Billy Joel is a living legend—a songwriter, storyteller, and piano virtuoso whose music has transcended generations. From heartfelt ballads to toe-tapping rock anthems, Joel’s ability to capture universal emotions has earned him a place among the greatest artists of all time. With a career spanning over five decades, the “Piano Man” has delivered a soundtrack to millions of lives, blending personal narratives, cultural commentary, and infectious melodies into unforgettable songs. Whether he’s reflecting on love, lamenting lost dreams, or crafting vivid tales of everyday characters, Joel’s music resonates with a timeless quality that feels as fresh today as when it was first released.
In this countdown, we’ll take a deep dive into the top 10 most popular Billy Joel songs of all time—tracks that have solidified his legacy and continue to inspire fans worldwide. From the stirring nostalgia of “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant” to the rebellious charm of “Only the Good Die Young,” these songs showcase the depth and diversity of his unparalleled artistry. Whether you’re a lifelong fan or discovering his music for the first time, this list is a celebration of a true musical icon whose work continues to strike a chord with audiences everywhere. Let’s turn up the volume and dive in!
1. Piano Man (1973)
Released in 1973 as the title track of Billy Joel’s breakthrough album, Piano Man is more than just a song—it’s a timeless narrative that captures the essence of a struggling musician. Drawing from Joel’s own experiences performing in a Los Angeles piano bar, the track paints a vivid picture of the bar’s eclectic mix of regulars. The famous harmonica intro sets a nostalgic tone, and the waltz-like melody complements the lyrics’ heartfelt storytelling. Through the characters in the song, Joel reflects on the human desire for connection, longing, and escape. With this track, Joel solidified his reputation as a master storyteller, and it remains a beloved classic, revered for its emotional depth and enduring appeal.
2. Uptown Girl (1983)
From the 1983 album An Innocent Man, Uptown Girl is a cheerful, doo-wop inspired homage to the 1950s and ‘60s. The track bursts with vibrant energy, thanks to its catchy rhythm, layered harmonies, and upbeat piano. Written about Joel’s future wife, supermodel Christie Brinkley, Uptown Girl tells the story of a working-class man who is infatuated with a glamorous woman beyond his reach. With playful lyrics and an infectious melody, the song became an instant hit, capturing the youthful optimism of aspiring love and the charm of a bygone era.
3. We Didn’t Start the Fire (1989)
We Didn’t Start the Fire, from Joel’s 1989 album Storm Front, is a fast-paced, history-packed anthem that captures the sweeping cultural and political events of the second half of the 20th century. With over 100 references to historical moments, figures, and trends from 1949 to 1989, the song’s rapid-fire delivery is both a history lesson and a social commentary. Joel’s ability to weave such a dense narrative into a compelling, rock-infused melody shows his knack for blending education with entertainment. The song’s message—that history is an ongoing, unrelenting force—resonates deeply, and its success only solidified Joel’s reputation as a thought-provoking artist.
4. Just the Way You Are (1977)
Released in 1977 on The Stranger, Just the Way You Are is a tender love ballad that quickly became one of Billy Joel’s signature songs. Its soft saxophone intro, delicate piano chords, and heartfelt lyrics convey an enduring message of unconditional love and acceptance. Written for Joel’s then-wife, Elizabeth Weber, the song was a bold declaration of admiration for her authenticity. It went on to win Grammy Awards for Record and Song of the Year, and its emotional sincerity has made it a popular choice for weddings and romantic moments for decades.
5. Scenes from an Italian Restaurant (1977)
A fan favorite and widely regarded as Billy Joel’s magnum opus, Scenes from an Italian Restaurant is a seven-minute musical journey filled with rich storytelling, shifting melodies, and diverse musical styles. Released in 1977 on The Stranger, the song weaves the story of Brenda and Eddie, a young couple whose love story fades as they grow older. With its jazzy intro, rock-driven sections, and sweeping orchestration, the track takes listeners through the ups and downs of life, love, and the passing of time. Though never released as a single, it showcases Joel’s genius as a storyteller and composer.
6. Only the Good Die Young (1977)
Only the Good Die Young, also from The Stranger (1977), is a rebellious anthem with a catchy, piano-driven rock rhythm and cheeky lyrics. The song tells the story of a young man who attempts to convince a Catholic girl to loosen her moral constraints, a theme that sparked controversy and led to bans on several radio stations. Despite—or perhaps because of—the backlash, the song’s infectious melody and playful attitude made it a huge hit. It has since become a staple of Joel’s catalog, resonating as a celebration of youthful defiance and living life boldly.
7. Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (1977)
Another standout from The Stranger, Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) is a satirical critique of the American obsession with material success. With its punchy rhythm, biting lyrics, and sarcastic tone, the song follows Anthony, a working-class man who grows disillusioned with the pursuit of wealth and social status. Joel’s delivery—characterized by his sharp New York edge—perfectly captures Anthony’s frustration with the “American dream.” The energetic saxophone outro and memorable refrain, “Who needs a house out in Hackensack? Is that all you get for your money?” make this track a quintessential Billy Joel anthem.
8. My Life (1978)
Released in 1978 on 52nd Street, My Life is an empowering anthem about independence and self-determination. With its upbeat, piano-driven riff and catchy chorus, the song became an instant radio favorite, reaching the Top 10. The track’s message of living life on your own terms struck a deep chord with listeners, resonating as a declaration of personal freedom. Its upbeat production and joyful tone made it a perfect theme song for the 1980s sitcom Bosom Buddies, and My Life remains one of Billy Joel’s most recognizable and feel-good songs.
9. The Longest Time (1983)
A standout track from An Innocent Man (1983), The Longest Time is a throwback to the doo-wop era, showcasing Joel’s love for vocal harmonies and nostalgic storytelling. With no instruments beyond his voice and a bass line, the song’s rich, layered sound feels both intimate and timeless. The lyrics reflect on love and the passage of time, with Joel’s soulful delivery adding an extra layer of sincerity. A surprise hit, The Longest Time became a fan favorite and exemplified Joel’s ability to pay homage to the music of his youth while creating something uniquely his.
10. Vienna (1977)
Vienna, from The Stranger (1977), is a reflective, poignant ballad that has grown in popularity over time. The song’s gentle piano melody and introspective lyrics offer a wise reminder to slow down and appreciate life’s journey. Inspired by a trip to Vienna, Joel observed the older generations there still actively engaged in society, a stark contrast to the American obsession with youth. While Vienna wasn’t a major hit upon release, its wisdom and emotional depth have made it a cherished classic. Over the years, it has become one of Joel’s most beloved and meaningful songs.
Samuel Moore is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
