Broadway has long been the beating heart of musical theater, a place where dreams are brought to life and stories are told through the power of song. It takes a special kind of talent to command the spotlight on Broadway’s grand stages—voices that not only capture the soaring highs and heartbreaking lows of a character but also leave audiences spellbound night after night. Over the decades, many have graced these stages, but only a select few have become true legends, transcending the footlights to become icons of musical theater.
In this article, we’re celebrating the crème de la crème—the top 15 best Broadway singers of all time. From the golden age of Broadway to modern masterpieces, these vocalists have redefined what it means to be a star on the Great White Way. Whether belting out show-stopping numbers or delivering delicate, emotional ballads, each of these performers has left an indelible mark on theater history. So, get ready to dive deep into the magic of Broadway as we count down the voices that have shaped generations of theater lovers and created unforgettable moments on stage. Let the curtain rise on our list of Broadway’s brightest stars!
1. Ethel Merman
Ethel Merman is a name forever etched in the history of Broadway, and her larger-than-life presence is the stuff of legends. With a voice that could fill the largest theaters without the need for a microphone, Merman became the ultimate Broadway diva. Her brassy, vibrant, and unwavering tone made her the go-to performer for the bombastic and bold roles of her time. Shows like Gypsy and Anything Goes became synonymous with her powerful, commanding voice. What set Merman apart was her ability to project raw energy into every performance. She didn’t just sing the notes; she inhabited her roles, transforming each character into a force to be reckoned with. Her vocal technique was flawless, and her diction was so clear that every word she sang resonated with the audience. Her signature belt became a model for generations of singers, and her performances set a new standard for what Broadway singing could be. Merman wasn’t just about the big, show-stopping numbers, though. Even in the quieter moments, she could convey deep emotional depth with her voice. She was a true force of nature, and her impact on Broadway is immeasurable. To this day, her voice serves as an inspiration to musical theater performers who seek to match her vocal power and stage presence. Ethel Merman’s legacy is alive in every belted note that fills a Broadway theater, reminding us of the joy, strength, and passion that live theater can bring.
2. Julie Andrews
Before becoming a cinematic icon in The Sound of Music and Mary Poppins, Julie Andrews was already dazzling audiences on Broadway with her remarkable vocal abilities and elegance. Andrews’ voice is often described as pure and crystalline, with a sweetness that immediately captivates listeners. She brought a certain grace and poise to her Broadway roles, particularly in productions like My Fair Lady and Camelot, where her voice seemed to float effortlessly through the most intricate vocal lines. Andrews’ vocal precision was matched only by her emotional depth. She could go from belting out a powerful anthem to delivering a tender, nuanced ballad with such ease that it seemed as though her voice was simply an extension of her heart. Her portrayal of Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady set a standard for how a leading lady could combine vocal technique with emotional storytelling. Even decades later, her influence on musical theater is undeniable. Andrews paved the way for a generation of performers who sought to blend beauty and skill in their voices. Her vocal range, control, and emotional resonance continue to inspire not just singers, but also actors, directors, and audiences. Julie Andrews’ legacy is one of timeless elegance, and her voice remains a touchstone for excellence in musical theater.
3. Audra McDonald
Audra McDonald is a true Broadway powerhouse, one of the most celebrated and versatile voices to ever grace the stage. With six Tony Awards to her name, McDonald’s voice blends technical brilliance with emotional depth, making every performance an unforgettable experience. She has an innate ability to express vulnerability, strength, joy, and sorrow all with equal intensity, and her vocal range knows no limits. McDonald’s roles in productions such as Ragtime, Porgy and Bess, and Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill showcase her incredible talent to the fullest. Whether she’s soaring through a classical aria or singing a jazz standard, her voice effortlessly transitions between genres, making her a true chameleon of the stage. But it’s not just her technical skill that sets her apart—Audra McDonald has an emotional honesty in her performances that few others can match. She taps into the very soul of a character, bringing a depth that resonates with her audience. Her rendition of “Summertime” from Porgy and Bess or her powerful portrayal of Billie Holiday in Lady Day are just a few examples of how McDonald can transform a song into something far greater than the sum of its notes. Her legacy is one of excellence, artistry, and a profound ability to connect with her audience on a deep emotional level. Audra McDonald is a singer whose influence on Broadway and beyond will continue for generations to come.
4. Patti LuPone
Patti LuPone is the very definition of a Broadway diva, renowned for her powerful vocals and commanding stage presence. With a career spanning decades, she has captivated audiences with her performances in iconic musicals like Evita, Gypsy, and Sweeney Todd. LuPone’s voice is striking—bold, commanding, and capable of tremendous emotional range. She’s not just a singer; she’s a storyteller. When she takes the stage, there’s no question who the star of the show is. Her portrayal of Eva Perón in Evita remains one of her most defining roles, with her rendition of “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina” becoming a moment of pure theatrical magic. Whether she’s belting out a powerful anthem or diving deep into a character’s emotional turmoil, LuPone’s vocal delivery is always impeccable. Her voice can soar with the highest notes and then drop to a hushed, intimate whisper that draws the audience in. LuPone’s fearlessness in her performances—whether she’s playing a tragic heroine or a fierce antagonist—has made her one of the most respected figures in musical theater. It’s not just her vocal power that has made her a Broadway icon, but her ability to immerse herself in each role with a rare intensity and authenticity. Patti LuPone is the epitome of Broadway’s thrilling, larger-than-life energy, and her impact on the stage will be felt for years to come.
5. Bernadette Peters
Bernadette Peters is one of Broadway’s most beloved stars, known for her exceptional vocal ability and distinctive stage presence. With her curly red hair and undeniable charm, Peters has captured the hearts of audiences with her performances in Stephen Sondheim musicals like Into the Woods and Sunday in the Park with George. What sets Peters apart from many of her peers is her ability to bring a sense of emotional vulnerability to every role she takes on. She can take a seemingly lighthearted number and imbue it with such depth that it resonates far beyond its initial surface. Her performances often feel like an intimate conversation, drawing the audience in with every note she sings. Peters’ vocal style is unique; she has a gift for singing with effortless grace, seamlessly transitioning between registers and creating a smooth, lyrical sound. Whether she’s singing a heart-wrenching ballad or delivering a comedic moment, Peters can effortlessly switch gears, showcasing her range as both a vocalist and an actress. Her portrayal of the witch in Into the Woods is one of her most memorable, where she brought a rare emotional complexity to the role. Peters’ voice has an enchanting quality, and it is her ability to blend humor, heartbreak, and vocal precision that makes her one of Broadway’s most enduring stars. She continues to captivate audiences with her timeless talent, making her an iconic figure in the world of musical theater.
6. Sutton Foster
Sutton Foster is a true force in modern Broadway, known for her magnetic presence, incredible vocal chops, and energetic performances. As a triple threat, Foster has the rare ability to seamlessly combine acting, singing, and dancing, and her roles in shows like Thoroughly Modern Millie, Anything Goes, and The Drowsy Chaperone have cemented her place as one of the most beloved performers of her generation. Foster’s voice is bright, clear, and full of life, with a crispness that makes every note seem effortless. Whether she’s singing a playful tune like “Gimme, Gimme” or delivering a heartfelt ballad, Foster brings an infectious energy to her performances. Her stage presence is undeniable; she can light up the entire theater with just a glance or a smile. It’s not just her vocal ability that makes her stand out—it’s her commitment to making every performance feel fresh and exciting. Her portrayal of Millie Dillmount in Thoroughly Modern Millie was a perfect showcase for her infectious charm, while her role as Reno Sweeney in Anything Goes proved that she’s just as adept at handling more sophisticated roles. Foster’s versatility is one of the reasons she’s so beloved by Broadway fans. She’s able to take on a range of characters, from the bubbly ingénue to the more complex leading lady, and bring something special to each one. Sutton Foster’s enthusiasm and passion for her craft have made her one of Broadway’s brightest stars, and there’s no telling where her remarkable career will take her next.
7. Angela Lansbury
Angela Lansbury’s name is synonymous with classic Broadway performances, though many also know her for her work in television, particularly Murder, She Wrote. However, her stage career is just as impressive, with her powerful presence and remarkable versatility earning her a lasting place in theater history. Lansbury’s voice was both gentle and commanding, able to effortlessly convey sweetness or power depending on the role. Her performances in shows like Mame, Sweeney Todd, and Gypsy left audiences in awe, proving that she was not just a leading lady, but a true character actress with an ability to transform before our eyes. Lansbury’s portrayal of the indomitable Mame Dennis in Mame was one of her most iconic roles, bringing to life a character brimming with optimism, charm, and strength. Her role as Mrs. Lovett in Sweeney Todd showcased her darker, more comedic side, displaying an entirely different side of her talent. Lansbury’s mastery was in her ability to bring nuance to each role, inhabiting her characters with a deep emotional understanding that made her performances feel entirely authentic. Her voice may not have been the strongest in terms of sheer power, but it was filled with warmth and richness that drew audiences in. Her performances were a perfect blend of technique and heart, making her one of the most beloved figures in Broadway history. Angela Lansbury’s legacy as one of the greats of musical theater is firmly established, and her ability to command the stage with both subtlety and grandeur remains unmatched.
8. Idina Menzel
Idina Menzel’s voice has become one of the most recognizable in Broadway history, and she is the embodiment of the modern Broadway star. Known for her powerhouse belting and emotional depth, Menzel first captured the public’s attention with her role as Maureen in Rent, but it was her portrayal of Elphaba in Wicked that cemented her place as a Broadway icon. Menzel’s performance of “Defying Gravity” has become one of the most iconic moments in musical theater, with her soaring high notes and raw emotional power resonating with audiences long after the show has ended. Her voice is both powerful and haunting, with a mix of rawness and refinement that makes it truly unique. Menzel has a remarkable ability to sing with vulnerability, allowing the emotions of a character to seep into her voice. Whether it’s the defiance of Elphaba or the determination of Elsa in Frozen, Menzel’s performances are marked by a deep commitment to the characters she portrays. Her vocal ability has been recognized with numerous awards and accolades, but it’s her ability to connect with her audience that truly sets her apart. Menzel’s voice has a rawness that few can match, and it’s that emotional intensity that elevates every performance she gives. From her stage career to her film work, Idina Menzel has left an indelible mark on Broadway, and her influence on the industry is sure to be felt for many years to come.
9. Chita Rivera
Chita Rivera is a Broadway legend whose contributions to musical theater are immeasurable. Known for her high-energy performances, dynamic dancing, and commanding presence, Rivera has become a symbol of Broadway excellence. Her career has spanned decades, and she is best remembered for her work in West Side Story, Chicago, and Kiss of the Spider Woman. Rivera was one of the original cast members of West Side Story, where she created the role of Anita, delivering a performance that became iconic for its fiery passion and emotional depth. But it was in Chicago where Rivera truly became a Broadway legend, playing Velma Kelly with a sassy, seductive energy that practically oozed from the stage. Her ability to dance, sing, and act with such precision and power has made her one of Broadway’s greatest all-around performers. What sets Rivera apart is her ability to fuse her talents—her impeccable voice, flawless dancing, and magnetic stage presence—into a single captivating performance. She’s a true Broadway triple threat, able to command attention in every scene she’s in. Rivera’s influence on the world of musical theater cannot be overstated. Her performances set a standard for what it means to be a fully realized, multi-talented performer on the Broadway stage. Even today, Chita Rivera’s impact on the Broadway community is felt deeply, and her career remains a shining example of the heights a performer can reach when they have both the talent and the drive to leave a lasting legacy.
10. Elaine Stritch
Elaine Stritch was a Broadway original, a performer whose bold personality and unforgettable voice made her a fixture of the New York theater scene for decades. Stritch’s voice was unmistakable: gravelly, brassy, and rich with emotion. She was known for her no-nonsense attitude and her ability to command attention whenever she was on stage. One of Stritch’s most iconic performances came in Company, where she brought to life the character of Martha in a rendition of “The Ladies Who Lunch” that has gone down in history as one of Broadway’s most memorable moments. Stritch’s ability to combine humor, vulnerability, and sarcasm in her performances made her a standout in any role she took on. She could make an audience laugh and cry in the same breath, a rare and invaluable gift. Stritch’s unique voice and style were a perfect match for the roles she chose, and her performances were filled with an authenticity that was both refreshing and rare. She was a master at using her voice to convey raw emotion, often imbuing her characters with a depth that was both touching and powerful. Elaine Stritch’s performances were an expression of her own larger-than-life personality, and her influence on the Broadway community is still felt today. She was a performer who could break down the barrier between the stage and the audience, creating a connection that was deep, personal, and unforgettable. Elaine Stritch may have left us, but her voice and her legacy will live on in the history of Broadway.
11. Mandy Patinkin
Mandy Patinkin is one of Broadway’s most respected and celebrated performers, known for his extraordinary vocal talent and emotional depth. His voice is an incredible instrument, capable of seamlessly transitioning from moments of booming power to delicate tenderness. Patinkin’s career is marked by his ability to bring an immense emotional range to his performances. Whether he’s belting out a powerful anthem or singing a delicate ballad, his ability to connect with his audience is unparalleled. He first captivated Broadway audiences with his performance as Che in Evita, where his vocal delivery was both impassioned and rich with nuance. But it was his role in Sunday in the Park with George that truly showcased Patinkin’s rare ability to convey vulnerability and depth through song. His voice has a unique quality—it is both strong and delicate, capable of great power yet equally adept at conveying moments of quiet introspection. Patinkin’s performances always feel deeply personal, as if he’s telling the audience a secret. His passion for storytelling through music is one of the reasons why his performances resonate so deeply. Every note he sings seems to carry weight, and every word he speaks feels sincere. His role as George in Sunday in the Park with George or his turn as the grandfather in The Secret Garden are prime examples of his ability to bring emotional layers to every character he portrays. Mandy Patinkin’s voice is a gift, and his contributions to Broadway are invaluable. His career remains a testament to the power of vulnerability, storytelling, and the artistry of musical theater.
12. Kristin Chenoweth
Kristin Chenoweth is a Broadway sensation whose infectious energy and extraordinary vocal range have made her a star both on and off the stage. Known for her role as Glinda in Wicked, Chenoweth quickly became a beloved figure in musical theater, charming audiences with her sparkling personality and high-flying soprano. What makes Chenoweth stand out is not just her incredible vocal range, which spans from impossibly high notes to deeper, more resonant tones, but also her remarkable comedic timing and stage presence. Whether she’s playing a bubbly, optimistic character or tackling a more serious role, Chenoweth brings an undeniable charm and warmth to everything she does. Her voice is sweet and pure, capable of hitting notes that seem to defy physics, and yet she can also sing with depth and sincerity when the moment calls for it. Chenoweth’s performance as Glinda in Wicked is a perfect example of how she can combine vocal prowess with impeccable comedic timing. She’s able to deliver a lighthearted, comedic performance while also showing the emotional growth of her character. Chenoweth has also proven her versatility in roles like You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown, where her natural sweetness and humor shone through. Whether belting out a showstopping number or delivering a tender ballad, Kristin Chenoweth’s performances are always captivating, and her remarkable vocal abilities and joyful energy continue to make her one of Broadway’s brightest stars.
13. Brian Stokes Mitchell
Brian Stokes Mitchell is a towering figure in the Broadway world, known for his deep, rich baritone voice that commands attention in every role he undertakes. A veteran of the stage, Mitchell has delivered show-stopping performances in classics like Ragtime, Kiss Me, Kate, and Man of La Mancha. His voice is one of the most powerful in Broadway history, capable of filling a theater with effortless strength while still conveying deep emotion. Mitchell’s vocal control is exceptional—he can move seamlessly between soaring high notes and commanding low registers, each note full of resonance and clarity. It’s this mastery of technique combined with his emotional depth that makes his performances so compelling. In Ragtime, Mitchell’s portrayal of Coalhouse Walker Jr. was a revelation, with his powerful voice and emotional intensity capturing the pain and defiance of the character. His performance in Kiss Me, Kate was equally impressive, as he brought charm and sophistication to the role of Fred Graham, effortlessly delivering both the comedic and dramatic elements of the character. What makes Mitchell stand out is his ability to infuse his performances with an undeniable warmth, drawing the audience in and making them feel the emotions of his character. His stage presence is magnetic, and whether he’s singing a heart-wrenching ballad or belting out an anthem, Mitchell’s performances never fail to leave an impact. As one of Broadway’s finest leading men, Brian Stokes Mitchell continues to be a force to be reckoned with, delivering powerful, nuanced performances that have become the gold standard in musical theater.
14. Lea Salonga
Lea Salonga’s voice is a beacon of clarity and power in the world of musical theater. Her rise to fame came through her Tony Award-winning performance as Kim in Miss Saigon, a role that showcased not only her vocal precision but also her emotional depth. Salonga’s voice is one of the purest in Broadway history—clear and resonant, capable of carrying both power and emotion in every note. Her ability to convey vulnerability through her voice is extraordinary, allowing her to connect with her audience in a deeply personal way. Salonga’s performance as Eponine in Les Misérables is a prime example of her vocal mastery, as she poured her heart into the character’s emotional journey, particularly in the iconic song “On My Own.” Salonga’s voice is often described as having a crystal-clear tone, and her ability to maintain impeccable control over her vocal range has made her one of the most respected performers in musical theater. Whether performing on Broadway or in concert halls around the world, Salonga’s voice remains a source of inspiration to aspiring singers and theatergoers alike. In addition to her stage work, Salonga’s career has extended beyond Broadway into film, television, and international concert stages, proving her versatility and global appeal. Her contributions to musical theater have left an indelible mark, and her ability to convey the emotional core of her characters through song makes her performances timeless. Lea Salonga continues to captivate audiences worldwide with her stunning voice and unwavering dedication to her craft.
15. Carol Channing
Carol Channing was one of Broadway’s most distinctive voices and personalities, known for her unmistakable rasp and her ability to light up a stage with her vibrant energy. Channing’s career spanned decades, and she remains best known for her portrayal of Dolly Levi in Hello, Dolly!, a role she made her own and performed hundreds of times during her career. Her voice, full of character and charm, was perfectly suited to the role of the irrepressible matchmaker, Dolly, and her comedic timing and larger-than-life stage presence made her one of the most beloved figures in musical theater history. Channing’s voice had a unique quality—raspy, yet full of warmth and humor—that made her instantly recognizable. It was a voice that conveyed both strength and vulnerability, often filled with infectious enthusiasm. Her performances were always captivating, and she had the rare ability to connect with audiences through both her voice and her comedic sensibilities. Channing’s portrayal of Dolly Levi is one of Broadway’s most iconic performances, and her time in the role has become a part of musical theater lore. But Channing’s talents weren’t confined to Hello, Dolly!—she also starred in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, where she brought her comedic genius to the role of Lorelei Lee. Over the years, Channing’s influence on the theater world only grew, and her distinct voice and playful charm remained central to her performances. Carol Channing’s contributions to Broadway are legendary, and her ability to bring both humor and heart to every role made her a true Broadway icon.
Edward Tomlin is a frequent contributor to Singers Room. Since 2005, Singersroom has been the voice of R&B around the world. Connect with us via social media below.
