Broadway has long been regarded as the pinnacle of musical theater, a dazzling stage where talent and passion collide to create unforgettable performances. From the soaring heights of “Les Misérables” to the joyous exuberance of “Hamilton,” the voices that have graced these iconic productions have left an indelible mark on the hearts of audiences worldwide. In this article, we celebrate the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time—artists whose extraordinary vocal abilities and emotional depth have not only defined the genre but have also shaped the very essence of musical storytelling.
These remarkable performers have transcended mere entertainment, bringing characters to life with stunning interpretations and powerful delivery. Whether through the sweeping ballads that echo in grand theaters or the intimate moments that resonate in smaller venues, each singer has carved a unique niche in Broadway history. Get ready to discover the legends who have inspired generations, captivated crowds, and set the standard for excellence in musical theater. Join us as we explore the voices that have made Broadway a beloved institution, celebrating their contributions and reliving the magic that only these exceptional talents can create.
1. Barbra Streisand
Barbra Streisand is a true icon whose unparalleled voice has transcended the worlds of Broadway, film, and pop music. With a career that spans over six decades, Streisand has captivated audiences with her emotive and commanding performances. Her rise to fame began with her role in Funny Girl, where her portrayal of Fanny Brice earned her not only critical acclaim but also cemented her as one of the greatest talents of her generation. What sets Streisand apart is her ability to convey deep emotion through every note, allowing listeners to feel the heart and soul of every song she performs.
Streisand’s voice is a force of nature, rich and full of texture, capable of conveying both incredible power and delicate vulnerability. Her performances in shows like Funny Girl and Hello, Dolly! exemplify this, as she effortlessly shifts between humor and heartache, evoking deep empathy in the audience. Her distinctive sound has made her a global superstar, and her recordings, from The Broadway Album to Barbra: The Concert, showcase her incredible vocal technique and emotional depth.
Beyond her vocal prowess, Streisand’s contributions to musical theater and film have left an indelible mark on the industry. She has won numerous awards, including multiple Grammys, an Oscar, and a Tony, proving her versatility and mastery across various forms of entertainment. Streisand is not just a singer; she is an artist whose performances resonate deeply, making her one of the most respected and admired performers in the world of musical theater and beyond.
2. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a true powerhouse, widely celebrated for her astonishing vocal range and deep emotional resonance. With a remarkable six Tony Awards to her name, McDonald has redefined what it means to be a leading lady on Broadway. Her career spans decades and encompasses a diverse range of roles, from the heartbreaking Bess in Porgy and Bess to the soul-stirring Billie Holiday in Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill. McDonald’s ability to embody the emotional depth of each character is unmatched, leaving audiences not only in awe of her technical skill but also moved by the vulnerability and strength she brings to her roles.
One of McDonald’s greatest strengths is her versatility. Whether performing in a dramatic musical, a classical opera, or a contemporary piece, she has a unique ability to seamlessly transition between genres. Her powerful soprano voice is capable of soaring effortlessly through the highest notes, while also delivering rich, velvety lows that resonate with warmth and strength. This combination of vocal agility and emotional depth has earned McDonald a dedicated following, and her live performances are nothing short of magical.
Beyond her stage work, McDonald has also enjoyed success in television and film, earning recognition for her roles in productions like The Good Wife and Wicked. Her influence extends far beyond the theater, as she continues to inspire and mentor younger performers. Audra McDonald’s legacy is defined not only by her extraordinary talent but by the emotional authenticity she brings to each of her performances, solidifying her place as one of the greatest voices of our time.
3. Liza Minnelli
Liza Minnelli, the daughter of Hollywood legend Judy Garland, is a Broadway icon whose dynamic stage presence and captivating voice have made her a beloved figure in musical theater. Minnelli’s rise to fame was marked by her unforgettable performance in Cabaret, where she brought the character of Sally Bowles to life with a combination of raw energy, wit, and vulnerability. Her performance in this role became one of the most iconic in Broadway history, and her ability to imbue every song with emotional depth made her an instant star.
Minnelli’s voice, a unique blend of power and delicacy, has a vibrancy that resonates deeply with audiences. Whether performing in Cabaret, The Act, or Liza with a Z, she has the rare ability to completely transform a song, making it uniquely her own. Her distinctive vocal style, which combines elements of jazz, pop, and theater, has earned her a special place in the hearts of fans worldwide.
What truly sets Minnelli apart, however, is her unparalleled energy and fearlessness on stage. No matter the venue or role, she brings a level of intensity and passion that is unmatched, creating an electric atmosphere wherever she performs. Her ability to connect with audiences, to share her emotions so openly, has made her not only a Broadway legend but also a global star whose influence continues to be felt in the world of musical theater and beyond. Minnelli’s legacy as an entertainer is defined by her vibrant spirit, vocal versatility, and the timeless energy she brings to every performance.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is the epitome of Broadway brilliance. Known for her fierce vocal talent and commanding stage presence, LuPone has captivated audiences for decades with her powerful performances. Whether playing the passionate and tragic Eva Perón in Evita or the complex and multi-dimensional Rose in Gypsy, LuPone’s ability to embody her characters is unparalleled. Her bold, no-holds-barred approach to performing has earned her a reputation as one of the most dynamic voices in musical theater, and her ability to bring raw emotion to every role she tackles is nothing short of extraordinary.
LuPone’s voice is a force to be reckoned with. Powerful and filled with emotion, it has the rare ability to fill a room with both subtlety and grandeur. Her performances are marked by an emotional intensity that is unmatched, and her singing is always deeply connected to the story she is telling. Whether belting out a soaring anthem or delivering a quiet, intimate moment, LuPone’s voice never fails to move the audience.
Beyond her vocal prowess, LuPone’s stage presence is magnetic. She commands the stage with every gesture and look, pulling audiences into the world of the character she is portraying. Her ability to shift between fierce determination and tender vulnerability has made her one of the most respected and admired actresses in the world of musical theater. Patti LuPone’s legacy is defined not only by her extraordinary voice but by her fearless commitment to creating deeply authentic and emotionally powerful performances that continue to inspire new generations of theatergoers and performers alike.
5. Bernadette Peters
With a voice that combines sweetness and power, Bernadette Peters has been enchanting audiences for over five decades. Known for her roles in Into the Woods, Song and Dance, and Annie Get Your Gun, Peters is celebrated not only for her vocal talent but also for her ability to capture the vulnerability and complexity of the characters she plays. Peters’ voice has a unique, ethereal quality that allows her to seamlessly transition between delicate, soft passages and bold, powerful statements, creating a dynamic and emotionally resonant performance every time she steps on stage.
Peters’ talent for blending vulnerability with strength has made her a beloved figure in musical theater. Her portrayal of The Witch in Into the Woods is one of the most iconic performances in Broadway history, as she infused the character with both sharp wit and a deep emotional core. Peters’ performances are marked by an attention to detail that brings nuance and depth to every role she tackles, and her ability to connect with the audience on a deeply personal level makes her performances unforgettable.
In addition to her vocal brilliance, Peters’ stage presence is magnetic. She has an innate ability to make every performance feel intimate, no matter how large the venue. Her expressive face and body language draw the audience in, making them feel as though they are experiencing the story right alongside her. Bernadette Peters has cemented her place as one of the most revered and enduring voices in musical theater, and her influence continues to inspire new generations of performers who look to her as a model of artistry, authenticity, and grace.
6. Josh Groban
Josh Groban is one of the most distinctive voices in contemporary music, known for his stunning tenor and a versatility that spans both classical and Broadway genres. While Groban’s roots lie in pop music, his deep connection to musical theater has made him a standout performer on Broadway stages as well. His performance in Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 showcased his remarkable ability to blend operatic training with a contemporary sensibility, making him an immediate sensation in the theater world. His rich voice, capable of soaring to great heights with emotional resonance, has earned him a special place among the most respected voices in both the classical and musical theater realms.
Groban’s voice is full of warmth and sincerity, able to convey deep emotion through its expansive range. Whether performing a heartbreaking ballad or a lively, upbeat number, he imbues every note with depth and passion. His training in classical music is evident in his powerful vocal technique, yet his ability to bring modern sensibilities to Broadway performances makes him uniquely suited to the stage.
Beyond his impressive vocal abilities, Groban has demonstrated his remarkable versatility in a variety of settings. Whether recording hit albums that mix pop with classical influences, or stepping into the limelight for a Broadway performance, he consistently brings authenticity and heart to his work. His natural charisma and dedication to his craft have earned him a devoted following, making him one of the most beloved figures in both musical theater and contemporary music. Josh Groban’s Broadway journey continues to inspire, bridging classical and modern elements in a way that resonates with both theatergoers and music lovers alike.
7. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel is a powerhouse of vocal talent whose rise to fame began with her iconic portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked. Her extraordinary vocal range, marked by her ability to hit high notes with effortless precision, and her emotive performances have made her a standout star in the world of Broadway. Menzel’s performance as the misunderstood witch in Wicked captivated audiences with her fierce, yet vulnerable interpretation of the role, and her rendition of “Defying Gravity” became an instant anthem for Broadway fans.
Menzel’s voice is known for its clarity, power, and emotional depth, which she uses to convey complex characters and emotions. Her ability to sing with both power and subtlety is a hallmark of her style. Whether belting out an anthem or delivering a quieter, more intimate moment, Menzel’s voice can break your heart and make you cheer with excitement all at once. This versatility has helped her carve out a permanent place on Broadway, and her performances continue to be some of the most thrilling moments in theater.
In addition to Wicked, Menzel’s career spans numerous successful Broadway productions, including Rent, If/Then, and Frozen (the film and the Broadway adaptation). Her status as a Broadway superstar is solidified not only by her vocal talent but by her ability to bring depth and humanity to every character she portrays. Idina Menzel’s legacy continues to inspire countless performers who aspire to follow in her footsteps, and her voice will forever remain one of the most recognizable and beloved in musical theater history.
8. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is one of Broadway’s most celebrated leading men, known for his rich baritone voice and commanding stage presence. His career has spanned decades, and his performances in shows such as Kiss Me, Kate and Ragtime have made him a beloved figure in the world of musical theater. Mitchell’s ability to portray complex characters with grace and authenticity has earned him widespread acclaim, and his smooth, powerful voice has captivated audiences in every performance. Whether in the role of the charming Fred Graham in Kiss Me, Kate or the dignified Coalhouse Walker Jr. in Ragtime, Mitchell brings a depth of emotion and sincerity to his roles that resonate long after the final curtain falls.
What sets Mitchell apart is his remarkable ability to infuse his performances with both warmth and authority. His baritone voice is capable of both tender moments and grand, dramatic power, creating an emotional depth that elevates every show he’s in. His skill in interpreting both classic and contemporary musical theater pieces allows him to bring a fresh perspective to each role he plays, making his performances feel both timeless and relevant.
Beyond his exceptional vocal talent, Mitchell is also known for his commitment to advocacy and mentorship within the theater community. He has worked tirelessly to inspire and support the next generation of performers, helping to shape the future of Broadway while continuing to thrill audiences with his own work. Brian Stokes Mitchell’s legacy as a performer, mentor, and advocate will continue to influence musical theater for years to come, ensuring that his powerful voice and enduring spirit remain a key part of Broadway’s legacy.
9. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a true legend of Broadway, whose trailblazing performances in West Side Story and Chicago have earned her a permanent place in theater history. Known for her electrifying stage presence and unmatched dance ability, Rivera is one of the few performers whose name is synonymous with Broadway excellence. Her portrayal of Anita in West Side Story became iconic, and her later work as Velma Kelly in Chicago solidified her status as a Broadway superstar. Rivera’s performances are marked by their high energy, charisma, and dedication to storytelling, making her one of the most beloved figures in the theater world.
Rivera’s voice, while not as classical or operatic as some of her contemporaries, is filled with charm, personality, and emotional depth. Her performances are defined by her ability to fully embody the character she’s playing, whether singing or dancing, drawing audiences in with every movement. She is a master at conveying the essence of a character through both song and choreography, bringing a unique and dynamic energy to each role.
As a trailblazer, Rivera broke barriers for women in musical theater and continues to inspire new generations of performers. Her legacy as a groundbreaking talent is not only defined by her performances but by her resilience and determination to push the boundaries of what is possible in the theater. Chita Rivera’s influence on Broadway will continue to be felt for generations to come, and her contributions to musical theater are nothing short of extraordinary.
10. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s voice is a gift to the world of musical theater. Widely celebrated for her role as Kim in Miss Saigon, Salonga’s incredible vocal range and emotional depth have made her a global star. Her voice, clear and bright, has the ability to evoke a wide range of emotions, from heart-wrenching sadness to triumphant joy. Salonga’s portrayal of Kim, a young woman caught in the turmoil of war, was nothing short of mesmerizing, earning her an Olivier Award and a Tony Award. Her performance, paired with her flawless vocal technique, solidified her status as one of the most respected voices in musical theater.
Salonga’s ability to convey raw emotion through song is unmatched. Whether she is performing a ballad or an upbeat number, her voice is capable of capturing the essence of the character, making every performance feel intimate and authentic. She has since starred in numerous productions, including Les Misérables, Allegiance, and Cats, each time bringing her unique voice and emotional intelligence to the stage.
In addition to her work in musical theater, Salonga’s influence extends beyond Broadway. She has earned international recognition for her performances in film and television and has become a mentor to aspiring singers and actors. Her contributions to musical theater, paired with her unwavering dedication to her craft, have earned her a place among the greatest talents of her generation. Lea Salonga’s legacy will continue to inspire future performers to pursue their passions with the same integrity and dedication she has shown throughout her remarkable career.
11. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is widely considered the quintessential Broadway star, a legend whose larger-than-life voice and powerful stage presence defined the golden age of musical theater. Known for her no-holds-barred vocal style and boundless energy, Merman’s performances in shows like Annie Get Your Gun and Anything Goes became landmarks in Broadway history. With her unmistakable voice, Merman could belt out a song with such force and clarity that it seemed to fill every corner of the theater, captivating audiences with her unrivaled vocal power.
Merman’s voice was a true marvel of the musical theater world. She had the rare ability to project with ease and grace, carrying the melodies of the era’s biggest songs without the need for microphones. Her work in Annie Get Your Gun, particularly with the classic hit “There’s No Business Like Show Business,” became iconic, and her presence on stage was equally commanding. Audiences were drawn to her unwavering energy and bold, charismatic character portrayals. Merman’s voice was unmistakable—a unique combination of clarity, strength, and style that never failed to ignite excitement.
In addition to her remarkable voice, Merman’s ability to create unforgettable characters was another hallmark of her career. Whether playing a brash, confident sharpshooter in Annie Get Your Gun or a showgirl in Anything Goes, she could bring her characters to life with passion, humor, and wit. Her legacy as the “First Lady of the American Musical” remains unmatched, and her influence continues to inspire generations of theater performers. Merman’s contributions to Broadway are timeless, and her name will forever be synonymous with the golden age of musical theater.
12. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury’s career spanned over seven decades, and she remains one of Broadway’s most versatile and beloved stars. Best known for her role as Mame in Mame and her Tony-winning performance as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, Lansbury’s remarkable talent encompassed both dramatic and comedic roles, solidifying her status as one of the theater’s most enduring figures. Throughout her career, she effortlessly transitioned between stage and screen, winning over audiences with her distinctive voice, impeccable timing, and remarkable ability to embody complex, multifaceted characters.
Lansbury’s stage presence was captivating. In Sweeney Todd, her portrayal of the scheming, yet lovable Mrs. Lovett was one of her most iconic performances, blending dark comedy with a poignant emotional depth. Her ability to move seamlessly between musical genres, from the lighthearted and zany Mame to the dark and twisted Sweeney Todd, showcased her unmatched versatility as an actress and singer. She earned five Tony Awards over the course of her career, and her performances remain some of the most memorable in Broadway history.
In addition to her Broadway success, Lansbury’s enduring legacy also extends to her work in film and television, most notably as the star of the long-running series Murder, She Wrote. Whether on stage or screen, her dedication to her craft and her ability to connect with audiences through her performances have made her a beloved figure in the entertainment world. Angela Lansbury’s influence on Broadway is immense, and her career will continue to inspire future generations of performers.
13. Norm Lewis
Norm Lewis is a groundbreaking figure in Broadway history, recognized not only for his extraordinary vocal talent but for his trailblazing role as the first Black actor to play The Phantom in The Phantom of the Opera. With his rich, resonant baritone voice and commanding stage presence, Lewis has become one of Broadway’s most celebrated leading men. His performances in shows such as Porgy and Bess, Les Misérables, and The Gershwin’s Porgy and Bess have earned him widespread acclaim, cementing his place as a true Broadway star.
Lewis’s vocal prowess is both powerful and expressive. He is known for his ability to sing with authority and grace, delivering each performance with passion and emotional depth. In The Phantom of the Opera, his portrayal of the mysterious, tortured character was a revelation, bringing a fresh perspective to the iconic role. His interpretation of The Phantom was both haunting and heartfelt, and his ability to convey the character’s deep vulnerability through his powerful voice added a layer of complexity that resonated with audiences.
Beyond his acting and singing, Lewis has used his platform to advocate for greater diversity and inclusion within the theater world. His groundbreaking achievements have paved the way for future generations of Black actors on Broadway, and his influence continues to be felt throughout the industry. Norm Lewis’s career is a testament to the power of perseverance, talent, and the ability to break down barriers, making him an inspiring figure in the world of musical theater.
14. Jennifer Holliday
Jennifer Holliday’s voice is a force of nature, and her performance as Effie White in Dreamgirls remains one of the most iconic and memorable in Broadway history. Holliday’s powerhouse vocals, filled with raw emotion and immense power, have made her a beloved figure in musical theater. Her rendition of the song “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” is legendary, a performance so emotionally charged that it has become one of the defining moments in Broadway history.
Holliday’s vocal range and control are unmatched, and her ability to convey deep, unfiltered emotion through her singing is what makes her performances so impactful. In Dreamgirls, she portrayed a character who experiences heartbreak, betrayal, and redemption, and Holliday’s powerful delivery of Effie’s most emotional numbers became the hallmark of her performance. Her ability to bring these moments to life with such raw emotion is what sets her apart from other performers, and her legacy as a leading lady in musical theater is secure.
In addition to her incredible talent on stage, Holliday’s career has included a successful recording career and a continued presence in the theater world. She has performed in numerous productions, including Chicago, and has continued to inspire new generations of performers with her passion and dedication to her craft. Jennifer Holliday’s influence on musical theater is undeniable, and her work remains an inspiration for both established and up-and-coming artists in the industry.
15. Sara Bareilles
Sara Bareilles made an unforgettable impact on Broadway with her musical Waitress, which she both wrote and starred in. Known for her soulful voice and songwriting abilities, Bareilles’s transition from pop star to Broadway sensation showcased her extraordinary talent in a new light. Her work on Waitress brought a fresh and modern sound to the stage, blending her signature style with the storytelling traditions of musical theater. Her work earned her multiple Tony Award nominations and a place as one of the most exciting new voices on Broadway.
Bareilles’s voice is uniquely expressive, with a warmth and vulnerability that resonates deeply with audiences. In Waitress, she portrayed Jenna, a waitress and aspiring baker caught in an unhappy marriage. Bareilles brought depth and heart to the character, capturing the emotional struggles and triumphs of Jenna with honesty and grace. Her music for Waitress is filled with poignant lyrics that echo the themes of love, loss, and self-discovery, and the show’s songs, such as “She Used to Be Mine,” have become anthems of empowerment for audiences.
Bareilles’s influence extends beyond Waitress, as she has continued to bring her unique voice and songwriting talents to both stage and studio. Her success on Broadway represents a new wave of pop artists making their mark in the theater world, and her ability to bridge the gap between these genres is a testament to her exceptional talent. Sara Bareilles has proven herself to be not only an outstanding performer but also a trailblazer for future generations of artists looking to merge pop music with the world of Broadway.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
