Broadway has long been the heartbeat of musical theater, a place where timeless stories come to life through extraordinary performances. At the center of this magic are the singers—those rare voices that stir our souls and electrify the stage. From the soaring high notes that send shivers down your spine to the deeply emotional ballads that make your heart ache, Broadway singers are the ultimate storytellers, weaving music and narrative together in a way that stays with you forever. But among the countless talents that have graced the Great White Way, there are a select few whose voices have transcended the stage, whose performances have become the stuff of legend.
In this article, we’re celebrating the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—artists who have shaped the sound of theater and left an indelible mark on audiences around the world. Whether belting out show-stopping numbers or delivering quiet, intimate moments that tug at the heartstrings, these performers represent the pinnacle of vocal excellence. So, grab your Playbill and settle in as we take a journey through Broadway’s most iconic voices, from golden-age legends to modern-day powerhouses, each one a testament to the magic of live musical theater.
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman reigns as the undisputed queen of Broadway, known for her extraordinary ability to fill any theater with her powerful voice, which resonated even without a microphone. With a career spanning five remarkable decades, Merman’s dynamic performances in iconic shows such as Anything Goes, Annie Get Your Gun, and Gypsy have etched her name in the annals of musical theater history. Her signature big, brassy belt was not just a vocal technique; it was an embodiment of the larger-than-life characters she portrayed, exuding both strength and charisma. Merman had a unique ability to project her emotions, making her an ideal fit for the demanding roles she took on. When she stepped on stage, she commanded attention, captivating audiences with every note. Merman’s contributions to Broadway have paved the way for future generations of performers, establishing her as a trailblazer in the industry. Her legacy continues to inspire artists today, reminding us of the vibrant spirit and artistry that define Broadway. Ethel Merman’s influence is felt not just through her recordings, but in the hearts of theatergoers who recognize her as a true pioneer of the stage.
2. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews is a Broadway icon whose crystal-clear soprano voice and unparalleled acting skills have captured the hearts of audiences for decades. She first dazzled theatergoers as Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady, a role that showcased her remarkable vocal range and ability to infuse characters with genuine emotion. This performance was quickly followed by her enchanting portrayal of Queen Guinevere in Camelot, further solidifying her status as a musical theater sensation. Andrews possesses a unique ability to connect deeply with her audience, drawing them into the emotional landscape of her characters. While she later became a beloved film star, her roots in Broadway remain an essential part of her illustrious legacy. Andrews’ performances are characterized by a sense of grace and authenticity, making every song resonate with profound meaning. Over the years, she has inspired countless performers to pursue their dreams in musical theater. Her contributions to both stage and screen have made her an enduring figure in the entertainment industry. Julie Andrews embodies the spirit of Broadway and continues to be celebrated for her artistry, charm, and dedication to the craft of performance.
3. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is an indomitable force on Broadway, celebrated for her fiery performances and extraordinary vocal talent. With a career spanning several decades, she has delivered some of the most memorable performances in musical theater history. LuPone is perhaps best known for her Tony Award-winning role as Eva Perón in Evita, where her passionate rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” resonated deeply with audiences. Another defining role was her portrayal of Mama Rose in Gypsy, which showcased her incredible range and emotional depth. LuPone’s voice is a force of nature; it combines raw power with tender vulnerability, allowing her to evoke a spectrum of emotions in her performances. Her commitment to her characters is palpable, bringing an intensity and authenticity that captivates audiences. LuPone has a unique ability to transform every song into a personal story, making her performances unforgettable. Whether she is belting high notes or delivering a quiet, intimate moment, she commands the stage with a presence that is impossible to ignore. As a true Broadway legend, Patti LuPone continues to inspire countless performers and remains a significant figure in the world of musical theater.
4. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a monumental figure in Broadway history, celebrated for her extraordinary talent and versatility. With a staggering record of six Tony Awards, she holds the title for the most awards won by a single performer, reflecting her unparalleled contributions to the theater. McDonald’s soprano voice is nothing short of breathtaking, effortlessly transitioning between classical and contemporary musical styles. She has taken on a wide array of roles, from the heartbreaking Carrie Pipperidge in Carousel to the emotionally charged Clara in Porgy and Bess, and the fierce Sarah in Ragtime. Each performance is infused with a deep emotional resonance that captivates audiences and leaves a lasting impression. McDonald’s ability to convey complex emotions through her singing and acting makes her one of the most compelling performers of her generation. She has not only redefined musical theater with her talent but also serves as an inspiration to aspiring artists everywhere. Audra McDonald’s legacy is a testament to the power of song and storytelling, and her remarkable performances continue to inspire and move theater lovers across the globe.
5. Bernadette Peters
With her signature curls and ethereal voice, Bernadette Peters embodies the essence of Broadway excellence. Known for her work in Stephen Sondheim’s masterpieces, Peters has left an indelible mark on musical theater through her unforgettable performances. Her portrayal of the witch in Into the Woods and her role as Dot in Sunday in the Park with George have become benchmarks of modern Broadway performance. Peters’ voice has a unique quality, combining a lightness with emotional depth that allows her to traverse a wide range of characters and moods. Her ability to imbue her performances with vulnerability and nuance has endeared her to audiences and critics alike. Beyond her vocal talents, Peters is also known for her charm and stage presence, captivating audiences with her warmth and authenticity. She has been a beloved figure in the theater community for decades, inspiring both fans and fellow performers with her artistry and dedication. Peters’ contributions to Broadway have not only enriched the landscape of musical theater but have also solidified her status as a true icon. Her performances continue to resonate, ensuring her place in the hearts of theater lovers for generations to come.
6. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is a Broadway star known for her boundless energy and exceptional talent. She first gained widespread acclaim for her Tony Award-winning performance in Thoroughly Modern Millie, where her comedic timing and vibrant vocals showcased her remarkable abilities. Foster’s talent extends beyond acting and singing; she is also an accomplished dancer, seamlessly integrating choreography into her performances. This versatility has allowed her to shine in diverse productions, including her celebrated roles in Anything Goes and The Drowsy Chaperone. Foster’s infectious charm and dedication to her craft have made her a beloved figure on Broadway. She possesses a unique ability to connect with her audience, drawing them into the world of her characters with her heartfelt performances. Her commitment to storytelling through song is evident in every role she takes on. Foster continues to be a shining light in the theater community, inspiring a new generation of performers with her artistry and passion for musical theater. Her contributions to Broadway are invaluable, as she effortlessly combines humor, dance, and powerful vocals, establishing herself as one of the industry’s brightest stars.
7. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is a powerhouse of talent whose dynamic voice has made her one of Broadway’s most iconic singers. She first rose to prominence as Maureen in the groundbreaking musical Rent, where her unique vocal style and stage presence captivated audiences. However, it was her portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked that truly catapulted her to superstardom. Menzel’s ability to hit astonishingly high notes while conveying intense emotion has made her performances unforgettable. Her rendition of “Defying Gravity” has become a defining moment in modern musical theater, showcasing her extraordinary talent and setting the standard for aspiring performers. Beyond her incredible vocal ability, Menzel’s commitment to her characters adds depth and authenticity to every role she embodies. She connects with her audience on an emotional level, inviting them into the world of her characters. Menzel’s influence extends beyond the stage, inspiring countless artists and fans around the globe. Her impact on Broadway is undeniable, as she continues to break boundaries and redefine what it means to be a leading lady in musical theater. Idina Menzel remains a shining star, lighting up the stage with her remarkable artistry and passionate performances.
8. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury is a multifaceted talent whose illustrious career spans television, film, and theater, leaving an indelible mark on Broadway. With iconic roles such as Mame Dennis in Mame and the unforgettable Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd, Lansbury showcased her incredible range and versatility as a performer. Her ability to infuse her characters with a blend of humor, heart, and a touch of darkness made her a standout on stage, earning her critical acclaim and five Tony Awards. Lansbury’s magnetic presence captivated audiences, and her performances often resonated long after the curtain fell. Beyond her stage work, she became a household name through her role in the beloved television series Murder, She Wrote, which further solidified her status as a cultural icon. Throughout her career, Lansbury has been a source of inspiration for aspiring actors, demonstrating the power of storytelling through performance. Her legacy as a Broadway legend is undeniable, as she set the standard for excellence in theater. Angela Lansbury’s contributions to the performing arts continue to be celebrated, ensuring that her name remains synonymous with talent, charm, and a deep love for the craft of acting.
9. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a true trailblazer in the world of Broadway, renowned for her incredible dancing and powerful vocal abilities. She made history with her groundbreaking role as the original Anita in West Side Story, a performance that helped redefine musical theater and showcased her remarkable talents. Rivera’s stage presence is nothing short of electric, drawing audiences in with her passion and commitment to her craft. Her ability to seamlessly combine acting, singing, and dancing sets her apart as one of the most versatile performers in Broadway history. In addition to her iconic role in West Side Story, Rivera’s performances in Chicago and Kiss of the Spider Woman have further solidified her legendary status. Throughout her career, she has broken barriers for Latina performers in the theater, paving the way for future generations. Rivera’s contributions to Broadway are celebrated not just for her talent but also for her pioneering spirit. She embodies the essence of what it means to be a Broadway star, inspiring countless artists with her dedication and artistry. Chita Rivera’s legacy continues to shine brightly in the world of musical theater, making her an enduring symbol of talent and determination.
10. Barbra Streisand
Before becoming a global film and recording superstar, Barbra Streisand took Broadway by storm with her unforgettable performance as Fanny Brice in Funny Girl. Her unique voice, characterized by emotional depth and incredible range, captivated audiences and critics alike, establishing her as a musical theater sensation. Streisand’s ability to blend humor, vulnerability, and sheer vocal power made her a standout performer, and her rendition of “People” remains one of the most iconic moments in Broadway history. Her performances exude authenticity, drawing audiences into the heart of her characters’ stories. Streisand’s talent transcends the stage; she has successfully made her mark in film, music, and directing, showcasing her versatility as an artist. Despite her extensive career, her roots in Broadway have remained a vital part of her identity, influencing her work across various mediums. Streisand continues to inspire aspiring performers with her dedication to the arts and her commitment to excellence. Her impact on Broadway and beyond is profound, as she has redefined what it means to be a leading lady. Barbra Streisand’s legacy is celebrated for its brilliance, and she remains a beloved figure in the world of entertainment.
11. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a singular talent in the world of Broadway, known for her sharp wit, commanding stage presence, and unforgettable voice. Her performance in Company as Joanne, delivering the iconic “The Ladies Who Lunch,” became a defining moment in her career, showcasing her ability to blend humor and pathos. Stritch’s no-nonsense attitude and fierce authenticity resonated deeply with audiences, making her a standout performer on the Broadway stage. She brought a unique blend of vulnerability and strength to her characters, captivating theatergoers with her honest portrayal of complex emotions. Stritch’s influence extends beyond her performances; she became a beloved figure known for her candid reflections on life and artistry. Her willingness to embrace her flaws and share her experiences resonated with many, earning her a devoted fanbase. Elaine Stritch’s legacy is one of authenticity and courage, reminding us of the power of being true to oneself in both life and art. Her contributions to musical theater continue to inspire and resonate with performers and audiences alike. Stritch’s spirit lives on in the hearts of those who appreciate the beauty of genuine storytelling and the richness of human experience.
12. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is a celebrated performer whose rich, expressive tenor voice and intense acting style have made him a standout on both stage and screen. He gained fame for his role as Che in the groundbreaking musical Evita, where his powerful vocals and emotive performances captivated audiences. Following this success, Patinkin further showcased his extraordinary talent in Sunday in the Park with George, bringing depth and authenticity to the role of George. His ability to convey raw emotion through his singing is one of his trademarks, making every performance a deeply moving experience. Patinkin’s unique vocal style, combined with his commitment to storytelling, has earned him a special place in the hearts of theater lovers. He approaches each role with meticulous care, ensuring that his performances resonate on a personal level. Beyond his theatrical work, Patinkin has also made a name for himself in television and film, showcasing his versatility as an artist. His dedication to the craft of performance and his passion for storytelling continue to inspire countless performers. Mandy Patinkin’s legacy is defined by his artistry, emotional depth, and a profound understanding of the human experience.
13. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a dazzling Broadway star whose soprano voice is nothing short of magical. Known for her razor-sharp comedic timing and incredible vocal range, she has captivated audiences in a variety of roles, most notably as Glinda in Wicked. Chenoweth’s ability to hit impossibly high notes while infusing her performances with humor and heart makes her a standout talent on stage. Her bubbly personality shines through in every role, allowing her to connect with audiences in a meaningful way. Beyond Wicked, she has showcased her talent in productions like You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, where her portrayal of Sally Brown earned her critical acclaim. Chenoweth is not just a gifted singer but also an accomplished actress, with a career that spans theater, television, and film. Her versatility and charm have made her a beloved figure in the entertainment industry, inspiring countless fans and fellow performers. Kristin Chenoweth’s legacy is one of joy, laughter, and heartfelt performances, ensuring her place among Broadway’s elite. She continues to shine brightly, proving that talent and charisma can create magic on stage.
14. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is a towering figure in the world of Broadway, known for his deep, resonant baritone voice that captivates audiences everywhere. He has starred in celebrated productions like Ragtime, where his powerful portrayal of Coalhouse Walker Jr. showcased his incredible vocal talent and emotional range. Additionally, his performances in Kiss Me, Kate and Man of La Mancha have earned him widespread acclaim and solidified his status as one of Broadway’s most revered leading men. Mitchell’s commanding presence on stage allows him to convey both strength and vulnerability, making every performance a masterclass in musical theater. His rich, expressive voice resonates with emotion, drawing audiences into the heart of each character he portrays. Beyond his theatrical accomplishments, Mitchell is also a dedicated advocate for the arts and education, using his platform to inspire the next generation of performers. His contributions to Broadway are invaluable, as he brings depth and artistry to every role he takes on. Brian Stokes Mitchell’s legacy is marked by his exceptional talent and dedication to the craft, ensuring that he remains a celebrated and influential figure in musical theater.
15. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga became an international sensation with her Tony Award-winning performance as Kim in Miss Saigon, where her powerful, emotive voice and incredible vocal control captivated audiences worldwide. Salonga’s talent extends beyond her remarkable singing; she has also made history as the first actress of Asian descent to play both Éponine and Fantine in Les Misérables, breaking barriers and paving the way for future performers. Her ability to bring emotional depth and authenticity to every role she undertakes has earned her a devoted fanbase and critical acclaim. Salonga’s performances are marked by her stunning vocal agility and her capacity to convey a wide range of emotions, from heartbreak to joy. She has continued to shine on the international stage, performing in various productions and concerts, while also serving as a mentor to aspiring artists. Lea Salonga’s impact on Broadway and beyond is profound, as she has not only set the standard for excellence in musical theater but has also become a symbol of hope and inspiration for countless fans around the world. Her legacy is one of artistry, resilience, and an unwavering commitment to the craft of performance.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
