Broadway has long been the beating heart of musical theater, a dazzling world where powerful voices, magnetic stage presence, and unparalleled storytelling collide. Over the decades, the Great White Way has introduced us to a parade of extraordinary talent—artists who have not only redefined the art of performance but have also left an indelible mark on the history of theater. From soaring high notes to gut-wrenching ballads, these performers have brought characters to life with such passion and authenticity that they’ve become legends in their own right.
In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—icons whose voices echo far beyond the theater walls. These stars have captivated audiences with their vocal range, emotional depth, and undeniable charisma, earning standing ovations night after night. Whether it’s the commanding presence of a diva belting out a show-stopping anthem or the tender vulnerability of a performer bringing tears to our eyes, these artists embody the very essence of Broadway magic.
So, join us as we take a journey through the glittering history of Broadway, honoring the voices that have shaped the stage and inspired generations. Who made the cut? Let’s find out and relive the moments that made us fall in love with musical theater!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman, affectionately known as the “First Lady of Broadway,” set the gold standard for powerhouse vocals in musical theater. Her unmistakable, brassy voice—capable of cutting through an orchestra without the aid of a microphone—made her an unstoppable force on stage. Merman’s performances in Anything Goes, Annie Get Your Gun, and Gypsy showcased not just her formidable singing ability but also her natural comedic timing and stage presence.
She had a gift for delivering show-stopping numbers with unmatched energy, and songs like “I Got Rhythm” and “Everything’s Coming Up Roses” became Broadway anthems thanks to her electrifying performances. Her signature, vibrato-rich belt voice was the blueprint for generations of musical theater singers who followed in her footsteps.
Merman’s success was not just due to her vocal power but also her ability to fully embody the larger-than-life characters she played, bringing charm, humor, and undeniable charisma to every role. Even after her passing, her influence continues to resonate in Broadway revivals and recordings, proving that her impact on musical theater is truly timeless. There has never been another quite like Ethel Merman—her voice and presence remain iconic, cementing her status as one of Broadway’s greatest legends.
2. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is Broadway royalty, known for her commanding presence, unparalleled vocal power, and ability to bring complex characters to life with fiery passion. From her star-making, Tony-winning turn as Eva Perón in Evita to her unforgettable portrayal of Rose in Gypsy, LuPone has solidified her place as one of the most dynamic performers in musical theater history.
Her voice—a rich, dramatic belt with an unmistakable vibrato—has the ability to shake a theater to its core, while her acting prowess adds layers of depth and nuance to every role she inhabits. She brings an emotional rawness to her performances, making her characters feel deeply real and profoundly human.
LuPone is also known for her fierce commitment to the integrity of the theater, never hesitating to speak her mind about the importance of live performance. Whether she’s belting out “Don’t Cry for Me, Argentina” or commanding the stage in Company, her presence is electrifying. Few performers can match her intensity, and her legacy as one of Broadway’s most fearless and captivating leading ladies is firmly established.
With a career spanning decades and still going strong, Patti LuPone remains an unstoppable force in musical theater.
3. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is nothing short of a Broadway phenomenon. With six Tony Awards to her name—a record for any performer—she has consistently wowed audiences with her breathtaking soprano and emotionally resonant performances. Whether she’s taking on the heart-wrenching drama of Ragtime, the sweeping romance of Carousel, or the depth of Porgy and Bess, McDonald brings a rare combination of classical technique and raw, honest emotion to every role she plays.
Her voice, a seamless blend of operatic purity and Broadway power, is one of the most exquisite instruments in the theater world. What sets McDonald apart is her ability to make every performance deeply personal, making audiences feel every note and every lyric as if they were experiencing it firsthand.
Beyond her incredible vocal ability, McDonald is also a gifted actress who immerses herself completely in her roles, whether on stage, on screen, or in concert settings. She has also used her platform to advocate for diversity and inclusion in theater, inspiring countless performers. Few artists can match her level of excellence, and her contributions to Broadway have elevated the art form to new heights.
Audra McDonald is, quite simply, a once-in-a-lifetime talent.
4. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is the epitome of Broadway elegance, known for her distinctive voice, impeccable comedic timing, and ability to bring both warmth and vulnerability to her characters. A true theater legend, Peters has captivated audiences for decades with unforgettable performances in Sunday in the Park with George, Into the Woods, Annie Get Your Gun, and Gypsy.
Her signature voice—a sweet yet powerful soprano with a velvety tone—has become instantly recognizable. Whether delivering the playful wit of “You Could Drive a Person Crazy” or the heart-wrenching emotion of “Send in the Clowns,” Peters possesses an unmatched ability to connect deeply with her audience. She is particularly renowned for her collaborations with Stephen Sondheim, interpreting his intricate lyrics with nuance and emotional depth.
Beyond her immense vocal talents, Peters is also a phenomenal actress, capable of evoking laughter one moment and tears the next. Her performances are filled with sincerity, making every role uniquely her own. Even after decades in the industry, her star power remains undiminished. A true Broadway treasure, Bernadette Peters continues to inspire new generations of performers with her timeless artistry and radiant stage presence.
5. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury was a true theater legend, bringing grace, intelligence, and versatility to every role she played. Though she was known to many for her television role in Murder, She Wrote, Lansbury’s impact on Broadway was equally, if not more, profound. From Mame to Sweeney Todd, she proved time and time again that she was one of the most gifted and magnetic performers in musical theater history.
Her ability to seamlessly transition between lighthearted, comedic roles and deeply dramatic characters showcased her incredible range. Whether playing the flamboyant and witty Mame Dennis or the darkly sinister Mrs. Lovett, Lansbury brought a unique charisma that made her performances unforgettable.
Her voice—warm, expressive, and filled with character—was never about sheer power but about storytelling. She could make audiences laugh, cry, or even shudder with a simple shift in tone. Lansbury’s contributions to Broadway helped redefine the possibilities of what a musical theater actress could achieve, and her legacy continues to inspire actors today.
Few performers have left as lasting an imprint on Broadway as Angela Lansbury. She was a masterful actress, a consummate professional, and, above all, an irreplaceable part of theater history.
6. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is the quintessential Broadway star of the modern era—an unstoppable force of talent, charm, and boundless energy. From her breakthrough role in Thoroughly Modern Millie to standout performances in Anything Goes, Shrek the Musical, and The Music Man, Foster has dazzled audiences with her triple-threat abilities in singing, dancing, and acting.
Her voice—crystal-clear, strong, and expressive—brings an infectious joy to every performance. Whether belting out high-energy numbers like “Gimme Gimme” or delivering heartfelt ballads with emotional depth, she has an uncanny ability to make every song feel fresh and exciting.
Beyond her vocal talents, Foster’s comedic timing and onstage charisma make her an audience favorite. She brings a rare mix of classic Broadway style and modern-day relatability, making her roles feel both nostalgic and new. Offstage, she’s known for her humble and hardworking nature, qualities that have endeared her to both fans and fellow performers.
Sutton Foster is one of the brightest stars on Broadway today, and her legacy is already cemented as one of the most dynamic and beloved performers in theater history.
7. Julie Andrews
Julie Andrews is the embodiment of grace, talent, and vocal perfection. Though she became a household name through films like The Sound of Music and Mary Poppins, her roots are firmly planted in Broadway. Her star-making performances in My Fair Lady and Camelot set the stage for a legendary career that has spanned decades.
Andrews’ voice—pure, bell-like, and effortlessly controlled—set a standard of excellence that few have matched. She could glide effortlessly through the most challenging melodies, making even the most demanding songs sound easy. Her portrayal of Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady remains one of the most iconic in musical theater history, and her ability to bring regal elegance to any role made her one of the most beloved performers of her time.
Beyond her extraordinary vocal talent, Andrews was a masterful actress, able to balance sophistication with warmth and humor. Even as her singing career was cut short due to vocal surgery, her influence on Broadway and beyond remains immeasurable.
Julie Andrews is, and always will be, a symbol of timeless Broadway excellence, inspiring generations of performers with her grace, talent, and enduring legacy.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel redefined what it means to be a Broadway powerhouse. With a voice that soars effortlessly through thrilling high belts, she has become one of the most recognizable and influential figures in modern musical theater. From her breakout role as Maureen in Rent to her legendary performance as Elphaba in Wicked, Menzel has made an indelible mark on Broadway.
Her performance of “Defying Gravity” in Wicked is one of the most iconic moments in theater history, inspiring countless fans and singers alike. Her voice—a unique blend of raw emotional intensity and powerhouse vocals—brings every song to life with passion and urgency. Whether she’s singing about rebellion, heartbreak, or triumph, Menzel has an unparalleled ability to connect with audiences on a deeply personal level.
Beyond Broadway, Menzel gained worldwide recognition as the voice of Elsa in Disney’s Frozen, further cementing her place as a cultural icon. Her rendition of “Let It Go” became a global phenomenon, proving that her impact extends far beyond the stage.
Idina Menzel is a force of nature—bold, unapologetic, and immensely talented. Her legacy as one of Broadway’s most powerful voices is already written in theater history.
9. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga is a Broadway icon whose voice is synonymous with clarity, emotion, and breathtaking precision. She first captivated audiences with her groundbreaking performance as Kim in Miss Saigon, a role that earned her a Tony Award at just 18 years old. From that moment, it was clear that Salonga was something truly special.
Her voice is a rare gift—crystal-clear, effortlessly controlled, and capable of expressing the deepest emotions with just a single note. Whether performing “I’d Give My Life for You” from Miss Saigon or “On My Own” from Les Misérables, she delivers each song with heartfelt sincerity. Her ability to bring vulnerability and strength to her characters makes her performances unforgettable.
Beyond Broadway, Salonga is beloved as the singing voice of two Disney princesses—Jasmine in Aladdin and Mulan in Mulan. Her rendition of “Reflection” remains one of Disney’s most cherished ballads, further solidifying her place in musical history.
With an international career spanning decades, Salonga continues to inspire new generations of performers. Whether on Broadway, in concert halls, or lending her voice to animated classics, she remains a shining example of what it means to be a true Broadway legend.
10. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is the definition of a Broadway legend—an electrifying performer whose dancing, acting, and singing have shaped musical theater for generations. With a career spanning over six decades, she has set the gold standard for what it means to be a triple-threat performer.
Rivera first gained recognition as Anita in West Side Story, where her fiery stage presence and dynamic movement made her an instant star. She then went on to dazzle audiences in Chicago, Kiss of the Spider Woman, and countless other Broadway hits. Her ability to bring sultry elegance and raw emotion to every role has made her one of the most respected figures in theater history.
What sets Rivera apart is her extraordinary stamina and longevity. Even in her later years, she continued to command the stage with the same passion and intensity that defined her early career. Her commitment to her craft and her fearless approach to storytelling make her a true Broadway pioneer.
Chita Rivera’s legacy is one of power, grace, and an unstoppable dedication to the stage. Her influence can be seen in every dancer, singer, and actor who dreams of making it big on Broadway.
11. Carol Channing
Carol Channing was a Broadway institution—a performer whose singular voice and dazzling personality made her one of the most beloved figures in musical theater history. Best known for her legendary portrayal of Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, Channing’s effervescent energy and comedic brilliance captivated audiences for decades.
Her voice, instantly recognizable with its distinctive rasp and playful charm, brought a unique magic to every role she played. Whether singing “Diamonds Are a Girl’s Best Friend” in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes or “Before the Parade Passes By” in Hello, Dolly!, Channing had an unmatched ability to light up the stage.
But beyond her remarkable talent, what made Channing truly special was her connection with audiences. She had a rare gift for making every performance feel personal, as if she were sharing an inside joke with the entire theater. Her warmth and charisma made her a performer people adored, both on and off the stage.
Carol Channing was Broadway’s eternal ray of sunshine, a performer whose legacy continues to bring joy to theater lovers everywhere. Even now, her influence shines brightly, reminding us of the pure magic of live performance.
12. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway phenomenon—a performer whose stunning soprano and infectious personality have made her one of the most beloved stars of the modern era. With a voice that effortlessly soars through dazzling high notes, she has captivated audiences in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, Wicked, and On the Twentieth Century.
Her portrayal of Glinda in Wicked cemented her place in Broadway history, with her showstopping performance of “Popular” becoming an instant classic. Chenoweth’s ability to blend comedic brilliance with sincere emotion makes her one of the most versatile performers on stage today.
Beyond Broadway, she has made her mark in television, film, and music, proving that her talent knows no bounds. Whether she’s belting out a Broadway ballad or delivering rapid-fire comedic dialogue, she does it all with charm and precision.
Kristin Chenoweth is the ultimate Broadway powerhouse—a performer whose presence lights up any stage. Her extraordinary voice, boundless energy, and delightful personality continue to inspire theater lovers around the world.
13. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is a Broadway master, known for his rich baritone voice and deeply emotional performances. His ability to tell a story through song is unparalleled, making him one of the most compelling actors in musical theater history.
His breakout role as Che in Evita showcased his ability to bring intensity and depth to a character, but it was his performance as George in Sunday in the Park with George that solidified his status as a Broadway legend. His rendition of “Finishing the Hat” is one of the most deeply affecting moments in musical theater—a raw, heartfelt portrayal of an artist’s struggle.
What sets Patinkin apart is his ability to make every song feel like a personal confession. Whether performing Stephen Sondheim’s intricate lyrics or delivering a heart-wrenching ballad, he has a way of pulling audiences into his world, making them feel every emotion along with him.
Mandy Patinkin is more than just a Broadway star—he’s a storyteller, a vocal powerhouse, and an artist who continues to redefine what it means to perform on stage. His legacy is one of passion, artistry, and an unwavering commitment to the craft.
14. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a force of nature—a performer whose razor-sharp wit, fearless honesty, and commanding stage presence made her one of Broadway’s most unforgettable stars. Best known for her performance in Company, where she delivered the definitive version of “The Ladies Who Lunch,” Stritch had an unmatched ability to captivate an audience.
Her voice—raw, expressive, and filled with character—was not about perfection, but about authenticity. Every performance felt like a masterclass in storytelling, filled with humor, vulnerability, and an undeniable edge. Stritch didn’t just play characters—she became them, bringing a realness to the stage that few could match.
Beyond her musical talents, she was a true Broadway personality, known for her no-nonsense attitude and candid interviews. She was a performer who lived and breathed theater, and her passion for the stage was evident in every role she took on.
Elaine Stritch wasn’t just a Broadway star—she was a Broadway institution. Her legacy is one of fearless storytelling, iconic performances, and a reminder that sometimes, the most unforgettable stars are the ones who break all the rules.
15. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand is a name that transcends Broadway—she is a global icon, a once-in-a-lifetime talent whose voice and artistry have left an indelible mark on the world of entertainment. But before she became a Hollywood and music legend, she was a Broadway star, wowing audiences with her stunning debut in Funny Girl.
Her performance as Fanny Brice in Funny Girl was nothing short of groundbreaking. Songs like “People” and “Don’t Rain on My Parade” became instant classics, showcasing her breathtaking vocal power and emotional depth. With her unmatched ability to blend vulnerability and strength, Streisand redefined what it meant to be a Broadway leading lady.
Though her Broadway career was brief, her influence on musical theater remains profound. Her unique voice—filled with emotion, richness, and technical brilliance—has inspired generations of performers.
Barbra Streisand is more than just a Broadway legend—she’s a cultural icon, a true artist, and one of the greatest voices of all time.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
