Broadway has long been the shining epicenter of musical theater, a place where timeless stories come to life through enchanting melodies and extraordinary talent. The magic of Broadway doesn’t just lie in the dazzling sets or the incredible choreography — it’s in the voices that soar across the stage, sending chills down our spines and moving us to tears. Some performers don’t just sing; they embody the characters they portray, leaving an indelible mark on the history of theater.
From the golden age of Broadway to the contemporary era, there have been singers whose vocal prowess, charisma, and stage presence have defined generations of theatergoers. These artists have delivered iconic performances in legendary shows, transforming songs into unforgettable moments that continue to resonate beyond the curtain’s close.
In this article, we’re celebrating the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time — the voices that took center stage and never let it go. Whether they’re belting out powerful ballads or delivering pitch-perfect high notes that defy gravity, these performers have made their mark on Broadway’s rich and illustrious tradition. Get ready to dive into the world of show-stopping talent and discover the legends who have set the bar for Broadway excellence!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is often celebrated as the “Queen of Broadway,” a title she earned through her unparalleled vocal prowess and commanding stage presence. Her voice, a booming force that could fill the largest theaters, was characterized by its crystal-clear tone and remarkable range. Merman’s ability to convey emotion through song was unmatched, making her a formidable force in musical theater. Her iconic role as Mama Rose in Gypsy has set a benchmark for Broadway performers, with her passionate delivery of songs like “Everything’s Coming Up Roses” and “There’s No Business Like Show Business” becoming legendary anthems of the genre. These performances showcased her exceptional comic timing, allowing her to connect with audiences on a personal level. What set Merman apart was her electrifying ability to create an intimate atmosphere, even in the vastest venues. Each note she sang resonated with authenticity and power, and her larger-than-life personality shone through every performance. Merman’s legacy is not just in her songs but also in the inspiration she provided to future generations of performers. Simply put, Ethel Merman was the embodiment of Broadway itself, and her influence continues to echo through the theater world today.
2. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald stands out as one of Broadway’s most extraordinary talents, boasting a record six Tony Awards—a feat unmatched by any other performer. Her voice is a marvel of rich, operatic quality that effortlessly transcends genres, from classical to jazz and contemporary musical theater. McDonald has made her mark in acclaimed productions such as Ragtime, Porgy and Bess, and Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, each role showcasing her incredible versatility and emotional depth. Whether she’s delivering deeply moving ballads or soaring through pitch-perfect high notes, her performances are always breathtaking, leaving audiences spellbound. Beyond her vocal prowess, McDonald’s stage presence is magnetic, drawing viewers in and making them feel every emotion conveyed through her songs. She brings a level of authenticity and vulnerability that allows her characters to resonate with audiences on a profound level. Audra McDonald’s contributions to Broadway are immeasurable, as she continues to push the boundaries of musical theater. Her dedication to her craft, combined with her remarkable talent, makes her a trailblazer and a beloved figure in the world of performing arts. Truly, Audra McDonald is a voice for the ages, inspiring countless artists to follow in her footsteps.
3. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is a true Broadway powerhouse whose magnetic performances have captivated audiences for decades. Known for her strikingly bold stage presence and unmistakable voice, LuPone first rose to fame with her iconic portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita. Her passionate rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” remains one of the most unforgettable moments in musical theater history, leaving audiences spellbound and yearning for more. Throughout her career, LuPone has consistently raised the bar in productions such as Gypsy and Sweeney Todd, proving time and again that her vocal strength and emotional depth are second to none. Each role she undertakes is imbued with a fierce intensity that resonates deeply with the audience, making her one of Broadway’s most unforgettable performers. LuPone’s ability to convey raw emotion through her singing is complemented by her exceptional acting skills, allowing her to bring complex characters to life. Beyond her incredible talent, she is known for her candidness and passion for the arts, advocating for the importance of theater in society. Patti LuPone’s legacy is one of excellence and inspiration, solidifying her status as a timeless icon of Broadway.
4. Bernadette Peters
When discussing star power on Broadway, few can match the charisma and talent of Bernadette Peters. With her distinctive, lilting voice and uncanny ability to convey deep emotion through song, Peters has graced the stage in some of the most memorable roles in theater history. Whether she’s portraying the wistful Dot in Sunday in the Park with George or the larger-than-life Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, Peters always leaves an indelible mark that lingers long after the curtain falls. Her voice is both powerful and nuanced, capable of delivering heart-wrenching ballads and show-stopping numbers with equal finesse. Audiences are often captivated by her charming presence and the way she effortlessly navigates the complexities of her characters. Beyond her vocal talent, Peters has also become a beloved figure in the Broadway community, known for her philanthropic efforts and advocacy for the arts. Her contributions to musical theater extend beyond her performances; she has inspired countless aspiring artists to follow their dreams. Bernadette Peters’ influence on Broadway is profound, and her ability to connect with audiences through her artistry ensures her legacy will endure for generations to come.
5. Julie Andrews
While Julie Andrews may be best known for her iconic film roles in Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music, her Broadway career was nothing short of legendary. Andrews originated the role of Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady, enchanting audiences with her crystal-clear soprano voice and impeccable diction. Her portrayal of Queen Guinevere in Camelot further solidified her status as one of Broadway’s brightest stars, captivating theatergoers with her undeniable charm and vocal artistry. Often described as having an “angelic” voice, Andrews had the unique ability to fill any theater with warmth and clarity, making her performances unforgettable. Beyond her vocal prowess, Andrews’ ability to convey emotion and authenticity in her characters endeared her to audiences around the world. Her influence extends beyond the stage, inspiring countless performers and musicians to pursue their dreams. Throughout her illustrious career, Andrews has received numerous accolades and awards, acknowledging her contributions to the world of theater and film. Julie Andrews remains a beloved figure in musical theater history, a symbol of grace and talent whose legacy continues to shine brightly in the hearts of fans everywhere.
6. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury is a true Broadway legend, her career spanning over an impressive seven decades. Renowned for her remarkable versatility as both an actress and a singer, Lansbury has left an indelible mark on the stage, delivering standout performances in beloved productions like Mame, Sweeney Todd, and Gypsy. Her unique ability to blend humor with gravitas, coupled with her rich mezzo-soprano voice, made her a fan favorite in every show she graced. Lansbury’s portrayal of Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd remains particularly memorable; her incredible comedic timing, combined with her vocal prowess, showcases her talent in a way that captivates and entertains. Each role she undertook allowed her to shine, and her ability to connect with audiences was unparalleled. Beyond her stage work, Lansbury’s contributions to television and film further demonstrate her extraordinary range and talent. Her work has garnered numerous accolades, including several Tony Awards and an honorary Academy Award. Angela Lansbury’s enduring legacy in theater and the arts continues to inspire generations of performers, and her timeless performances ensure she will always be remembered as one of the greats of Broadway.
7. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is undeniably the voice that defined a generation, her powerful belt and emotional vulnerability resonating deeply with audiences worldwide. She first captured the spotlight as Maureen in Rent, but it was her groundbreaking role as Elphaba in Wicked that catapulted her to Broadway superstardom. Menzel’s iconic rendition of “Defying Gravity” not only earned her a Tony Award but also became a defining moment in musical theater, showcasing her incredible vocal range and dramatic intensity. Her voice can soar effortlessly to thrilling heights, making her one of the most celebrated performers of the modern Broadway era. Beyond her vocal talent, Menzel’s stage presence is magnetic, drawing audiences into the heart of each character she portrays. She has become a role model for aspiring artists, demonstrating the power of resilience and authenticity in the performing arts. Menzel’s influence extends beyond the stage, as she has also made significant contributions to film and television, further solidifying her status as a multifaceted artist. Idina Menzel’s legacy in Broadway history is profound, and her ability to connect with audiences through her music and performances will ensure she remains a cherished figure in the world of theater.
8. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was the quintessential Broadway legend, embodying a brassy, bold spirit that made her utterly unforgettable. Known for her sharp wit and commanding stage presence, Stritch transformed every role into a masterclass in performance. Her rendition of “The Ladies Who Lunch” from Company is a quintessential Broadway moment, filled with raw emotion and biting humor that resonated with audiences of all ages. Stritch’s gravelly voice and no-nonsense attitude set her apart as a beloved figure both on and off the stage, and her larger-than-life personality shone through in every performance. She was not only a talented actress but also a gifted storyteller, sharing her experiences and insights with audiences in a way that felt deeply personal. Stritch’s contributions to theater have inspired countless performers, and her ability to tackle challenging roles with honesty and authenticity remains a benchmark for aspiring artists. Throughout her career, she received numerous accolades for her work, including Tony Awards and Emmy nominations. Elaine Stritch’s legacy is one of strength, humor, and unmatched talent, continuing to inspire future generations of performers with her bold approach to the craft of acting.
9. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is one of Broadway’s most versatile stars, known for her ability to seamlessly blend comedy, dance, and powerhouse vocals into unforgettable performances. With her stunning portrayals in shows like Thoroughly Modern Millie and Anything Goes, Foster has redefined what it means to be a triple threat on stage. Her energy is infectious, captivating audiences from the moment she steps onto the stage. Foster’s crystal-clear voice, combined with her impeccable comedic timing, allows her to tackle a wide range of characters, making each performance a unique experience. Audiences are drawn to her bubbly persona, which radiates warmth and charm, enhancing every role she plays. Beyond her theatrical accomplishments, Foster has ventured into television and film, further showcasing her diverse talents. She remains a leading force on Broadway, inspiring fans and aspiring performers alike with her passion and dedication to her craft. Sutton Foster’s contributions to musical theater have made her a beloved figure in the industry, and her ability to connect with audiences ensures her continued success on stage. As she moves forward in her career, Foster’s influence will undoubtedly inspire future generations of artists in the world of musical theater.
10. Lin-Manuel Miranda
Lin-Manuel Miranda has revolutionized Broadway with his groundbreaking work in Hamilton and In the Heights. As a composer, lyricist, and performer, Miranda has infused a fresh, modern voice into the theater, blending hip-hop, R&B, and traditional musical elements in ways that have forever altered the landscape of musical theater. His portrayal of Alexander Hamilton was both electrifying and deeply emotional, showcasing his ability to deliver rapid-fire lyrics while infusing them with genuine heart and storytelling depth. Miranda’s innovative approach to musical theater has inspired countless artists, and his work has resonated with diverse audiences, bridging cultural divides and sparking conversations about history and identity. Beyond his theatrical achievements, Miranda has made significant contributions to film and television, further solidifying his status as a multifaceted artist. His commitment to social justice and community advocacy has endeared him to fans, highlighting his dedication to using his platform for positive change. Lin-Manuel Miranda’s impact on Broadway is undeniable, and his creative vision will influence the next generation of performers and creators. His legacy as a trailblazer in the arts is secure, ensuring that his contributions to theater will be felt for years to come.
11. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin’s voice is instantly recognizable—a rich, expressive tenor that can shift from tender to thunderous in an instant. His performances in iconic roles, such as Che in Evita and Georges in Sunday in the Park with George, have earned him acclaim as one of Broadway’s most compelling leading men. Patinkin’s deep emotional connection to his characters is palpable, and his ability to convey vulnerability alongside strength makes every performance a transformative experience. His vocal mastery is evident in every note, with a range that captivates audiences and brings them into the heart of the story being told. Beyond the stage, Patinkin has made a significant impact on television and film, showcasing his versatility as an artist. His passion for storytelling and the arts is matched only by his dedication to philanthropy and advocacy for the arts. Each performance is a testament to his commitment to the craft, and his ability to inspire and connect with audiences is truly remarkable. Mandy Patinkin’s legacy in Broadway history is profound, and his remarkable talent ensures that he will always be remembered as one of the finest performers of his generation.
12. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway darling, beloved for her sparkling soprano and impeccable comedic timing. Her role as Glinda in Wicked solidified her place as one of Broadway’s most cherished stars, with her high-flying performance of “Popular” leaving audiences in stitches and earning her a special place in theater history. Chenoweth’s voice is nothing short of a marvel, effortlessly hitting impossibly high notes while maintaining a warmth and charm that makes her utterly endearing. Whether she’s portraying a quirky character or delivering a heart-wrenching ballad, her stage presence lights up every performance, captivating the audience from start to finish. Beyond her impressive theatrical accomplishments, Chenoweth has ventured into television and film, showcasing her diverse talents and broadening her reach as an artist. She is not only a remarkable performer but also a passionate advocate for the arts, inspiring young artists and promoting creativity in education. Kristin Chenoweth’s contributions to musical theater are significant, and her ability to connect with audiences ensures her continued success on stage. Her legacy as a multifaceted performer will resonate for years, making her an enduring figure in the world of Broadway.
13. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a true Broadway icon, celebrated for her boundless energy, dazzling dance moves, and sultry voice. With unforgettable performances in legendary shows like West Side Story, Chicago, and The Rink, Rivera has established herself as a genuine triple threat. Her portrayal of Velma Kelly in Chicago is particularly memorable, with her show-stopping number “All That Jazz” still sending chills down audiences’ spines. Rivera’s charisma shines through in every performance, and her ability to connect with her characters adds a depth that resonates with theatergoers. As a pioneer for Latina actresses in musical theater, she has paved the way for future generations of performers. Rivera’s contributions to Broadway extend beyond her performances, as she has become an advocate for diversity and inclusion in the arts. Her remarkable career has garnered numerous accolades, celebrating her talent and dedication to the craft. Chita Rivera’s legacy in the world of musical theater is both profound and enduring, ensuring that her influence will be felt for many years to come. Her vibrant spirit and extraordinary talent have made her a lasting star in the ever-evolving landscape of Broadway.
14. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is often referred to as “The Last Leading Man” of Broadway, a title he has earned through his spectacular performances and rich baritone voice. His ability to deliver both powerful anthems and tender ballads with equal finesse sets him apart as one of the most respected performers on the stage. Mitchell’s roles in productions like Ragtime and Kiss Me, Kate are legendary, showcasing his commanding stage presence and vocal prowess that captivates audiences night after night. His performances are marked by a unique ability to bring depth and gravitas to every character, making each moment on stage a memorable experience. Beyond his theatrical achievements, Mitchell is also known for his work in television and film, demonstrating his versatility as an artist. He is passionate about supporting the arts and advocating for arts education, using his platform to inspire others to pursue their creative dreams. Brian Stokes Mitchell’s impact on Broadway is profound, and his extraordinary talent continues to resonate with audiences. His legacy as a leading man is secure, ensuring that he will always be celebrated as one of the finest performers of his generation.
15. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s voice is pure magic, captivating listeners with its clarity and emotional intensity. Best known for originating the role of Kim in Miss Saigon and for her work as the singing voice of Disney princesses Jasmine and Mulan, Salonga has established herself as a beloved figure in musical theater. Her performance in Les Misérables as Eponine is particularly heart-wrenching; her rendition of “On My Own” often brings audiences to tears, showcasing her incredible ability to connect with the emotions of her characters. Salonga’s global appeal and unmatched vocal talent have made her an icon in the arts, inspiring countless performers around the world. She is known not only for her stunning voice but also for her dedication to philanthropy and advocacy for the arts, using her platform to uplift others. Her performances are marked by authenticity and grace, creating moments that resonate deeply with audiences. Lea Salonga’s contributions to Broadway and the broader world of musical theater are significant, and her legacy is one of talent, passion, and inspiration. She remains a shining star, and her influence will continue to shape the future of musical theater for generations to come.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
