Broadway – the beating heart of musical theater, where dreams take flight and stars are born. For over a century, this glittering stage has been graced by performers whose voices have left audiences spellbound, transporting them to worlds of passion, heartbreak, and triumph. These iconic singers have not only defined the magic of the Great White Way but have also set the gold standard for theatrical excellence.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time – an elite group of vocal powerhouses who have redefined what it means to command the stage. From the golden age classics to contemporary trailblazers, these artists have delivered unforgettable performances that have become part of Broadway’s very DNA. With their extraordinary vocal range, emotional depth, and magnetic stage presence, these legends have brought to life characters and stories that continue to resonate across generations.
Whether you’re a lifelong theater aficionado or a newcomer eager to dive into Broadway’s rich history, prepare to be inspired as we take you on a journey through the lives and legacies of these unparalleled performers. Who made the list? Let the spotlight shine on the greatest voices to ever grace the Broadway stage!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman was a Broadway powerhouse whose voice could stop traffic. Known as the “Queen of Broadway,” she brought unmatched energy and confidence to every performance. Merman didn’t just sing—she delivered each song with brass, bite, and total conviction, making her impossible to ignore. In shows like Gypsy, Annie Get Your Gun, and Anything Goes, she set a standard for what it means to own a stage. Her crystal-clear diction and booming, unamplified voice were legendary—audiences in the back row could hear every syllable. “There’s No Business Like Show Business” became her signature anthem, not just because of its catchy tune, but because she lived and breathed that sentiment. She embodied the heart and soul of musical theater, blending wit, showmanship, and musicality in perfect harmony. Beyond her vocal power, Merman’s comedic timing and charisma made her a natural star. She didn’t just perform a role; she commanded the stage with confidence and joy. Even decades after her passing, her influence remains deeply embedded in Broadway tradition. Ethel Merman didn’t just perform musicals—she defined them. For anyone who loves the golden age of theater, her legacy is a masterclass in what it means to be a Broadway legend.
2. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters has long been a Broadway favorite, admired for her unmistakable voice, curly red hair, and spellbinding stage presence. There’s a magical quality to the way she performs—an emotional honesty that makes her characters feel heartbreakingly real. In Sunday in the Park with George and Into the Woods, she delivered performances that were both vocally stunning and emotionally raw. Peters has a unique gift for interpreting the complex, nuanced scores of Stephen Sondheim, effortlessly navigating challenging melodies while never losing the heart of the song. Her voice, with its sweet vibrato and emotional color, can be both playful and piercingly vulnerable. Whether she’s delivering a tender ballad or a biting solo, Peters always brings layers of depth and humanity. Her connection to the material is so intimate that audiences feel like she’s singing directly to them. But she’s more than just a voice—she’s a true actress, bringing subtlety and charm to every gesture and line. Bernadette Peters has earned her place as a Broadway icon not just because of her talent, but because of her ability to move people. She doesn’t just sing a song—she tells a story you’ll never forget.
3. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is Broadway’s fiery diva, a performer whose sheer intensity and vocal power make her unforgettable. Whether she’s belting “Don’t Cry for Me, Argentina” in Evita or commanding the stage in Gypsy, LuPone doesn’t just play a character—she inhabits it with every fiber of her being. Her voice is bold, rich, and full of drama, cutting through orchestras and grabbing the audience by the heart. What sets LuPone apart is her fearlessness—she never holds back, emotionally or vocally. There’s a sense of danger and unpredictability in her performances that keeps audiences riveted. She’s also known for her outspoken nature and fierce commitment to theatrical integrity, qualities that have made her both beloved and iconic in the theater community. Over the years, her performances have become benchmarks for aspiring actors—few can match her ability to combine raw emotion with technical excellence. Beyond her legendary vocal range, LuPone brings an emotional honesty that makes her characters deeply human. Watching her on stage is an experience—it’s powerful, emotional, and electric. Patti LuPone is a true Broadway original, the kind of performer whose presence changes the energy in a theater the moment she steps on stage.
4. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald isn’t just a Broadway star—she’s a once-in-a-generation talent. With a record-breaking six Tony Awards, she’s proven time and again that she can do it all. Her voice is a marvel: soaring, expressive, and capable of effortlessly moving between classical, jazz, and Broadway styles. From Ragtime to Porgy and Bess, she brings grace, strength, and emotional depth to every role. McDonald’s performances are marked by intelligence and vulnerability, whether she’s portraying a fierce mother, a complex historical figure, or a woman in love. What truly sets her apart is her ability to connect with audiences on an emotional level. Her singing isn’t just technically flawless—it’s profoundly moving. Every lyric feels lived-in, every note purposeful. Beyond the stage, McDonald has become a role model and advocate, using her platform to speak out for social justice and arts education. She’s admired not just for her voice, but for her integrity, thoughtfulness, and commitment to her craft. Audra McDonald represents the best of Broadway: an artist who constantly evolves while staying true to herself. Her legacy is still being written, but she already stands among the greats, inspiring the next generation of performers.
5. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews is the epitome of elegance and grace on stage. While many know her from iconic film roles like Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music, her Broadway roots run just as deep. Her breakout performance as Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady remains one of the most celebrated in musical theater history. Andrews possessed a soprano voice that was both pristine and powerful—crystal-clear in tone, with a lyrical purity that felt effortless. She brought an old-world charm to the stage, combined with precise diction and a natural warmth that made audiences instantly fall in love with her. Her regal bearing and unshakable poise set her apart from her peers, making her a shining example of classic Broadway style. Even as her career expanded into Hollywood and beyond, Andrews always retained the discipline and artistry of a stage performer. Her influence continues to be felt in generations of performers who admire her versatility, humility, and technical brilliance. Julie Andrews brought sophistication and sincerity to every role, proving that musical theater could be both dazzling and heartfelt. She is, and always will be, a symbol of Broadway excellence.
6. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury was one of Broadway’s most beloved and versatile stars. With a career that spanned decades, she brought intelligence, wit, and heart to every role she played. She wasn’t just an actress—she was a full-on storyteller. From the charming Mame to the chilling Sweeney Todd, Lansbury proved time and again that she could handle anything a musical threw at her. Her comedic instincts were razor-sharp, yet she also had the ability to reveal layers of emotion beneath even the most eccentric characters. Her performance as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd is a masterclass in character work: funny, dark, and unexpectedly poignant. She had an expressive voice, not known for its technical perfection, but for its remarkable storytelling power—it was honest, expressive, and full of personality. What truly made Lansbury stand out was her complete commitment to each character, no matter how quirky or complex. She didn’t chase the spotlight—it followed her because she was so magnetic. A consummate professional and a beloved figure in the theater world, Lansbury left behind a legacy of rich, unforgettable performances. She was the kind of actor who made Broadway feel magical, and her influence will be felt for generations.
7. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is pure Broadway sparkle. With a voice that can soar into the stratosphere and comedic timing that’s second to none, she’s carved out a space all her own in the world of musical theater. Her performance as Glinda in Wicked launched her into superstardom, but Chenoweth’s career is filled with brilliant moments on and off the stage. Her soprano is bright and agile, capable of lightning-fast runs and high notes that sound like sunshine. But beyond her technical prowess, she has an undeniable charm that draws audiences in. Chenoweth has the rare ability to make you laugh out loud one moment and tear up the next. Whether she’s singing a heartbreaking ballad or engaging in full-blown comedic mayhem, she always brings her full personality to the role. Her background in opera gives her a vocal edge, but it’s her Broadway spirit—bubbly, vibrant, and full of heart—that truly defines her. She’s also known for her humility and warmth offstage, endearing her even more to fans and colleagues. Kristin Chenoweth isn’t just a star—she’s a force of joy. Her performances are unforgettable, and she continues to shine as one of Broadway’s brightest lights.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s voice is a force of nature—raw, emotional, and powerful enough to bring down the house. Her breakout role as Maureen in Rent put her on the map, but it was as Elphaba in Wicked that she became a legend. Her performance of “Defying Gravity” didn’t just make waves—it became a defining moment in modern Broadway. Menzel’s voice, with its rich belt and husky texture, is instantly recognizable. But it’s not just about hitting high notes; it’s about the feeling behind them. She sings with an intensity that grabs you by the heart and doesn’t let go. There’s a vulnerability beneath the power that makes her performances feel deeply human. Offstage, Menzel has built a career in film and music, but her roots in theater run deep. She’s inspired countless young performers with her authenticity and courage, proving that being different—being yourself—is something to be celebrated. Menzel brings grit and soul to everything she touches. She’s not the kind of performer who plays it safe—and that’s exactly why audiences love her. With every performance, she reminds us why musical theater can be so thrilling, so moving, and so alive.
9. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is one of Broadway’s most passionate and unpredictable performers. Known for his expressive tenor voice and powerful presence, Patinkin doesn’t just sing a song—he pours his entire soul into it. His early work in Evita and Sunday in the Park with George showcased his unmatched ability to blend music and emotion in ways few can replicate. There’s an intensity to his performances that feels almost electric. He doesn’t just hit the notes; he explores every nuance, every emotional crack, every possibility a lyric can offer. His interpretations often feel like personal conversations, intimate and alive. Patinkin is also known for taking creative risks—sometimes challenging, always bold. Whether on Broadway, in concert, or on screen, he brings an unmatched emotional honesty to his work. While his style may not be for everyone, those who connect with him find a performer who leaves everything on the stage, night after night. He’s also an advocate for the arts and a generous collaborator. Mandy Patinkin is not just a Broadway performer—he’s an artist in the truest sense. His legacy is one of fearless creativity, and his impact on the world of musical theater is profound and lasting.
10. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a living legend whose contributions to Broadway are simply unmatched. With a career spanning over six decades, she has dazzled audiences with her extraordinary dance skills, fiery presence, and strong, expressive voice. Rivera’s performance as Anita in West Side Story marked the beginning of her long reign as one of musical theater’s most dynamic talents. Her work in Chicago, Bye Bye Birdie, and Kiss of the Spider Woman further solidified her status as Broadway royalty. Rivera has always had an electrifying stage presence—when she dances, she doesn’t just move, she commands. Her performances are a thrilling blend of physicality, emotion, and charisma. What makes Rivera truly remarkable is her ability to evolve while staying true to her artistry. She’s not just a performer—she’s a pioneer, especially for Latinx performers in theater. Even in her later years, she continues to perform with the same passion and fire that first captivated audiences. Rivera brings a level of professionalism and authenticity that’s become a gold standard in the industry. Her impact on Broadway isn’t just historical—it’s deeply personal for those who’ve watched her, worked with her, or dreamed of following in her footsteps.
11. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was one of a kind—brassy, bold, and utterly unforgettable. She wasn’t your typical Broadway leading lady, but that’s exactly what made her so iconic. With her sharp wit, gravelly voice, and razor-edged timing, Stritch carved out a place all her own in theater history. Her most famous performance, as Joanne in Stephen Sondheim’s Company, gave us the legendary rendition of “The Ladies Who Lunch.” It’s not just a song—it’s a full-blown experience. Stritch delivered it with a mix of sarcasm, vulnerability, and world-weary charm that made it unforgettable. She was a master of turning biting humor into poignant truth. Stritch didn’t just play characters—she became them, quirks and all. Whether in a rehearsal room or onstage in front of a full house, she was unapologetically herself: raw, honest, and often hilarious. She wasn’t afraid to take risks or speak her mind, and that authenticity made her magnetic. Offstage, she was equally compelling—open about her struggles, yet always fiercely determined. Elaine Stritch wasn’t just a performer—she was a force of personality, a true original who proved that charisma, confidence, and courage could be just as powerful as perfect pitch or polished notes.
12. Carol Channing
Carol Channing was pure Broadway joy—larger-than-life, instantly recognizable, and endlessly entertaining. With her unmistakable voice, animated expressions, and boundless energy, Channing lit up every stage she walked onto. Best known for her role as Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, she played the character more than 5,000 times throughout her career, making it one of the most iconic performances in musical theater history. Her version of “Before the Parade Passes By” is Broadway gold, full of heart, humor, and show-stopping charm. Channing had a way of making audiences feel like they were in on the fun. She broke the fourth wall with ease, inviting you into her world with a wink and a grin. But beneath the comedic sparkle was a deeply dedicated artist. She worked tirelessly, always delivering 110%, whether in a packed theater or a quiet rehearsal. Her personality was as radiant offstage as it was under the lights—gracious, funny, and fiercely committed to her craft. Carol Channing wasn’t just a performer; she was a celebration of everything Broadway stands for. Her joyful spirit, tireless dedication, and iconic roles left an indelible mark on musical theater and in the hearts of everyone who watched her perform.
13. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is the epitome of a modern Broadway star—talented, charismatic, and endlessly versatile. She burst onto the scene with her Tony-winning performance in Thoroughly Modern Millie, and from there, she’s been a consistent standout in productions like Anything Goes, Violet, and The Music Man. Foster brings a magnetic energy to the stage, lighting it up with her infectious smile, lightning-quick tap-dancing, and powerhouse vocals. But she’s more than just dazzling technique. There’s a sincerity in her performances that makes her characters feel relatable and real. Whether she’s belting out a show-stopping number or delivering a quiet, emotional moment, she has a way of drawing the audience in and making them care. Foster is also known for her remarkable work ethic and down-to-earth personality. She’s the kind of performer who makes even the most difficult choreography or vocal runs look effortless. Her blend of old-school Broadway flair and modern sensitivity makes her a favorite among both classic musical lovers and newer theater fans. Sutton Foster doesn’t just perform—she connects. Her presence on stage is like a shot of joy and inspiration, and she continues to set the bar for what it means to be a Broadway leading lady today.
14. Nathan Lane
Nathan Lane is a Broadway treasure—a comic genius with the heart and voice of a true showman. His work in The Producers, where he played the scheming but lovable Max Bialystock, is nothing short of legendary. Lane’s ability to command the stage with impeccable timing, physical comedy, and deep emotional insight sets him apart from the rest. He doesn’t just make you laugh—he makes you feel something deeper under the humor. With a rich baritone voice and an expressive face that can move from absurd hilarity to heartbreaking sincerity in a second, Lane has become one of the most respected performers in the business. Beyond The Producers, he’s shined in A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum, Angels in America, and The Front Page, proving his dramatic chops as well as his comedic brilliance. He brings a sense of craft to every role, digging into character with care and nuance. Lane’s presence is always a gift to the audience—warm, witty, and unmistakably authentic. Whether he’s making a crowd roar with laughter or leaving them in awe, Nathan Lane is a performer of the highest caliber. Broadway wouldn’t be the same without him.
15. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell has one of the most majestic voices in Broadway history. His rich baritone is smooth, commanding, and full of emotional depth—perfect for the sweeping, dramatic roles he’s known for. In shows like Ragtime, Kiss Me, Kate, and Man of La Mancha, Mitchell brought a grandeur and gravitas that few performers can match. He sings with both strength and sensitivity, delivering powerhouse performances that are as heartfelt as they are technically flawless. Beyond his vocal gifts, Mitchell possesses an incredible stage presence. He carries himself with dignity and grace, making every character feel noble, grounded, and fully alive. Whether portraying a dreamer, a revolutionary, or a romantic hero, he infuses his roles with intelligence and soul. Offstage, Mitchell is admired for his generosity and leadership within the theater community, including his work as chairman of The Actors Fund. He’s not just a great performer—he’s a great advocate for the arts. Brian Stokes Mitchell exemplifies what it means to be a Broadway star: talent, heart, and a deep respect for the craft. He’s a true gentleman of the stage, and his legacy continues to inspire singers, actors, and audiences around the world.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
