Broadway has always been the ultimate stage for musical talent, where powerful voices meet unforgettable performances, and where legends are born. Over the decades, this iconic stretch of Manhattan has witnessed the rise of countless stars, each leaving their indelible mark on the theater world. But among the glittering array of performers, there are a select few whose voices have transcended the boundaries of the stage, earning them a place in the pantheon of Broadway greatness.
From the golden age of musicals to contemporary blockbusters, these singers have delivered show-stopping performances that have moved audiences to tears, laughter, and standing ovations. Their voices, ranging from soulful and soothing to soaring and electrifying, have defined the heart and soul of Broadway’s most cherished productions. Whether belting out high notes with precision or bringing deep emotion to every lyric, these artists represent the very best of what musical theater has to offer.
Join us as we pay tribute to the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—a celebration of talent, passion, and the unforgettable moments that have shaped the history of Broadway. Prepare to be amazed as we highlight the voices that continue to inspire and captivate generations of theater lovers!
1. Ethel Merman
Often referred to as the “Queen of Broadway,” Ethel Merman’s powerful, brassy voice could fill any theater without the need for a microphone. Merman’s ability to deliver show-stopping performances became legendary, particularly with her work in musicals like Gypsy and Annie Get Your Gun. Her signature style—unapologetically bold and commanding—made her the go-to star for composers like Irving Berlin and Cole Porter. Merman’s voice truly epitomized the golden age of Broadway. Audiences would leave theaters in awe, still humming the tunes she so effortlessly brought to life.
2. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald’s voice is nothing short of extraordinary, and her six Tony Awards are a testament to her unmatched talent. Known for her versatility, McDonald has tackled everything from operatic arias to contemporary musical theater with grace and precision. Her performances in shows like Ragtime, Porgy and Bess, and Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill showcase her ability to convey deep emotion while maintaining impeccable vocal control. Whether she’s delivering a tender ballad or commanding the stage with a powerhouse anthem, McDonald never fails to leave an indelible impression on her audience.
3. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is a Broadway icon whose voice is both thrilling and unmistakable. Known for her gutsy, larger-than-life performances, LuPone has made roles like Eva Perón in Evita and Mama Rose in Gypsy her own, earning her multiple Tony Awards along the way. Her ability to hit high notes with a mix of power and emotion has made her a favorite among both theater lovers and critics alike. When LuPone steps on stage, the energy in the room shifts—her presence is magnetic, and her voice is unforgettable.
4. Julie Andrews
Before she became a beloved film star, Julie Andrews was dazzling Broadway audiences with her crystalline soprano voice. Her performances in My Fair Lady and Camelot set a new standard for vocal purity and acting prowess. Andrews’ ability to communicate vulnerability and strength simultaneously made her a standout in the early days of musical theater. Her perfect pitch, combined with her undeniable charm, made her one of the brightest stars to ever grace the Broadway stage.
5. Bernadette Peters
With her distinctive voice and curly red hair, Bernadette Peters has been a Broadway favorite for decades. Her performances in Stephen Sondheim classics like Into the Woods and Sunday in the Park with George have become legendary. Peters brings a unique vulnerability and warmth to her roles, and her voice—rich, expressive, and emotionally charged—can switch from playful to heartbreaking in an instant. She’s a performer who knows how to connect with her audience, leaving them deeply moved by the end of every show.
6. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is a modern Broadway star whose incredible energy and vocal range have made her a favorite in shows like Thoroughly Modern Millie and Anything Goes. Foster’s ability to blend humor, dance, and vocal prowess sets her apart as one of the top performers of her generation. Her infectious personality and dazzling stage presence light up every performance, making her a must-see talent in the contemporary Broadway scene. Whether belting out a show-stopping number or delivering a tender ballad, Foster’s versatility shines through in every role.
7. Angela Lansbury
While Angela Lansbury is often remembered for her TV role in Murder, She Wrote, her contributions to Broadway are equally iconic. Her ability to embody characters like Mame Dennis in Mame and Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd showcased her incredible versatility and magnetic stage presence. Lansbury’s deep, resonant voice and impeccable comedic timing made her a Broadway legend, and her performances are still studied and revered by fans and aspiring actors alike.
8. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a true original—her larger-than-life personality and gritty voice made her an unforgettable presence on the Broadway stage. Stritch’s performance in Company, with the iconic rendition of “The Ladies Who Lunch,” remains etched in Broadway history. Her no-nonsense attitude and raw, emotional delivery made her a favorite among audiences. While not known for a traditionally “pretty” voice, Stritch’s ability to command a stage and communicate deeply felt emotions made her one of Broadway’s most unique and enduring stars.
9. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin’s voice is a force of nature—powerful, emotive, and dynamic. A master of both classical and contemporary Broadway, Patinkin’s performances in Evita and Sunday in the Park with George are among the most revered in musical theater history. His ability to convey deep emotion through song makes him one of the most compelling performers of his time. Patinkin’s soaring tenor can move an audience to tears one moment and have them on their feet the next.
10. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s voice is instantly recognizable—her belt is nothing short of iconic. Best known for her roles as Elphaba in Wicked and Maureen in Rent, Menzel has redefined what it means to be a Broadway star in the 21st century. Her rendition of “Defying Gravity” has become a modern anthem, and her ability to hit high notes with both power and emotion makes her a vocal powerhouse. Menzel’s performances are filled with intensity and heart, making her a fan favorite on and off the stage.
11. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a Broadway legend whose career spans over six decades. Known for her dance skills as much as her voice, Rivera originated iconic roles in shows like West Side Story and Chicago. Her fiery energy and unmatched stage presence make her performances unforgettable. Rivera’s voice, while not the most traditional, is filled with character and emotion, and her ability to combine singing, dancing, and acting has made her one of Broadway’s most versatile stars.
12. Lin-Manuel Miranda
Lin-Manuel Miranda may be best known as the genius behind Hamilton, but his own performances are equally impressive. Miranda’s ability to blend rap, traditional musical theater, and heartfelt emotion has redefined what it means to be a Broadway performer in the modern age. His performance as Alexander Hamilton showcased his dynamic vocal ability and deep understanding of storytelling through song. Miranda’s voice carries both the weight of history and modern innovation, making him a trailblazer in the world of Broadway.
13. Kristin Chenoweth
With a voice that can soar effortlessly into the stratosphere, Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway favorite. Best known for her role as Glinda in Wicked, Chenoweth’s soprano is both powerful and playful, capable of hitting high notes with ease while maintaining a light, bubbly tone. Her comedic timing and stage presence only add to her charm, making her one of the most beloved performers on the Broadway stage. Chenoweth’s unique voice and personality have made her a standout in every show she’s been a part of.
14. Hugh Jackman
Though he’s a major Hollywood star, Hugh Jackman’s roots are in musical theater, and his love for the stage is evident in every performance. Whether in The Boy from Oz or The Music Man, Jackman brings charisma, energy, and a powerful voice to every role. His ability to command the stage with charm and intensity makes him a favorite among Broadway audiences. Jackman’s versatility as both a singer and actor sets him apart, and his performances always leave the audience wanting more.
15. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s voice is often described as crystal-clear, and her performances are nothing short of breathtaking. Known for originating the roles of Kim in Miss Saigon and Eponine in Les Misérables, Salonga’s ability to convey deep emotion through her voice is unparalleled. Her pure, soaring soprano has made her one of Broadway’s most revered performers. Salonga’s global appeal and vocal excellence have left a lasting impact on both Broadway and the world of musical theater.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
