues to inspire actors and performers across all genres. Whether portraying a sweet, romantic lead or a villainous matron, Lansbury brought authenticity, heart, and a remarkable level of skill to every role. Her timeless performances in musicals like Sweeney Todd, Mame, and Gypsy remain etched in the minds of Broadway fans, and she will forever be remembered as one of the greats of the theater world.
7. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s name is synonymous with power, precision, and passion, a true force in the world of Broadway whose immense vocal talent has earned her global recognition. Menzel first rose to prominence as Maureen in Rent, but it was her portrayal of the misunderstood Elphaba in Wicked that propelled her into the spotlight. Her performance of “Defying Gravity,” with its soaring notes and intense emotional depth, became one of Broadway’s defining moments. Menzel’s vocal range and control are nothing short of extraordinary, as she effortlessly transitions from heart-wrenching ballads to the powerful belts that have become her trademark. Her voice, capable of reaching both delicate highs and powerful lows, captures the vulnerability and strength of the characters she plays. Her later performances in If/Then and Frozen further solidified her status as one of Broadway’s brightest stars, with the song “Let It Go” becoming a global anthem. Menzel’s contributions to musical theater are characterized not just by her vocal prowess but by her ability to deeply connect with her characters, infusing them with emotional richness that resonates with audiences. Her fearless performances and unapologetic approach to her roles have made her an inspiration to performers worldwide. Whether it’s through the striking drama of Elphaba or the determined, independent Liz in If/Then, Menzel brings a level of intensity and authenticity to each character that makes her a force on Broadway. Idina Menzel has not only redefined modern musical theater but has also become a symbol of resilience and strength.
8. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster has become a household name in the Broadway world, celebrated for her dazzling talent, infectious energy, and undeniable stage presence. A consummate triple threat, Foster is as skilled in dancing as she is in singing and acting, and she’s proven her versatility through a wide array of roles that have captivated audiences. Her breakout performance in Thoroughly Modern Millie earned her a Tony Award, and her portrayal of the optimistic, bubbly Millie Dillmount became one of Broadway’s most iconic characters. Foster’s performances are marked by a sense of joy and enthusiasm that shines through in every song and dance number. Her ability to seamlessly blend comedy with vulnerability has made her a standout performer in shows like Anything Goes, where she played the sprightly, good-hearted Reno Sweeney, and The Drowsy Chaperone, where she brought a delightful sense of wit and charm to her role. Foster’s vocal style is clear, strong, and capable of delivering both the highest notes and the most intricate phrasing with precision. Her charm on stage, combined with her impeccable timing and commitment to her craft, has made her one of the most celebrated performers of her generation. In addition to her Broadway roles, Foster’s television and film appearances have also showcased her talent, further establishing her as a versatile performer. Whether she’s singing a heartwarming ballad or dancing up a storm, Sutton Foster has proven time and time again that she is a force to be reckoned with in the world of musical theater.
9. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was Broadway’s ultimate scene-stealer, a performer whose wit, sharp humor, and commanding presence left an indelible mark on every stage she graced. Known for her sharp tongue and no-nonsense attitude, Stritch was the kind of performer who could command the attention of an entire theater with just a glance or a single line of dialogue. One of her most iconic performances came in Company, where she delivered the unforgettable “The Ladies Who Lunch” with a raw, unfiltered energy that became a masterclass in character-driven storytelling. Stritch’s voice wasn’t traditionally beautiful in the way that many of her contemporaries’ voices were, but it was powerful in its own right—rich with emotion, vulnerability, and a kind of gritty realness that made it uniquely captivating. She brought a lived-in quality to every role she took on, from her hilarious turn in A Little Night Music to her poignant performance in Elaine Stritch at Liberty, where she bared her soul to audiences in a way that few performers ever dare. Stritch’s ability to balance humor with deep emotional resonance was a hallmark of her work, and her fearless approach to performing made her a true original in the world of Broadway. Her unapologetic style and ability to turn every performance into an unforgettable event left a lasting legacy on the stage, and her contributions to the theater world remain unparalleled. Elaine Stritch wasn’t just an actress—she was an institution, a performer whose presence could never be duplicated.
10. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand is a true musical legend whose Broadway career, though relatively short, left an indelible impact on the theater world. Streisand’s Broadway debut in Funny Girl was nothing short of revolutionary, as her portrayal of Fanny Brice catapulted her to superstardom. Her voice, which is as powerful as it is unique, brought a new level of depth and sophistication to musical theater, and her performances in songs like “People” and “Don’t Rain on My Parade” became some of Broadway’s most iconic moments. Streisand’s vocal range is extraordinary, and her ability to convey emotion through her voice is one of her greatest strengths. Her performances were not just about hitting the right notes; they were about capturing the heart and soul of each character she portrayed. Although Streisand transitioned to an equally successful film and music career, her impact on Broadway has remained undeniable. She brought a level of star power and artistry to the stage that set a new standard for future performers. Streisand’s influence on musical theater is still felt today, and her time on Broadway has cemented her as one of the most important figures in musical theater history. Whether on stage or on screen, Barbra Streisand’s immense talent and unique presence continue to inspire audiences around the world.
11. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is an icon whose electrifying presence, unmatched dance ability, and dynamic performances have made her a living legend in the world of Broadway. Rivera’s name is synonymous with some of the most memorable roles in musical theater history, including her groundbreaking performances in West Side Story, Chicago, and Kiss of the Spider Woman. She was one of the original cast members of West Side Story, where she brought to life the fiery and passionate Anita, a role that would become one of the most celebrated in Broadway history. Her performance was a perfect blend of strength, sensuality, and vulnerability, showcasing Rivera’s incredible range as an actress and dancer. Rivera’s work in Chicago as the manipulative and alluring Velma Kelly solidified her as one of the most magnetic performers of her generation. Her ability to combine both theatricality and vulnerability made her stand out in every show she took part in. Known for her dazzling dance moves, Rivera’s choreography in both West Side Story and Kiss of the Spider Woman showcased her impeccable technique and unique style. With her fierce and elegant stage presence, Rivera set a new standard for the leading ladies of Broadway. Her contributions to musical theater have made her a Broadway legend, and her influence continues to inspire dancers and actors worldwide. Rivera’s career, which has spanned more than six decades, proves that age is no obstacle to greatness. Even as she continues to grace stages across the country, her legacy as a performer and a trailblazer remains etched in the fabric of Broadway history.
12. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin’s name is synonymous with vocal excellence, emotional depth, and a powerful stage presence that leaves an indelible mark on every performance. Known for his exceptional voice and versatility, Patinkin has showcased his talent in a range of roles that span musical theater, opera, and television. His Tony-winning portrayal of Che in Evita was a turning point in his career, where his deep, resonant baritone voice brought both intensity and sophistication to the role. Patinkin’s ability to convey emotion with his voice is extraordinary, as he can easily shift from tender, heart-wrenching moments to powerful, commanding expressions of anger or passion. His role as Georges in Sunday in the Park with George revealed his ability to embody complex, introspective characters with grace and subtlety. Patinkin’s vocal skill and emotional depth are complemented by his commitment to storytelling, which makes him a master of his craft. Though he’s perhaps best known for his Broadway roles, Patinkin has also enjoyed a successful television career, especially with his role in The Princess Bride and his long-running stint on Criminal Minds. However, it’s on the Broadway stage where his true magic happens, as he connects with audiences on a deeply personal level. His work has inspired countless actors and musicians, and his performances are a testament to his passion for his craft. Mandy Patinkin is not just a performer; he is a master of his art, and his influence on Broadway is undeniable.
13. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway darling whose dazzling soprano voice and infectious charm have made her one of the most beloved performers of her generation. Known for her boundless energy, impeccable comedic timing, and sheer vocal power, Chenoweth has become a star on Broadway and beyond. She first gained widespread attention for her Tony-winning role as the sweet and quirky Sally in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, but it was her portrayal of Glinda the Good Witch in Wicked that truly cemented her place as a Broadway legend. Chenoweth’s bright and sparkling soprano voice is capable of reaching some of the highest notes with effortless ease, and she has a rare ability to inject both warmth and humor into her performances. Her infectious energy, combined with her perfect comedic timing, makes her one of Broadway’s most captivating performers. Chenoweth’s talents go far beyond singing; she’s also an accomplished actress with an extensive career in television and film, showcasing her versatility and wide-ranging abilities. Her contributions to Broadway have earned her numerous accolades, and her performances continue to bring joy and laughter to audiences around the world. Whether she’s belting out a show-stopping number or delivering a witty one-liner, Chenoweth brings a rare charm to every role she plays. With her combination of vocal brilliance, comic timing, and stage presence, Kristin Chenoweth has earned her place as one of Broadway’s brightest stars, and her career shows no signs of slowing down.
14. Carol Channing
Carol Channing is one of Broadway’s most cherished stars, known for her unforgettable voice, radiant stage presence, and the larger-than-life personality she brought to every performance. Best known for her portrayal of Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, Channing’s portrayal of the role became legendary, as she infused the character with a unique blend of humor, heart, and charm. Her voice, distinctive and unmistakable, was filled with warmth and sincerity, and her performance as Dolly became a hallmark of Broadway. Beyond Hello, Dolly!, Channing’s career spanned numerous Broadway productions, and she became known for her comedic timing and her ability to captivate audiences with her engaging, playful nature. Channing’s career was a testament to her dedication to her craft, and she performed in the same shows for decades, endearing herself to generations of theatergoers. Her larger-than-life personality made her an unforgettable presence on stage, and her exuberant performances always left audiences smiling. Her work with legendary composers and lyricists like Jerry Herman and Stephen Sondheim helped cement her legacy as one of Broadway’s greatest stars. Carol Channing was more than just a performer—she was an institution, a force of nature who knew how to steal the spotlight and leave a lasting impression. Her devotion to the stage and her ability to make every role her own has made her one of Broadway’s most beloved performers, and her legacy lives on in the hearts of theater lovers around the world.
15. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s rise to Broadway stardom is a story of breaking barriers and making history. As the first Asian woman to win a Tony Award, Salonga has become a beacon of talent, resilience, and inspiration for performers everywhere. Her crystal-clear voice, combined with her emotional depth, has made her one of the most celebrated voices in musical theater. Salonga’s performance as Kim in Miss Saigon was a defining moment in her career, earning her critical acclaim and making her a household name. Her powerful rendition of “I Still Believe” became a standout number, showcasing not only her vocal prowess but also her ability to connect with the emotional core of the character. Beyond Miss Saigon, Salonga has performed in Les Misérables, Allegiance, and The King and I, demonstrating her incredible versatility across a variety of roles. Her contributions to Broadway have made her an icon in the musical theater world, and her influence extends beyond the stage. Salonga has inspired countless performers, particularly from marginalized communities, showing that talent knows no boundaries. She has proven time and again that she is not just a performer but a pioneer, breaking down barriers and making her mark on Broadway. Lea Salonga’s contributions to musical theater will forever be remembered, and her legacy as one of the greatest voices in Broadway history is secure.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
