When it comes to the dazzling world of Broadway, the magic of musical theater often hinges on the power of the voice. The best Broadway singers have not only captivated audiences with their stunning vocal abilities but have also left an indelible mark on the art form itself. From soaring ballads that tug at the heartstrings to electrifying showstoppers that bring the house down, these performers have defined and redefined what it means to be a star on the Great White Way.
In this article, we will embark on a thrilling journey through the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time. We’ll explore the legendary talents who have graced the stage, from the golden age of musicals to the contemporary hits that resonate today. Each of these artists has a unique story, a signature style, and a vocal prowess that has enchanted audiences and inspired generations of performers. Whether it’s the emotional depth of a heart-wrenching solo or the exhilarating energy of a full-cast number, these singers have showcased the transformative power of music. Join us as we celebrate their remarkable contributions and discover why they remain unforgettable icons in the world of Broadway!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is often referred to as the epitome of Broadway excellence, a legendary figure whose powerful voice and commanding stage presence became synonymous with the golden age of musical theater. Born in 1908, Merman’s remarkable ability to belt out iconic songs with an unmatched vocal strength was central to her success in some of Broadway’s most beloved productions, including Annie Get Your Gun and Gypsy. With an innate ability to project her voice to the back rows of any theater without the need for microphones, Merman’s vocal prowess became legendary. Her rendition of “There’s No Business Like Show Business” from Annie Get Your Gun remains one of her signature moments, encapsulating her personality, energy, and her undeniable star power. Merman’s influence stretched far beyond her own performances, as she set a standard that many aspiring Broadway performers still strive to achieve. She introduced audiences to the full force of musical theater, where emotion, voice, and character intertwine in unforgettable ways. Her vocal style, marked by a brassy, no-nonsense approach, created an unmistakable sound that defined an era. Even after her passing in 1984, Merman’s legacy continues to echo through the world of Broadway. Aspiring performers, especially those hoping to fill the shoes of a musical theater legend, often look to her for inspiration. Ethel Merman’s role in shaping the Broadway landscape is immeasurable, and her name will forever be etched in the annals of musical theater history.
2. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is a force of nature whose unmatched vocal power and undeniable stage presence have earned her a permanent place among Broadway’s elite. Known for her commanding performances in shows like Evita and Gypsy, LuPone’s ability to pour raw emotion into every note she sings is what makes her performances so electric. Her vocal range, dramatic intensity, and fearlessness in taking on the most challenging roles have garnered her a devoted fan base. One of the most iconic moments in her career came with her portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita, where she delivered an unforgettable rendition of the anthem “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina.” LuPone’s interpretation of the song remains one of the most memorable in musical theater history, capturing both the ambition and vulnerability of the character in a way that few performers could. Her commitment to the craft of musical theater is evident in her consistently electrifying performances, where she combines raw emotion with impeccable technique. Whether playing a woman of power or someone with deep emotional struggles, LuPone’s mastery of her craft is unparalleled. Offstage, she is just as fierce in her advocacy for artists and her stance on issues facing the theater community, demonstrating her passion for the art form extends beyond just performance. Patti LuPone’s career has been defined by her dedication to excellence, and she continues to inspire new generations of performers who look up to her as a model of artistry, authenticity, and unparalleled talent.
3. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand is a musical icon whose contributions to Broadway and beyond have earned her a permanent place in the hearts of fans around the world. Known for her distinct voice that effortlessly moves from powerful, belting notes to delicate, tender moments, Streisand’s career has spanned across musical theater, pop music, film, and television. Her breakout role in Funny Girl catapulted her to stardom, and from that point, she became synonymous with both musical excellence and an ability to evoke raw, heartfelt emotion through song. Streisand’s voice, often described as rich and expressive, captivated audiences in both intimate settings and large concert halls. Songs like “People,” from Funny Girl, showcase her ability to turn simple melodies into something profoundly moving, encapsulating not just technical skill but a deep emotional connection with the material. Her blend of Broadway and pop music styles allowed her to cross over to mainstream success, making her one of the most versatile and beloved artists of all time. Throughout her career, Streisand has continued to break barriers, from being one of the first women to produce her own albums to becoming one of the few performers to achieve success across multiple entertainment platforms. With an illustrious career filled with numerous accolades, Streisand’s voice remains timeless, and her legacy in the world of musical theater is undeniable. She paved the way for future generations of performers, showing that with talent, authenticity, and determination, one can achieve greatness in multiple facets of the entertainment world.
4. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald’s name has become synonymous with excellence in musical theater. With a career spanning decades and an incredible six Tony Awards to her name, McDonald is a true powerhouse whose voice and emotional depth continue to captivate audiences worldwide. Known for her extraordinary vocal range and incredible precision, McDonald has graced the stage in some of the most challenging and iconic roles in musical theater. Her versatility shines in a wide array of productions, from the haunting beauty of Porgy and Bess to the whimsical fantasy of Into the Woods. McDonald’s ability to bring characters to life through her voice is unparalleled, blending technical mastery with an emotional sincerity that makes each performance unique. Whether portraying a soulful character in a classic American opera or a beloved figure in a contemporary Broadway musical, her performances resonate deeply with audiences. Her voice, warm and lush, possesses a clarity and precision that allows her to move between the subtlety of classical music and the energy of musical theater with ease. One of McDonald’s most beloved performances came in her portrayal of Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, where her raw interpretation of Holiday’s pain and joy through music was transformative. Audra McDonald is a true artist, known not only for her impeccable technique but also for her passion for storytelling and the way she connects with every role she inhabits. Her remarkable ability to convey complex emotions and her tireless work ethic have made her a leading figure in musical theater, and she continues to inspire both audiences and fellow performers alike.
5. John Legend
John Legend, a gifted singer, songwriter, and producer, has transcended the worlds of pop and R&B to become an influential figure in musical theater as well. Although he first garnered fame with his chart-topping hits and smooth, soulful voice, Legend’s contributions to Broadway have made a significant impact, blending contemporary music with traditional storytelling. His Broadway debut came in the production of Jitney, where his smooth, soulful voice and natural acting ability were on full display. Legend’s background in music, coupled with his ability to emotionally connect with his material, made him a standout performer in the show, earning critical acclaim for his role. He brings a unique perspective to the stage, offering an artistic crossover between genres that is rare in Broadway theater. Legend’s move into musical theater is a reflection of his belief in the power of music to tell meaningful stories. He has also been involved in producing and writing original music for theater, and his role in the Broadway production of Jesus Christ Superstar Live showcased his ability to seamlessly bridge genres while maintaining his distinctive voice. For Legend, musical theater is more than just another stage to perform on—it is an opportunity to express complex emotions and social issues through music, just as he has done in his other work. As an artist who continues to evolve and break new ground, John Legend’s presence on Broadway has enriched the landscape of musical theater, helping to bring a modern voice to the stage while honoring the tradition of storytelling through song.
6. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is one of the most iconic voices in contemporary Broadway theater, known for her remarkable vocal range and powerful stage presence. Menzel first gained national recognition for her role as Maureen Johnson in the groundbreaking musical Rent, where her performance of “Seasons of Love” became an anthem for audiences everywhere. However, it was her portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked that truly cemented her place in Broadway history. Menzel’s delivery of “Defying Gravity,” a song that has since become a symbol of empowerment and resilience, showcased not only her stunning vocal ability but also her capacity to infuse her performances with raw emotion. Her voice, powerful and piercing when necessary, is also capable of subtlety, effortlessly navigating complex emotional landscapes in songs that challenge the limits of vocal technique. Offstage, Menzel has also captured hearts worldwide through her role as Elsa in the Frozen franchise, where her song “Let It Go” became a worldwide phenomenon. What sets Menzel apart is her ability to make her voice resonate with both technical precision and deep emotional truth. Her performances convey a sense of vulnerability and strength in equal measure, making her one of the most respected and celebrated artists on Broadway today. In addition to her stage work, Menzel has also embraced other genres, performing in concerts around the world and recording music that transcends Broadway. Idina Menzel’s contributions to musical theater are immeasurable, and she remains one of the most influential performers of her generation.
7. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera’s name is synonymous with Broadway excellence, and she stands as one of the true trailblazers in the history of musical theater. A legend in every sense of the word, Rivera’s career began when she originated the role of Anita in West Side Story, a part that would define her for years to come. With a career spanning over six decades, Rivera has demonstrated an extraordinary ability to bring both fierce energy and grace to the stage, making her one of the most beloved performers in Broadway history. Her dynamic presence, combined with her impeccable dance ability, has earned her iconic roles in productions such as Chicago and Kiss of the Spider Woman. Rivera’s voice is rich and strong, but it’s her ability to blend powerful singing with intricate dance choreography that sets her apart from other performers. Her performances are always a masterclass in combining vocal technique with physical storytelling. Beyond her raw talent, Rivera’s pioneering role as one of the first Latina stars on Broadway paved the way for generations of performers from diverse backgrounds to find success in the theater world. Her impact cannot be overstated, as she continues to inspire countless artists who look up to her as both a performer and a trailblazer. Chita Rivera’s legacy is one of breaking barriers and redefining what it means to be a star of the stage. With her enduring talent, fierce determination, and incredible versatility, Rivera remains one of the defining figures in the history of musical theater.
8. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s voice is one that has captured the hearts of audiences all over the world, earning her a place among the greats of musical theater. With her breathtaking soprano voice and exceptional ability to convey deep emotion through song, Salonga’s performances are always a standout. Her breakthrough role in Miss Saigon made her an international star, with her portrayal of Kim in the emotionally charged musical earning her a Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical. Salonga’s vocal range and control allow her to effortlessly navigate the complexities of songs with both power and sensitivity. Her performance of “I Dreamed a Dream” in Les Misérables is a perfect example of her ability to take a well-known song and infuse it with her own unique emotional depth, making it entirely her own. Beyond her impressive vocal ability, Salonga’s acting skill is equally extraordinary, as she is able to fully inhabit her characters and make them resonate with authenticity. Salonga’s career has spanned across continents, and she has become a global ambassador for musical theater. Her performances in the Philippines, London, and on Broadway have solidified her as one of the most respected and beloved musical theater performers of her time. Lea Salonga’s contributions to musical theater are immeasurable, and her ability to connect with audiences on an emotional level through her voice and storytelling continues to make her an icon of the stage.
9. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell’s name is synonymous with the golden era of Broadway, where he became known for his rich baritone voice that has the rare ability to captivate an entire theater with its warmth and depth. Mitchell’s career began in the 1980s, but it was his role in the 1999 revival of Kiss Me, Kate that truly established him as a leading man of Broadway. His voice, deep and resonant, brings a sense of authority to every role he takes on, and his performances are often marked by an emotional sincerity that makes his characters feel authentic and relatable. His work in Ragtime further cemented his place as one of Broadway’s leading actors, where he gave an unforgettable performance as Coalhouse Walker Jr. One of Mitchell’s greatest strengths is his ability to infuse his performances with genuine emotion, drawing the audience in with every note and lyric. His voice has a commanding quality that is never overbearing, allowing him to convey both strength and vulnerability with equal precision. Whether in a classic musical like Man of La Mancha or more contemporary productions, Mitchell’s contributions to musical theater are undeniable. His powerful performances have earned him numerous accolades, including Tony Award nominations and wins, and his impact on Broadway cannot be overstated. Brian Stokes Mitchell’s artistry has left an indelible mark on the stage, and his enduring legacy is a testament to his remarkable talent and dedication to the craft of musical theater.
10. Kristen Chenoweth
Kristen Chenoweth’s boundless energy, incredible vocal range, and infectious personality have made her one of Broadway’s most beloved stars. Known for her portrayal of Glinda in Wicked, Chenoweth brought her own unique brand of charm and humor to the role, creating a character that was equal parts bubbly and deeply sincere. Her vocal range, which spans from a high soprano to a rich belt, allows her to tackle a variety of musical styles with ease, making her one of the most versatile performers on the Broadway stage. Chenoweth’s performances are always infused with a sense of fun and joy, making her a favorite among both fans and fellow performers. In addition to her work in Wicked, Chenoweth has had memorable performances in You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, where her portrayal of Sally Brown earned her a Tony Award, and Promises, Promises, which showcased her comedic timing and sharp wit. Chenoweth’s career has also branched into television and film, where her performances in shows like Pushing Daisies and Glee have further endeared her to audiences. What makes Chenoweth such a standout talent is not just her vocal ability, but her ability to light up the stage with her infectious enthusiasm and wit. Kristen Chenoweth continues to bring joy and laughter to audiences with her performances, and her legacy in musical theater is one of warmth, talent, and a true love for the art form.
11. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury’s incredible career has spanned over seven decades, earning her a place as one of the most respected and beloved figures in the world of musical theater. Known for her versatility and enduring talent, Lansbury’s work on Broadway has had an immeasurable impact, and her performances continue to captivate audiences of all ages. Her career began in the 1940s, but it was her iconic role as the formidable Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd that showcased the depth of her talent. Lansbury’s portrayal of the character, whose dark humor and deep pathos were brought to life with nuance and wit, earned her a Tony Award and became one of her most celebrated performances. She is also widely recognized for her work in Mame, where she delivered a performance that was equal parts charming, hilarious, and heartwarming. What sets Lansbury apart is her ability to tackle a wide range of roles, from comedic to dramatic, and make each one her own. Her distinctive voice, which is rich and warm, is perfectly suited to the musical theater stage, and she has a remarkable ability to imbue every character with a deep sense of humanity. Beyond her work on Broadway, Lansbury became a beloved television star with Murder, She Wrote, but her theater roots have always remained at the core of her career. Angela Lansbury’s enduring legacy is one of unwavering dedication to the craft of acting, and her influence on musical theater is felt to this day.
12. Vanessa Williams
Vanessa Williams is a multi-talented performer whose career has been marked by her stunning versatility and ability to excel in a variety of artistic fields. Best known for her work in music, film, and television, Williams also made an indelible mark on Broadway with her performance in Kiss of the Spider Woman. Her portrayal of the seductive and tragic character of Aurora earned her widespread acclaim and solidified her as a powerhouse performer on the Great White Way. Williams’s vocal ability is breathtaking, with a warm, soulful voice that resonates deeply with audiences. Her performances are always infused with an emotional authenticity that allows her to connect with the audience on a personal level. In addition to her Broadway career, Williams has had a successful music career, earning numerous accolades, including Grammy nominations, and her hits like “Save the Best for Last” became iconic songs of the ’90s. Williams’s ability to move seamlessly between musical genres, from pop to Broadway to jazz, speaks to her remarkable versatility and dedication to her craft. She has also been a trailblazer for women of color in entertainment, breaking down barriers and becoming a role model for countless aspiring performers. Vanessa Williams’s enduring career is a testament to her artistry, resilience, and the power of her voice, which continues to inspire and uplift audiences everywhere.
13. Norm Lewis
Norm Lewis is a true pioneer in the world of Broadway, known for his powerful, evocative voice and groundbreaking performances. His career reached a historic milestone when he became the first African American to portray the role of the Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera. Lewis’s voice, rich and soulful, is perfectly suited to the grandiose nature of Broadway, and his performance as the Phantom was praised for its emotional depth and vocal precision. His ability to convey complex emotions through song is unparalleled, and his presence on stage commands attention from the moment he steps into the spotlight. In addition to The Phantom of the Opera, Lewis has earned acclaim for his performances in Porgy and Bess and Les Misérables, where his portrayal of Javert further solidified his status as one of Broadway’s finest talents. What makes Lewis a standout performer is not just his vocal ability, but his incredible stage presence and the emotional depth he brings to each role. He is able to take on characters with emotional complexity and give them a level of humanity that resonates with audiences long after the final curtain. Norm Lewis’s contributions to Broadway are groundbreaking, and his ability to connect with audiences on a profound level has made him one of the most respected performers in the theater world.
14. Kelli O’Hara
Kelli O’Hara’s voice is one of the purest and most stunning in all of musical theater, and she has earned a place as one of Broadway’s most respected performers. Known for her incredible soprano voice, O’Hara has become a fixture in the world of musical theater, with standout performances in productions like The King and I and South Pacific. Her portrayal of Anna Leonowens in The King and I earned her a Tony Award and cemented her place among the greatest Broadway stars of her generation. O’Hara’s voice is delicate and powerful at the same time, capable of capturing both the fragility and strength of her characters. Her performances are marked by emotional honesty and an incredible ability to convey vulnerability, which makes her stand out in every role she plays. Her portrayal of Nellie Forbush in South Pacific showcased her ability to tackle both the dramatic and the lighthearted aspects of a role, making her one of the most versatile actresses of her generation. O’Hara’s artistry extends beyond the stage, as she has also become known for her work in concert and recording, where her vocal ability continues to shine. Her performances are always marked by grace and integrity, and her contributions to Broadway have made her one of the most beloved and respected figures in the theater world today.
15. Matthew Morrison
Matthew Morrison’s rise to fame began on Broadway, where his smooth voice and charismatic stage presence quickly made him a star. He gained recognition for his role in Hairspray, but it was his portrayal of the charming and conflicted high school teacher Will Schuester on Glee that propelled him to national stardom. Morrison’s performance on Glee allowed him to showcase his vocal range and ability to balance humor with emotional depth, earning him legions of fans and critical acclaim. His voice is both smooth and powerful, and he has a remarkable ability to connect with his audience through both comedic and serious roles. Offstage, Morrison’s career has flourished, with performances in shows like The Light in the Piazza and South Pacific, where his vocal abilities were showcased alongside his acting talent. Morrison has also found success in recording and performing in concert, where his effortless charm and vocal talent continue to win over audiences. What sets Morrison apart is his ability to bridge the worlds of Broadway and television, becoming a contemporary icon in musical theater while remaining a beloved performer in pop culture. His dedication to the craft of musical theater and his ability to connect with fans in both intimate and large-scale settings have solidified him as one of the most versatile and admired performers of his generation.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
